M68: Guns N' Roses GAMETHREAD [hidden]

[brainbomb]

I dont actually think jamie is scummy at all

[brainbomb]

this is where you should be asking the mechanically supposedly outted scum why he suddenly thinks jamie is town

[brainbomb]

##Vote e.m.c

[ghug]

this is where you should be asking the mechanically supposedly outted scum why he suddenly thinks jamie is town

Hey, mechanically supposedly outed scum, why do you think Jamie is town?

Why do you think emc and snowy are scum?

[brainbomb]

I dont think ive ever been a policy kill based on something I said in pregame. That is actually pretty funny.

*The crowd giggled*

You know what, last game D1 reads went super well, Jamie is so condescending here he's leaking scum fluids all over my poor face.

This is really random

[brainbomb]

this is where you should be asking the mechanically supposedly outted scum why he suddenly thinks jamie is town

Hey, mechanically supposedly outed scum, why do you think Jamie is town?

Why do you think emc and snowy are scum?

Snowy was a rvs vote. I have no opinion just wanted his attention

Jamie seems town because I dont consider what hes done to be flaky or lacking in purpose. I couldnt really explain his scum game easily but I dont feel this is anywhere close to it. for one I find him annoying; usually that doesnt occur

emc snapshots of the game all look too forced. they dont seem like genuine observations an emc makes.

[brainbomb]

i could argue foodcoats is scum who wants to miskill damo and he has higher respect for damo townplay than mine.

I dont get a town vibe from food yet

[Hamilton Brian]

Two things I'd like not to see end of D1:

a) recursive kill of Chaqa

b) immediate kill of brainbomb

Hopefully the sober second thoughts can offer some reconsiderations.

However, the thread so far has felt like when your SO tells you not to squeeze that pimple, but you do it anyway.

[Hamilton Brian]

And now I am seeing we have 14; could have sworn we had more. I know, I know, read the setup.

Big thing that stands out to me is...we can't lose as long as we have a rose. So claiming should be anathema.

11 town? 9, 10, or 11 roses. Maybe 2 guns?

[brainbomb]

optimal town play was to take a rose the only reason anyone wouldve taken a gun as town was to give town a 1 shot vig

were all on the same page on that right?

[Hamilton Brian]

And for anyone new: http://mafia.peterlund.se

[Hamilton Brian]

optimal town play was to take a rose the only reason anyone wouldve taken a gun as town was to give town a 1 shot vig

were all on the same page on that right?

On the face of that statement, sounds ok to me, but I need more info from the setup.

[brainbomb]

the only reason scum takes a rose here is if they expect to get elim early which im probably the only scum player who expects to die by n3 in every game. so you can see why my claim is pretty unhelpful since id either be revealing im able to die or id be saying im scum who expected to die

[dargorygel]

GM NOTE
Vote Count 1.01
Sergeant Vecna fell asleep at the desk, leaving Sergeant Darg to note the suspicions of the gathered detectives. He doesn't mind. He can drink coffee while he watches the desk. It's his job. He notes these suspects and votes at present:

Brainbomb: (5) foodcoats, Jamiet99uk, President Eden, ghug, damo666
Jamiet99uk: (1) Macca573
e.m.c^42: (1) brainbomb
(we have one end vote presently, foodcoats for brainbomb)

Chaqa, emc, Hamilton, Johnny Big Horse, rdrivera, snowy, and worcej have not yet voted.

Rdrivera, snowy, and worcej have not yet posted.

At this moment, brainbomb has more votes on him as a suspect than anyone else.

LOTS of time left to solve this mystery.

[rdrivera2005]

Good night fellow town cops and some bad guys.

This wagon on Brain is utterly bullshit. Bbs answer to the wagon is another bullshit, which makes me puzzled.

Anyone that found weird that many roses is either scum or stupid as the rational thing to do as town is to choose a rose.

I really dislike the PE entrance and his condescending post to Brain.

I disliked Food vote on Brain as how on Earth he assumed Brain hardclaimed a gun?

I dislike Ghug and Chaqa claiming a gun, but at same time it's a bold move to do as scum.

I liked Macca's entrance.

##vote Food

[Hamilton Brian]

in my one thing at a time thinking...

With that scum QT open for the 24 hours prior to start, there was plenty of time to concoct some strategy. Look to see who might drive discussion somewhere else.

[Hamilton Brian]

And with out number of roses, I think we win simply waiting scum out, right?

Not sure I've seen Rivera come in so emphatic on a D1 but I'd agree that the BB wagon is BS. But, stop grabbing for all that rope.

[rdrivera2005]

optimal town play was to take a rose the only reason anyone wouldve taken a gun as town was to give town a 1 shot vig

were all on the same page on that right?

On the face of that statement, sounds ok to me, but I need more info from the setup.

What info you want to get from the setup? What's the use of a gun to town other then randomly shooting someone? Scum probably have 3 guns. Assuming worst scenario where they all kill a target, it will be down to 8 -3, which means only two miskills for town. A wrong town shot that kill another town just count as a misskill too, so why a non megalomaniac town would want to play vig and choose a gun?

[rdrivera2005]

And with out number of roses, I think we win simply waiting scum out, right?

Not sure I've seen Rivera come in so emphatic on a D1 but I'd agree that the BB wagon is BS. But, stop grabbing for all that rope.

I don't get what you mean with "simply waiting scum out". Scum have a NK so we need to find them and we don't have any PR. This is a pretty vanilla game after N3 and town usually don't perform well on vanilla games here....

[foodcoats]

Two things I'd like not to see end of D1:

a) recursive kill of Chaqa

b) immediate kill of brainbomb

Hopefully the sober second thoughts can offer some reconsiderations.

However, the thread so far has felt like when your SO tells you not to squeeze that pimple, but you do it anyway.

D1ing Chaqa would actually be pretty funny since this is ostensibly his last game on WebDip Mafia because he’s been D1d too many times.

##VOTE Chaqa