MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[Bonatogether]

Look, Bona may well be scum but imo less certain than Macca. Can we not just kill Macca and Yav first and see who is left?

How can we kill Macca *and* Yav?

[Bonatogether]

Town
me
jamie
yavu
chaqa
rdr
macca
kgray
celaph
food
damo
Scum

[Bonatogether]

food was online but then he left without posting anything

[Chaqa]

bored

[TheMadMonarch]

I know there's a day to go but surely you can see the danger of the situation.

Town should could consolidate. Scum will have to bus.

Macca is today's vote. Last one on is scum.

##VOTE Macca

I'm not last, so I'm not scum right?

##UNVOTE

[TheMadMonarch]

Jamie is town based on basic logic.

If Jamie were scum, when he outed the WW, the Wolf would have told us he guessed VT on Jamie and was wrong. The WW knows both he and the town need to remove scum to win, so there would be no reason to lie. So when Jamie outs Hamilton and HB confirms he guessed Janitor on Jamie, this implicitly means Jamie is town because scum!Jamie would never out the Werewolf there.

TLDR:
- WW would have outed scumJamie in the hopes of potentially winning down the line, and has no reason to lie to cover for scumJamie

WW could guess Janitor on a Godfather Jamie. This proves nothing.

[TheMadMonarch]

I know there's a day to go but surely you can see the danger of the situation.

Town should could consolidate. Scum will have to bus.

Macca is today's vote. Last one on is scum.

Why not instead, pretend Macca is dead.

Now, vote your next highest read.

This is flawed logic.

What if Macca flips Janitor? That would be a very good piece of information on people like me, Rivera, and Jamie.

OK,

What would happen if I flipped Janitor? Godfather? How would you act then?

[Bonatogether]

I know there's a day to go but surely you can see the danger of the situation.

Town should could consolidate. Scum will have to bus.

Macca is today's vote. Last one on is scum.

##VOTE Macca

I'm not last, so I'm not scum right?

##UNVOTE

Was this just a sly way to unvote?

[TheMadMonarch]

Look, Bona may well be scum but imo less certain than Macca. Can we not just kill Macca and Yav first and see who is left?

My problem is that this is a policy shimmydingdong more than anything else.
No one today has actually laid out a case on Macca unless I missed it. It’s basically “Macca lurked.”

And acting this way damo is bad for town.

WE WANT

INNNNN

FO-MAYSHUN

Thank you! I am a lurker every game, please do something better.

[TheMadMonarch]

I think it's understandable for Bona to not know his own scum tells assuming he hasn't played much scum. Is there anyone alive who can speak to Bona's performances as scum on discord?

Secondly, the highlighted line is just a lie. We all thought that your play was incredibly anti-town, but assumed that scum would back down under the pressure you were under. We thought you were town not because you were a good hunter, but because of your boldness.

This had been the crux of my Bona Townread so far, and the note the people did similar things in our scum game (see above, I wasn't watching him) confirms my belief that he is a scumbo.

Confirms? Do you have alternative reasoning aside from piggybacking off of other people?

Yes. You're scummy, and I don't like your [backflipping/actually I believed him the whole time] deal with darg.

This CONFIRMS it. It's icing on the cake.

[TheMadMonarch]

@Yav and at @ Macca

Your best guess at the scumteam please

uhh....

Bona and yav.

Beyond that, perhaps rdr or Jamie?

[TheMadMonarch]

I know there's a day to go but surely you can see the danger of the situation.

Town should could consolidate. Scum will have to bus.

Macca is today's vote. Last one on is scum.

##VOTE Macca

I'm not last, so I'm not scum right?

##UNVOTE

Was this just a sly way to unvote?

Not intentionally. However:

I saw some people being sus of yav as well, and I want to communicate that I'd be happy to vote Yav, if y'all want to go in that direction as well.

[damo666]

Look, Bona may well be scum but imo less certain than Macca. Can we not just kill Macca and Yav first and see who is left?

How can we kill Macca *and* Yav?

On consecutive days

[damo666]

##vote Bona

[TheMadMonarch]

##vote Bona

Any reason?

[damo666]

##vote Bona

Any reason?

His latching on to my 'scumminess' looks like a desperate flailing attempt to get focus away from himself.

[foodcoats]

food was online but then he left without posting anything

Was busy yakkin with damo in the qt

[Bonatogether]

##vote Bona

Any reason?

His latching on to my 'scumminess' looks like a desperate flailing attempt to get focus away from himself.

The fact that it is I pointing this out does not invalidate the point that you did scummy things - can you address those?

[kgray]

I am not going to vote the following today or tomorrow

kgray
rdr


err that's it

Uh why though?

[kgray]

> Getting the numbers wrong becuase he is not paying attention
> End voting without due cause
> Having suddenly unlikely "scumreads"

Are these the mating cries of the Scumdamo?

I don't get your last point. Why would scum!damo suddenly have unlikely scumreads?