Mini-Mafia Game - Interesting Facts Edition GAME THREAD [Hidden]

[Vecna]

He's tunneling the shit out of snowy and doing almost nothing else?

he's engaged with a lot more people than he usually does, and the swap to snowy seemed like the typical dumb bozo stuff though?

I mean yeah, tunneling is usually town bozo. I only take issue with the part where you like his play.

Dont particularly agree with the first part. Dont particularly agree with the second part.

Still think my allignment assesment is correct

[Vecna]

Oh, sorry.

Also ##vote damo

Do you think it's weird that he told me "nice one" to voting Bob making it 5? Among other things

I will assert it tickled my ivory and ebonies when I read it.

I feel like I have to go back and rework all of my town/mafia leans...which pisses me off because I will be useless tomorrow.

So Vecna....Vecna, Vecna, Vecna, you of the unknown persuasion. YOU of the "null" read from HB. What do you think of Foodcoats. They are in my upper tier of mafia reads BUT I have been on the bad end of killing Food in the daytime before. What are you thinking?

Also, the timing on this is pretty odd after I just started a semi-crusade

[foodcoats]

I’m inclined to believe snowy is town and was RBd. Darg and Bob both noted how snowy is acting funny, and so have I. Snowy’s funny behaviour might have looked like a PR trying to play scummy to stay out of NK range, so a good RB target on that scum POE.

I also am inclined to think JBH made legit townslips regarding PR terminology and RBs. I don’t think a newer player would go to the wall that hard to fake townslip.

Could be wrong on either of these but will remove them from my POE for today.

A point of deduction from this is there would be no reason for scum!damo to behave as he did toward town!snowy (voting his voters). So as long as snowy is town, damo is highly unlikely to be scum, in theory.

[foodcoats]

Darg’s scumreads were snowy and Bob. Bob scumread damo, Chaqa and HB. Since Bob made those reads in earnest, what do people think of those three? (I think snowy has been discussed a lot, and I’m believing the RB claim for now.)

[Hamilton Brian]

Also, the timing on this is pretty odd after I just started a semi-crusade

Odd as in, "this might be mafia HB" or odd in the perjorative sense?

What semi-crusade?

So where are we going to go, town, hand in hand?

Let's get our Jester out and outed? For if they win then our chances of winning are greater.

[foodcoats]

We are dumb, clueless, and taking shots in the dark.

Only 1 person know they're the Jester.

Only 3 people know they are mafia and nothing else.

We've got a couple PRs that know their roles.

We've got a lot of insinuations and misreads.

Can we get anything out of D1 votes? Or was all of my persistent navel gazing in vain?

I think your base assumption that (as I perceived) there must be scum on the wagons or influencing made you come out with some wild takes, like assuming JBH must be scum (couldn't really follow the logic there. All in all, I think you committed the cardinal sin of trying to fit the facts into the theory, instead of just saying "what exactly happened here."

Though maybe I wouldn't be thinking that were I not one of the wagons, who knows.

Think biggest takeaways are is if ghug/food is scum the other is moderately likely to be.

What’s the theory that makes ghug and I more likely to be scum together?

[Hamilton Brian]

Darg’s scumreads were snowy and Bob. Bob scumread damo, Chaqa and HB. Since Bob made those reads in earnest, what do people think of those three? (I think snowy has been discussed a lot, and I’m believing the RB claim for now.)

Well, though this might be the defendant leading the prosecution...or is it witness leading... Neverfuckingmind!

I townread chaqa for the "let's get jester done with" numbers. Damo...I think they were a ? in my mega posts.

[foodcoats]

I’m somewhat still bothered by ghug’s Jester claims. I like Chaqa and snowy’s points about how hard it is for town to do this. But then, would scum go so far? Ghug is very canny and I bet he could Jester claim as scum.

[foodcoats]

Darg’s scumreads were snowy and Bob. Bob scumread damo, Chaqa and HB. Since Bob made those reads in earnest, what do people think of those three? (I think snowy has been discussed a lot, and I’m believing the RB claim for now.)

Well, though this might be the defendant leading the prosecution...or is it witness leading... Neverfuckingmind!

I townread chaqa for the "let's get jester done with" numbers. Damo...I think they were a ? in my mega posts.

What did you make of damo voting all the snowy voters?

[Hamilton Brian]

I really think we need to roll like this:

each person drop their town/mafia reads. We need to make some quick decisions, and it might be best done as concensus.

[foodcoats]

I'm unimpressed with Chaqa so he's probably town.

Whats unimpressive? Chaqa has done some significant analysis. Do you think it has been bad? What would have been better and suggested Chaqa is scum for being good?

I realize my questions are a bit unclear but I’m quite confused by your claim that Chaqa is bad and therefore town. That’s what you’re saying?

[snowy801]

What’s the theory that makes ghug and I more likely to be scum together?

You decided the Bob vote

---

As Jester has yet to claim, I think we must play on assuming that they never will.

---

Why would scum damo not vote my voters?

[Hamilton Brian]

Darg’s scumreads were snowy and Bob. Bob scumread damo, Chaqa and HB. Since Bob made those reads in earnest, what do people think of those three? (I think snowy has been discussed a lot, and I’m believing the RB claim for now.)

Well, though this might be the defendant leading the prosecution...or is it witness leading... Neverfuckingmind!

I townread chaqa for the "let's get jester done with" numbers. Damo...I think they were a ? in my mega posts.

What did you make of damo voting all the snowy voters?

Let me get back to you about that. Doesnt register in my memory right now, but...

[snowy801]

Uh oh, HB is asking for read lists.

Drama to follow

[foodcoats]

also having good vibes from Bozo. Not being stuck on a single mindset, but actually engaging more than one alley.

He's tunneling the shit out of snowy and doing almost nothing else?

he's engaged with a lot more people than he usually does, and the swap to snowy seemed like the typical dumb bozo stuff though?

I don’t know that I agree with this. Bozo has pretty much been stuck on snowy. I don’t think he’s made any scumreads since thinking darg and ghug were bussing snowy. That level of being stuck actually strikes me as being suspicious.

##VOTE bozo

[Hamilton Brian]

Uh oh, HB is asking for read lists.

Drama to follow

You tell me why in 24 hours it's not a bad thing. In community organizing, tell me why consensus is the wrong take?

[foodcoats]

Oh, sorry.

Also ##vote damo

Do you think it's weird that he told me "nice one" to voting Bob making it 5? Among other things

Why do you think scum!damo would vote off all your voters as he did?

[snowy801]

Oh I don't care. I just know, historically, that this community does

[snowy801]

Oh, sorry.

Also ##vote damo

Do you think it's weird that he told me "nice one" to voting Bob making it 5? Among other things

Why do you think scum!damo would vote off all your voters as he did?

To appear towny, while accomplishing nothing?

[foodcoats]

it does not provide feedback whether an actual role was stopped from functioning.

I do like the persistency on your questioning. Weak assumption; scum might be less inclined to persist while people are uttering suspicion.

Good point. I think the stubbornness suggests JBH is town.

Also, Vecna and JBH are almost certainly not scum together when Vecna fluffs JBH’s alleged townslip this way.