M68: Guns N' Roses GAMETHREAD [hidden]

[Jamiet99uk]

There are therefore three scum in this pool:

1. Damo666
2. ghug
4. Worcej
5. BrainbomB
7. Prez Eden
8. Macca573
9. Rdrivera2005
10. Hamilton Brian
12. EMC
14. Johnny Big Horse

[rdrivera2005]

To be honest, I like most of the current wagons (Macca, emc and Worcej, Ghug a bit less).

##vote emc - I think he is trying to replicate his lurking town meta from last game, but without any sparks that usually indicate town emc.

[Jamiet99uk]

I advocate killing EMC today for the following reasons:

1. He is in the scum pool.

2. He contributed nothing at all on D1.

3. He has contributed nothing since then either.

4. People didn't vote him because "oh he'll be modkilled or subbed out" but predictably he re-appeared at the end, just in time to save himself from that outcome. Textbook scum!EMC behaviour.

5. If he somehow is actually town he is VERY unlikely to be targeted by the Mafia for the NK, which means we would be stuck with him in the endgame if we don't DK him.

[Jamiet99uk]

Unofficial vote tally:

EMC: (2) Jamiet99uk, Rdrivera2005
Ghug: (2) Johnny Big Horse, Macca
Macca573: (2) Damo666, ghug
worcej: (1) Snowy801

Unvoted: President Eden

[rdrivera2005]

There are therefore three scum in this pool:

1. Damo666
2. ghug
4. Worcej
5. BrainbomB
7. Prez Eden
8. Macca573
9. Rdrivera2005
10. Hamilton Brian
12. EMC
14. Johnny Big Horse

I won't clear Chaqa. If you are scum and claimed a gun you need to shoot and choosing you as target isn't exactly the choice I expect from town Chaqa.

[Jamiet99uk]

There are therefore three scum in this pool:

1. Damo666
2. ghug
4. Worcej
5. BrainbomB
7. Prez Eden
8. Macca573
9. Rdrivera2005
10. Hamilton Brian
12. EMC
14. Johnny Big Horse

I won't clear Chaqa. If you are scum and claimed a gun you need to shoot and choosing you as target isn't exactly the choice I expect from town Chaqa.

You think Chaqa targeting me is scum indicative.

That's interesting.

Why do you feel that town!Chaqa would not fire at me?

[dargorygel]

##GM NOTE
Vote Count 2.3
Macca573: (2) Damo666, ghug
ghug: (2) Johnny Big Horse, Macca573
e.m.c^42: (2) Jamiet99uk, rdrivera2005
worcej: (1) snowy

[Hamilton Brian]

There are therefore three scum in this pool:

1. Damo666
2. ghug
4. Worcej
5. BrainbomB
7. Prez Eden
8. Macca573
9. Rdrivera2005
10. Hamilton Brian
12. EMC
14. Johnny Big Horse

I won't clear Chaqa. If you are scum and claimed a gun you need to shoot and choosing you as target isn't exactly the choice I expect from town Chaqa.

You think Chaqa targeting me is scum indicative.

That's interesting.

Why do you feel that town!Chaqa would not fire at me?

Certainly there's a world where scum conspire to lie about a claim like this; not saying it is happening here but I think it would be pretty naive to rosily accept it without at least some question.

But why wouldn't town Chaqa shoot Jamie? Who do you think better candidates were?

[Hamilton Brian]

##unvote

I'm bad at this game send help

What? Something shift an opinion you held on to? Care to explain. Or are you just being...existential?

[Hamilton Brian]

I advocate killing EMC today for the following reasons:

1. He is in the scum pool.

2. He contributed nothing at all on D1.

3. He has contributed nothing since then either.

4. People didn't vote him because "oh he'll be modkilled or subbed out" but predictably he re-appeared at the end, just in time to save himself from that outcome. Textbook scum!EMC behaviour.

5. If he somehow is actually town he is VERY unlikely to be targeted by the Mafia for the NK, which means we would be stuck with him in the endgame if we don't DK him.

I'd also suggest that he's one of the pool that was on the foodcoats kill.

[dargorygel]

##GM NOTE
Woo HOO the bot is back up!
Thanks peterlund!

[peterlund]

Hello everyone!

Now mafia.peterlund.se is up and running again.

Sorry for the inconvenience, but I upgraded my fiber converter to get 1Gbit/sec up and down (10 times faster than before ).

Regards Peter

[Hamilton Brian]

I advocate killing EMC today for the following reasons:

1. He is in the scum pool.

2. He contributed nothing at all on D1.

3. He has contributed nothing since then either.

4. People didn't vote him because "oh he'll be modkilled or subbed out" but predictably he re-appeared at the end, just in time to save himself from that outcome. Textbook scum!EMC behaviour.

5. If he somehow is actually town he is VERY unlikely to be targeted by the Mafia for the NK, which means we would be stuck with him in the endgame if we don't DK him.

I'd also suggest that he's one of the pool that was on the foodcoats kill.

Oh, Jesus. Just looking at the bot to refresh my memory and nearly half of us were on Food. Ugh.

[Jamiet99uk]

I am keen to hear from Brainbomb.

[snowy801]

Snowy, what's behind the sudden uptick of +1s on me after D2 started?

You're posting more, I guess?

I've got my eye on you.

I invite you, then, to continue threatening me with a good time

##vote ghug

If you are correct and all President Eden is is overly confident in himself, how do you feel about his assertions that there are likely 3 scum in yourself, Chaqa, brainbomb, and Jamiet in the context of not knowing what the N1 reveals were? You previously stated numerous times that you believe PE is scum for tone and context but not, if I recall, because of his arguments.

Do you believe he is likely one now, given what you know?

[Jamiet99uk]

I am keen to hear from Brainbomb.

OK WHO HACKED MY ACCOUNT?
The real Jamie T would never say that.

[rdrivera2005]

I won't clear Chaqa. If you are scum and claimed a gun you need to shoot and choosing you as target isn't exactly the choice I expect from town Chaqa.

You think Chaqa targeting me is scum indicative.

That's interesting.

Why do you feel that town!Chaqa would not fire at me?

Certainly there's a world where scum conspire to lie about a claim like this; not saying it is happening here but I think it would be pretty naive to rosily accept it without at least some question.

But why wouldn't town Chaqa shoot Jamie? Who do you think better candidates were?

I think emc and Johnny are better candidates and also Brain if you want info. Jamiet wasn't particularly scum read D1 and posts a lot so it's easier to sort. I would never choose him as a shot target D1 and I am town.

Would you choose Jamiet?

[Jamiet99uk]

But why wouldn't town Chaqa shoot Jamie? Who do you think better candidates were?

I think emc and Johnny are better candidates and also Brain if you want info. Jamiet wasn't particularly scum read D1 and posts a lot so it's easier to sort. I would never choose him as a shot target D1 and I am town.

Would you choose Jamiet?

Why Johnny, in particular?

[Johnny Big Horse]

People who claim to have fired a gun:

Chaqa

People who claim they were shot and saved due to their vest:

Jamiet99uk (one shot)
Snowy801(one shot)

If you were shot last night, please claim.
If you fired a gun last night, please claim.

Otherwise, it can be assumed that Chaqa, Snowy, and myself are telling the truth, which means Snowy was the Mafia kill attempt, and Chaqa shot me. This makes it highly likely that Chaqa and Snowy, in addition to myself* are all town.

* I know that I'm town, of course.

I was hoping someone would put this together (for me)

[Hamilton Brian]

You think Chaqa targeting me is scum indicative.

That's interesting.

Why do you feel that town!Chaqa would not fire at me?

Certainly there's a world where scum conspire to lie about a claim like this; not saying it is happening here but I think it would be pretty naive to rosily accept it without at least some question.

But why wouldn't town Chaqa shoot Jamie? Who do you think better candidates were?

I think emc and Johnny are better candidates and also Brain if you want info. Jamiet wasn't particularly scum read D1 and posts a lot so it's easier to sort. I would never choose him as a shot target D1 and I am town.

Would you choose Jamiet?

I think brain would be really good for info, and I think it makes them good for a flip today. Interested about EMC and Johnny; why would they be better candidates?

WOuld I choose Jamie? I don't know. Based on performance on D1, perhaps not. So in my thinking, who were the people I was feeling lots of energy about...brain, PE, snowy. They might have made for better targets/resolutions on N1 for the gun.