M68: Guns N' Roses GAMETHREAD [hidden]

[Hamilton Brian]

Three reasons Eden could have been shot rather than Jamie

I) Jamie is scum
2) Scum thought it a decent enough gamble to kill PE with the side effect of throwing shade on Jamie
3) A townie shot PE

I assign rough probabilities as follows:

1) 30
2 ) 67
3) 3

I think I am coming around to point 2. Do you think it forces a Jamie wagon?

2 implies Jamie is town.

Right, I just assumed there's be a furor over jamie still being alive when they can obviously be killed due to the used-up rose.

[damo666]

(Yes, Damo, that means I am townreading you. Please help yourself to a celebratory biscuit.)

Vote me out. But I am right. I will take the solo win, and to hell with the rest of the team.

Mafia is Chaqa, Jamie, and Damo. That is it.

Of course they will self-congratulate each other.
Of course, they will try to convince the rest of you to vote me out.
That is their job

When the game is over, I will go buy myself a trophy because I called it.

Good grief. Please explain our 3 choices and actions each night for this to work.

[Chaqa]

Johnny is either townslipping hard or was coached a lot in the mafia QT.

##Unvote

I'm wondering if we should just live in the world where he's town.

[Hamilton Brian]

Having banged on about JBH being a safe kill his impassioned (though somewhat naive) post sound very town. I am tempted to gamble 'all in' on JBH being town.

In this case who to vote for? I think it has to be from {HB, worcej, rdr}. Thoughts people on kill Johnny v assume Johnny town and if the latter who to kill?

I appeal for a Bozo type survey on the above.

Glad you mentioned worcej. Rereading their contributions but aside from some entertaining anectdotes about sleeping in a suburu, they'be been kind of combative. Going around in circles with snow. I am trying to understand what their line of thinking is.

What are you thinking about ghug? Both of us the commonalities on the two daykills. Not that it's a bunch to go on.

[damo666]

Johnny is either townslipping hard or was coached a lot in the mafia QT.

##Unvote

I'm wondering if we should just live in the world where he's town.

If I ignore the fact that scum {Chaqa, JBH, x} is gonna say this who do you have in mind to kill then?

[damo666]

##unvote

[Chaqa]

Johnny is either townslipping hard or was coached a lot in the mafia QT.

##Unvote

I'm wondering if we should just live in the world where he's town.

If I ignore the fact that scum {Chaqa, JBH, x} is gonna say this who do you have in mind to kill then?

Hamilton, rivera, or worcej would be my top guesses at the moment.

[Jamiet99uk]

That took me 20 seconds, Hamilton.

Why did you even ask that question and not just check for yourself?

I was going through, came across this: viewtopic.php?p=245030#p245030, and just wanted the certainty.

I think he meant nobody but him scum read them. He was annoyed that nobody scumread Damo.

[Jamiet99uk]

(Yes, Damo, that means I am townreading you. Please help yourself to a celebratory biscuit.)

Vote me out. But I am right. I will take the solo win, and to hell with the rest of the team.

Mafia is Chaqa, Jamie, and Damo. That is it.

Of course they will self-congratulate each other.
Of course, they will try to convince the rest of you to vote me out.
That is their job

When the game is over, I will go buy myself a trophy because I called it.

I hope you enjoy your bronze medal.

[Jamiet99uk]

Having banged on about JBH being a safe kill his impassioned (though somewhat naive) post sound very town. I am tempted to gamble 'all in' on JBH being town.

In this case who to vote for? I think it has to be from {HB, worcej, rdr}. Thoughts people on kill Johnny v assume Johnny town and if the latter who to kill?

I appeal for a Bozo type survey on the above.

Holy 180 degree flip, Batman.

You were trying to endhammer him and now you're all in on him being Town?

[Hamilton Brian]

Johnny is either townslipping hard or was coached a lot in the mafia QT.

##Unvote

I'm wondering if we should just live in the world where he's town.

If I ignore the fact that scum {Chaqa, JBH, x} is gonna say this who do you have in mind to kill then?

Hamilton, rivera, or worcej would be my top guesses at the moment.

I would support 2 of those three.

[Jamiet99uk]

I think I am coming around to point 2. Do you think it forces a Jamie wagon?

2 implies Jamie is town.

Right, I just assumed there's be a furor over jamie still being alive when they can obviously be killed due to the used-up rose.

Are you reading the thread?

This has already been mentioned by more than one person, and I have talked about it.

You are either scum, or you're playing the game they want you to play.

[damo666]

People I will definitely not vote for today: Jamie Chaqa ghug

People I would vote for only if somebody made an ultra convincing case: celaph emc

People I am willing to vote for: HamB rdr worcej

I also will revert to JBH if he's looking the compromise solution.

I think I'll vote ##vote worcej and see what happens.

[Jamiet99uk]

People I will definitely not vote for today: Jamie Chaqa ghug

Didn't you just call Chaqa scum?

[Jamiet99uk]

Johnny is either townslipping hard or was coached a lot in the mafia QT.

##Unvote

I'm wondering if we should just live in the world where he's town.

If I ignore the fact that scum {Chaqa, JBH, x} is gonna say this who do you have in mind to kill then?

This post implies Chaqa is scum, now he's on your Do Not Vote list, like 3 posts later.

[damo666]

Having banged on about JBH being a safe kill his impassioned (though somewhat naive) post sound very town. I am tempted to gamble 'all in' on JBH being town.

In this case who to vote for? I think it has to be from {HB, worcej, rdr}. Thoughts people on kill Johnny v assume Johnny town and if the latter who to kill?

I appeal for a Bozo type survey on the above.

Holy 180 degree flip, Batman.

You were trying to endhammer him and now you're all in on him being Town?

I know, I know. Sometimes I hate this game.

[Jamiet99uk]

I'm quite perturbed at the way Damo is suddenly flip flopping all over the place like a wild Brainbomb.

[damo666]

Johnny is either townslipping hard or was coached a lot in the mafia QT.

##Unvote

I'm wondering if we should just live in the world where he's town.

If I ignore the fact that scum {Chaqa, JBH, x} is gonna say this who do you have in mind to kill then?

This post implies Chaqa is scum, now he's on your Do Not Vote list, like 3 posts later.

No, I don't think Chaqa is scum. I am just pointing out that risk (both him and JBH being scum) but it is one I [think] I have decided to take.

[damo666]

I'm quite perturbed at the way Damo is suddenly flip flopping all over the place like a wild Brainbomb.

So am I lol.

On the one hand I think Johnny is very likely telling the truth but on other I'm terrified scum will win this game tonight which will be galling if iy happens and I haven't followed my own advice.

Ultimately it's a gamble. I'd say Johnny is about 85% town and therefore I'm willing to take the risk.

Unless he's been coached ....

but then why wouldn't the coacher take the role of claimant ....

but then they would like come under greater suspicion ....

but then why would scum target JBH?

Aaaarrggghhhh!!!!

I'm going round in circles.

Gonna take a break.

[Chaqa]

Johnny is either townslipping hard or was coached a lot in the mafia QT.

##Unvote

I'm wondering if we should just live in the world where he's town.

If I ignore the fact that scum {Chaqa, JBH, x} is gonna say this who do you have in mind to kill then?

This post implies Chaqa is scum, now he's on your Do Not Vote list, like 3 posts later.

I read that post as "Ignoring the fact that IF these two are scum..."