MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[BobMcBob]

Thanks for letting me "co-GM" HR. I didn't do much but I think I have a better idea of how to run a few things.

This game was a pain to watch, because it felt (at least partially with the benefit of omnipotence) that the scumteam was playing pretty bad in multiple situations. But town's ability to actually vote them out was legitimately awful. Celaph and Macca both should've died, and then kgray for celaph interactions. I have no clue how well I would've done as town actually playing, but I can be pretty sure nobody would've listened if I was right.

Also Jamie, shut your mouth. You played awfully too.

[brainbomb]

no scum won because they (chaqa and kgray) dominated the thread and led the discussions at will with little resistance; which allowed them to keep two serial lurker scum from ever getting picked off.

RHK was almost an aberration.

[ghug]

My panic started us downhill. I legit thought I was going to be DKed, and was not going to be around. My bad. Humble bowing and scraping.

I still have no idea why you completely lost your mind just because four people voted for you.

Really weird.

Try to calm down in future.

You often do this as well, Jamie.

[Jamiet99uk]

Love that when you all are killing me right after I replace and before I can do anything, I yell that you need to kill Chaqa/Kgray/Celaph.
And then no one paid any heed lol.

For the people saying it was bad I self voted, I had a PR read on Maniac (I sent a message to the godthread) so I knew it was better I died before him. Then you assholes killed Maniac next anyway. lol

You sucked, and were as much use as an ashtray on a motorcycle.

Thanks for subbing in, all the same.

You sucked, too, Jamie.

You sucked, too.

Please, analyse my faults. And your own.

[brainbomb]

almost doesnt count when it comes to killing scum. you either did or you didnt. I killed 0 scum this game. bad loss, and will try to play better in m68

[Jamiet99uk]

My panic started us downhill. I legit thought I was going to be DKed, and was not going to be around. My bad. Humble bowing and scraping.

I still have no idea why you completely lost your mind just because four people voted for you.

Really weird.

Try to calm down in future.

You often do this as well, Jamie.

Incorrect.

"Often"?

Provide 3 or more examples of games in which I was a town PR who claimed my role when under minimal pressure.

That's absolutely not something I "often" do, you're wrong.

[TheMadMonarch]

Excellent Game HR. Loved it!

I forgot to go invisible last night, so I appeared breifly as I rushed to turn it off. I watched the thread through the bot, and prepared my vote to drop at 10 seconds left.

I know I'm "never on for EOD", but I have once before. While Scum at milo. But the only person I assume to be able to remember that was my two time scum buddy kgray.

I don't like this assertion that "both teams were bad", it's a directly competing game, you play with what you have.

All in all, I had a hoot. Thanks darg for making me play!

[Jamiet99uk]

no scum won because they (chaqa and kgray) dominated the thread and led the discussions at will with little resistance; which allowed them to keep two serial lurker scum from ever getting picked off.

RHK was almost an aberration.

I would not say Kgray led any discussions, far from it. Kgray was much less assertive and active and questioning than normal.

That's Kgray's scumtell, apparently, and we should take note.

[Jamiet99uk]

Also Jamie, shut your mouth.

This is not the sort of thing a GM should say.

[Jamiet99uk]

Thanks for letting me "co-GM" HR. I didn't do much but I think I have a better idea of how to run a few things.

This game was a pain to watch, because it felt (at least partially with the benefit of omnipotence) that the scumteam was playing pretty bad in multiple situations. But town's ability to actually vote them out was legitimately awful. Celaph and Macca both should've died, and then kgray for celaph interactions. I have no clue how well I would've done as town actually playing, but I can be pretty sure nobody would've listened if I was right.

Also Jamie, shut your mouth. You played awfully too.

Didn't do much? Did you actually do anything?

Doesn't seem like you provided HR with much support.

[yavuzovic]

I also take credit for playing awfully. That last thing about double kill was unnecessary risk. We would have killed a scum anyway if I didn't suggest that. I also repeatedly said that they aren't both scum. Even if our plan worked, it wouldn't be any better than just killing Macca.

[worcej]

@Ghug: Could you tell us more about why you scumread Kgray and Chaqa?

There is proof that these two are great at scum theater in the last game I ran.

I remember thinking they did a smashing job.

worcej. This kind of shit is so frustrating. What does that have to do with this game at all? How is that related to Jamie's question? If you think I'm putting on theater with someone then that's one thing, but this is just irrelevant fearmongering.

https://i.kym-cdn.com/entries/icons/fac ... 28/519.jpg

[yavuzovic]

jamie calm down

[ghug]

I still have no idea why you completely lost your mind just because four people voted for you.

Really weird.

Try to calm down in future.

You often do this as well, Jamie.

Incorrect.

"Often"?

Provide 3 or more examples of games in which I was a town PR who claimed my role when under minimal pressure.

That's absolutely not something I "often" do, you're wrong.

You don't claim. You heavily intonate. Off the top of my head, I can think of the last time kgray and Chaqa won as scum, and the game before this one.

[worcej]

O well. Even if we killed Macca we'd never have got all the others.

Three bussers?

This is why we should never only rely on VCA...

[Jamiet99uk]

jamie calm down

It's pretty clear a majority of you actively hate me, hold me deeply in contempt, or think I'm a joke. If the general view of the community is that my presence here is either harmful, or pitiful, or contemptible, then I think I know what I need to do.

It's a shame that it's come to this but my presence here is apparently no longer welcome. I'll comment further tomorrow after I've had some sleep.

[brainbomb]

this discussion is a sign i should post a signup. council let me know when yall are okay with my setup

[Jamiet99uk]

I've enjoyed playing Mafia here even if my deductive skills weren't great. I hope as a GM I've provided some fun setups for you even if they weren't perfect.

[Jamiet99uk]

this discussion is a sign i should post a signup. council let me know when yall are okay with my setup

I think you'll have to ask someone else.

[worcej]

jamie calm down

It's pretty clear a majority of you actively hate me, hold me deeply in contempt, or think I'm a joke. If the general view of the community is that my presence here is either harmful, or pitiful, or contemptible, then I think I know what I need to do.

It's a shame that it's come to this but my presence here is apparently no longer welcome. I'll comment further tomorrow after I've had some sleep.

I wouldn't say any of what you listed is true. You, like myself, are abrasive and are passionate. We both just have to be more respectful.

In regards to this game: You had a bad game and are a large part of why town lost here. It happens to all of us, so don't take it with as much salt as you are. Just try to be better.