M69: Trapped in the Chipotle R&D Lab [HIDDEN]

[snowy801]

I think Macca should challenge rdrivera

Hold your fucking horsies nobody should be challenging anyone.
I do think rdrivera is very sus though

Why not?

viewtopic.php?p=250304#p250304

Sometimes I wonder why I even bother

[BobMcBob]

I think Macca should challenge rdrivera

Hold your fucking horsies nobody should be challenging anyone.
I do think rdrivera is very sus though

Why not?

free flowing wagons, waiting for more important info to come forward, all that stuff
maybe we can do it later but now is not a good time

[Jamiet99uk]

Hold your fucking horsies nobody should be challenging anyone.
I do think rdrivera is very sus though

Why not?

He has to trigger the challenge in the first 24 hrs of the phase.

There isn't much "later" left if he wants to do that, about 5 hours?
free flowing wagons, waiting for more important info to come forward, all that stuff
maybe we can do it later but now is not a good time

[Jamiet99uk]

Whoops bad quoting sorry

[Jamiet99uk]

I meant:

He has to trigger the challenge in the first 24hrs of the phase.

There isn't much "later" left if he wants to do that.

[rdrivera2005]

Once again, I need the cop to claim now. You are throwing the game if you don't.

Seconded

I am probably the dumbest player around, but why?

[snowy801]

Looking at the item description again, it does not appear that the spinach has to be triggered in the first 24 hours. Correct me if I'm wrong

[Jamiet99uk]

Looking at the item description again, it does not appear that the spinach has to be triggered in the first 24 hours. Correct me if I'm wrong

Oh sorry. Gladiator challenges normally work like that though.

[snowy801]

Once again, I need the cop to claim now. You are throwing the game if you don't.

Seconded

I am probably the dumbest player around, but why?

4 possible roleblocks, 3 accounted for (ghug, damo, me) all presumed not to be cop -> cop (probably) has got off 2 scans = cop reveals answer, gives away item so it doesn't get easily stolen today

[Jamiet99uk]

##CALL GM
Can the spinach challenge be triggered at any point in the phase?

[rdrivera2005]

I think Macca should challenge rdrivera

Please don't.

[rdrivera2005]

Seconded

I am probably the dumbest player around, but why?

4 possible roleblocks, 3 accounted for (ghug, damo, me) all presumed not to be cop -> cop (probably) has got off 2 scans = cop reveals answer, gives away item so it doesn't get easily stolen today

This if you think the Guac owner isn't an unlucky useless player.

[snowy801]

I am probably the dumbest player around, but why?

4 possible roleblocks, 3 accounted for (ghug, damo, me) all presumed not to be cop -> cop (probably) has got off 2 scans = cop reveals answer, gives away item so it doesn't get easily stolen today

This if you think the Guac owner isn't an unlucky useless player.

Even if cop got roleblocked once, come out, give your item away

[Chaqa]

##CALL GM
Can the spinach challenge be triggered at any point in the phase?

##GM note:
I’m going to rule that spinach must be used in the first 24 hours. This wasn’t explicit but logically flows with other items, as well as to prevent an un-fun game state if a gladiator challenge is ever used in the last few minutes of the phase.

[Jamiet99uk]

I am trying to imagine a scenario in which all of these things could be true:

1. Bozo is telling the truth about the napkin message
2. Scum sent him that message
3. Scum also killed Ghug using the steak.
4. Bozo is not scum.

The only scenario I can think of is if the scum planned to frame Ghug using the napkin and get him miskilled, but because their night kill failed, the person with the steak got jumpy and departed from that plan because they fear Ghug so much.

Just shooting Ghug would feel like an attempt to frame me. But that doesn't explain the napkin message.

[snowy801]

I am trying to imagine a scenario in which all of these things could be true:

1. Bozo is telling the truth about the napkin message
2. Scum sent him that message
3. Scum also killed Ghug using the steak.
4. Bozo is not scum.

The only scenario I can think of is if the scum planned to frame Ghug using the napkin and get him miskilled, but because their night kill failed, the person with the steak got jumpy and departed from that plan because they fear Ghug so much.

Just shooting Ghug would feel like an attempt to frame me. But that doesn't explain the napkin message.

Why would bozo even mention the napkin in the first place if he's scum? I'd just shut up about it in that case, I think

Also I don't know why anyone would fear ghug that much unless they thought he was the cop or something

[Hamilton Brian]

I think it’d be a very easy conclusion to make (to frame you) given the animosity. Which is why I don’t think it would stand up.

[rdrivera2005]

4 possible roleblocks, 3 accounted for (ghug, damo, me) all presumed not to be cop -> cop (probably) has got off 2 scans = cop reveals answer, gives away item so it doesn't get easily stolen today

This if you think the Guac owner isn't an unlucky useless player.

Even if cop got roleblocked once, come out, give your item away

The question is give to whom? How you can be safe that you are not giving to scum or 3P.

Also, why 3P would steal Guac? He is immune and it's not in his list.

[snowy801]

This if you think the Guac owner isn't an unlucky useless player.

Even if cop got roleblocked once, come out, give your item away

The question is give to whom? How you can be safe that you are not giving to scum or 3P.

Also, why 3P would steal Guac? He is immune and it's not in his list.

Just pick one.
Not 3P per se, mafia will probably shoot cop to deny guak usage

[damo666]

Why are 3 people voting an rb claimant?