M69: Trapped in the Chipotle R&D Lab [HIDDEN]

[bozotheclown]

How does catching the 3P advantage town? Game rule states nothing about town losing when 3P wins, so far as I could tell.

If I missed something, please elaborate on how mass claims helps us catch 3P, as I am stupid and do not understand.

If the town does not lose if the 3P wins, there is less risk in the town mass claiming items, but the town needs to eliminate the 3P to win.

Mass claiming items helps catch the 3P because there are only 10 items the 3P can be holding.

why would we want to claim items

There are 6 items the mafia can't start with. The advantages of claiming early are narrowing the scum pool and preventing mafia from making fake claims later. There are also obvious disadvantages.

[snowy801]

I changed my mind, I think it would be advantageous for town to mass claim items, because I think we would have a high probability of catching the 3P before he gets his required items. However, I am confident that it would be impossible to get a consensus on this.

How does catching the 3P advantage town? Game rule states nothing about town losing when 3P wins, so far as I could tell.

If I missed something, please elaborate on how mass claims helps us catch 3P, as I am stupid and do not understand.

If the town does not lose if the 3P wins, there is less risk in the town mass claiming items, but the town needs to eliminate the 3P to win.

Mass claiming items helps catch the 3P because there are only 10 items the 3P can be holding.

Knowing that town does not lose with 3P win (as far as I can tell), would you still say you are still in advocacy of revealing every item town has for the marginal gain of eliminating a handful of players from the 3P pool?

[bozotheclown]

How does catching the 3P advantage town? Game rule states nothing about town losing when 3P wins, so far as I could tell.

If I missed something, please elaborate on how mass claims helps us catch 3P, as I am stupid and do not understand.

If the town does not lose if the 3P wins, there is less risk in the town mass claiming items, but the town needs to eliminate the 3P to win.

Mass claiming items helps catch the 3P because there are only 10 items the 3P can be holding.

Knowing that town does not lose with 3P win (as far as I can tell), would you still say you are still in advocacy of revealing every item town has for the marginal gain of eliminating a handful of players from the 3P pool?

Not for that reason, but the mafia can only hold 11 of the 17 items, so it eliminates 6 players from the mafia pool and prevents a mafia from surviving the DK at EOD by claiming one of these 6 items.

[Bonatogether]

If the town does not lose if the 3P wins, there is less risk in the town mass claiming items, but the town needs to eliminate the 3P to win.

Mass claiming items helps catch the 3P because there are only 10 items the 3P can be holding.

Knowing that town does not lose with 3P win (as far as I can tell), would you still say you are still in advocacy of revealing every item town has for the marginal gain of eliminating a handful of players from the 3P pool?

Not for that reason, but the mafia can only hold 11 of the 17 items, so it eliminates 6 players from the mafia pool and prevents a mafia from surviving the DK at EOD by claiming one of these 6 items.

1) lessening the POE might be useful if items aren't revealed on flip. we could try to get people to claim items 5 minutes before EoD if they're on the block

2) ever heard of a counterclaim

[bozotheclown]

Knowing that town does not lose with 3P win (as far as I can tell), would you still say you are still in advocacy of revealing every item town has for the marginal gain of eliminating a handful of players from the 3P pool?

Not for that reason, but the mafia can only hold 11 of the 17 items, so it eliminates 6 players from the mafia pool and prevents a mafia from surviving the DK at EOD by claiming one of these 6 items.

1) lessening the POE might be useful if items aren't revealed on flip. we could try to get people to claim items 5 minutes before EoD if they're on the block

2) ever heard of a counterclaim

I assume the items are not revealed because they stay in the game.

Forcing everyone to claim their item early eliminates the risk of counterclaims, unless the mafia want to counterclaim town on D1.

[Bonatogether]

Not for that reason, but the mafia can only hold 11 of the 17 items, so it eliminates 6 players from the mafia pool and prevents a mafia from surviving the DK at EOD by claiming one of these 6 items.

1) lessening the POE might be useful if items aren't revealed on flip. we could try to get people to claim items 5 minutes before EoD if they're on the block

2) ever heard of a counterclaim

I assume the items are not revealed because they stay in the game.

Forcing everyone to claim their item early eliminates the risk of counterclaims, unless the mafia want to counterclaim town on D1.

@gm are any items held on flip revealed?

forcing everyone to claim their item gives scum all that info to choose kills off of.

[Hamilton Brian]

Man, I am just not feeling it right now. No offense to ya'll. This'll probably be my last mafia game until whatever we might get for a winter break. So...I have really just skimmed the thread. Not picking up much out of the ordinary Day 1 features. I think once I get my document started and check stuff out of the bot tonight/tomorrow, I'll be in a better frame of mind.

THought I would end this post with a relevant joke.

I ran to a Chipotle today.

[Hamilton Brian]

That wasn't the only running I did!


Ba dum dum!

[Hamilton Brian]

Just on the outset feeling good about snowy, bozo, bona.

Just very gut and peripheral given how much time I've take to read. Don't expect a great elaboration as to why.

[Bonatogether]

Just on the outset feeling good about snowy, bozo, bona.

Just very gut and peripheral given how much time I've take to read. Don't expect a great elaboration as to why.

ty, very cool

[foodcoats]

I’m lost

Bona who are you voting

[Bonatogether]

I’m lost

Bona who are you voting

ghug

[foodcoats]

Actually I’ll sheep snowy instead

##VOTE Vecna

Baah baah

[lfischl]

u-uwu?

##vote snowy

Why?

[Bonatogether]

Actually I’ll sheep snowy instead

##VOTE Vecna

Baah baah

why not me?

[foodcoats]

Actually I’ll sheep snowy instead

##VOTE Vecna

Baah baah

why not me?

Ghug wagon is too big

[TheMadMonarch]

Alrighty, Mafia time!

Firstly,
The last of my assessments are due this week, so expect lower activity, but it should go up.

Secondly,

[TheMadMonarch]

Alrighty, Mafia time!

Firstly,
The last of my assessments are due this week, so expect lower activity, but it should go up.

Secondly,

oops... continue

That bozo-snowy interaction, very sus (not for bozo). ##vote snowy


I actually like bozo's idea, but I'll wait for a little more support before I participate.

[Bonatogether]

Actually I’ll sheep snowy instead

##VOTE Vecna

Baah baah

why not me?

Ghug wagon is too big

but every early d1 wagon dies (the larger, the faster), so by voting ghug you will therefore expedite the failure of the ghug wagon to actually kill ghug.

[Bonatogether]

Alrighty, Mafia time!

Firstly,
The last of my assessments are due this week, so expect lower activity, but it should go up.

Secondly,

oops... continue

That bozo-snowy interaction, very sus (not for bozo). ##vote snowy


I actually like bozo's idea, but I'll wait for a little more support before I participate.

why would you take advice from a bozo