MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[Chaqa]

##Vote Hamilton
##END

Let’s end the phase just before deadline so we don’t have a 48 hour night please

[Jamiet99uk]

Is there a downside to ending?

I'd like Hamilton to tell us more about his guess on Kgray.

I'd like Bona to tell me about the Cop claim.

[Jamiet99uk]

Alright I'm off to do some in-person housework.

Microsoft Housework Simulator(TM) just not exciting enough anymore?

[Jamiet99uk]

Well played HB, it’s a tough role to draw.

You have provided some very valuable info to town.

Voting for you now sucks but town is forced to do it - you could choose to go on a rampage and duel down the mafia. This is so obvious that yavu and Chaq now look awful.

##VOTE Hamilton

Oh yeah like I’d mask off to save the Werewolf, lmao

I think Jamie shouldn’t have even revealed it.

What the fuck, Chaqa?

You were one of the people who encouraged me to reveal:

I say reveal.

It’s not me btw

[damo666]

D5 kill HB 7 4
N5 scum NK me say 6 4
D6 kill scum Macca (obv if we MK it's game over) 6 3
N6 scum NK darg 5 3
D7 kill scum yav (again MK we lose) 5 2
N7 scum NK kgray [say] 4 2
D8 again we gotta get this right, very nervous at this stage, kill scum rdr [phew!]
N8 scum NK Bona [say] 3 2
D9 got to choose between celaph Jamie Chaqa food (an unenviable task)

I think I would have to plump for that bussing fan Chaqa.

My order would be Chaqa Jamie Food celaph.

I hope food hasn't been pulling the wool over eyes all game.

[damo666]

D5 kill HB 7 4
N5 scum NK me say 6 4
D6 kill scum Macca (obv if we MK it's game over) 6 3
N6 scum NK darg 5 3
D7 kill scum yav (again MK we lose) 5 2
N7 scum NK kgray [say] 4 2
D8 again we gotta get this right, very nervous at this stage, kill scum rdr [phew!] 4 1
N8 scum NK Bona [say] 3 1
D9 got to choose between celaph Jamie Chaqa food (an unenviable task)

I think I would have to plump for that bussing fan Chaqa.

My order would be Chaqa Jamie Food celaph.

I hope food hasn't been pulling the wool over eyes all game.

Numbers corrected

[celaph]

I see your point re J.

Unless bona's D1 vote was a reckless diamond hard Mohs scale 10 bus I can only see him as scum if both Kak and HB also are.

I will examine Bona Kak HB + ? teams and report back. Busy at mo so will be a while but before EON.

Is there a reason you're discounting the chance that Bona was bussing? I agree that he looks really good for it and it's one of the main reasons I'm hesitant to kill him, but I wouldn't put it past him.

You can't keep bringing up this one thing as a justification to not townread me even though everyone admits it was an extremely townie thing to do.

You're misunderstanding my point. Your vote is a great reason to townread you, the best reason by a long shot. That said, as food and Damo have pointed out, the scum are either exactly Jamie rdr Macca yav, or there is a busser. So you can't just stand on that vote alone.

[celaph]

I'm going to try to do this briefly and then add explanations throughout the day.

Foodcoats is right. I am the werewolf. I've had 2 unsuccessful chomps. Hence my frustration yesterday.

Jamie as Janitor was the 2nd one. Jamie was also my second choice and I did not go with my original person.

Kgray was my first attempt but not as a VT guess.

I was considering what my options were when the game started. I didn't see a win condition for me by helping mafia (and maybe there is but I didn't see the numbers). So my decision was to help town. It still is. Town wins when mafia and werewolf are gone. I think when you look at the condition for winning, I am a useful role for nighttime for you.

The benefit I've had for town hasn't been great and my reads have been all over the place. However, knowing now that the Scum/Town/Werewolf/Town, it might reveal the reasons for voting movement.

And if this is not the best time to have revealed, then I am sure some smartalec will be more than willing to educate me on it.

##vote HB

[celaph]

I’m going to be gone for basically all of today (irl) because I’m playing in a vFTF dip tourney. First round was last night and I’m currently in second, wish me luck!

I think I believe Jamie..? And I think it’d be best for him to reveal the werewolf, but really I haven’t thought it through.

I’m going to try to keep checking in, but I’ll be back tonight at least. ##vote Hamilton for now.

Good luck!

[celaph]

Is there a downside to ending?

I'd like Hamilton to tell us more about his guess on Kgray.

I'd like Bona to tell me about the Cop claim.

I guessed godfather on kgray

[Bonatogether]

Another thing to say to Bonatogether:

It is currently SATURDAY.
You are NOT at school today.
Therefore you can post and participate today.

I'm not going to spend every damn hour on mafia. I have other commitments.

[damo666]

Another thing to say to Bonatogether:

It is currently SATURDAY.
You are NOT at school today.
Therefore you can post and participate today.

I'm not going to spend every damn hour on mafia. I have other commitments.

Can you please explain your view on darg. With a sensible explanation you can become strongtown

[Bonatogether]

@Bona

Stop stalling. You don't want to answer my question. Why is that?

Is this the cop question? or something else?

[Bonatogether]

Another thing to say to Bonatogether:

It is currently SATURDAY.
You are NOT at school today.
Therefore you can post and participate today.

I'm not going to spend every damn hour on mafia. I have other commitments.

Can you please explain your view on darg. With a sensible explanation you can become strongtown

I was trying to softclaim cop to get scum to kill me but then kak went and did the same thing but more.

[celaph]

D5 kill HB 7 4
N5 scum NK me say 6 4
D6 kill scum Macca (obv if we MK it's game over) 6 3
N6 scum NK darg 5 3
D7 kill scum yav (again MK we lose) 5 2
N7 scum NK kgray [say] 4 2
D8 again we gotta get this right, very nervous at this stage, kill scum rdr [phew!] 4 1
N8 scum NK Bona [say] 3 1
D9 got to choose between celaph Jamie Chaqa food (an unenviable task)

I think I would have to plump for that bussing fan Chaqa.

My order would be Chaqa Jamie Food celaph.

I hope food hasn't been pulling the wool over eyes all game.

Numbers corrected

I agree with all this except that we probably no kill D9 to force scum to eliminate an option.

[Jamiet99uk]

Is there a downside to ending?

I'd like Hamilton to tell us more about his guess on Kgray.

I'd like Bona to tell me about the Cop claim.

I guessed godfather on kgray

Ah great yes, thanks.

[Bonatogether]

It almost seems to easy for it to be those four, but how am I ever going to wagon kgray and Chaqa, who have both been working their tails to solve?

Only real question mark is RDR, and I would not even consider him until we shimmy-ding-dong at least three out of the other four. Bona/RDR is really the axis, but at this point I think bona is flailing scum.

I don't flail as scum this early.

[Jamiet99uk]

I'm not going to spend every damn hour on mafia. I have other commitments.

Can you please explain your view on darg. With a sensible explanation you can become strongtown

I was trying to softclaim cop to get scum to kill me but then kak went and did the same thing but more.

FINALLY an answer. Apparently you'll answer questions from Damo but not me.

Why did you refuse to answer this for so long?

[damo666]

We should not end until Macca and Yav have spoken just in the tiniest chance either are town with a gun.

Clearly scum do not have a gun.

[Bonatogether]

Is there a reason you're discounting the chance that Bona was bussing? I agree that he looks really good for it and it's one of the main reasons I'm hesitant to kill him, but I wouldn't put it past him.

You can't keep bringing up this one thing as a justification to not townread me even though everyone admits it was an extremely townie thing to do.

You're misunderstanding my point. Your vote is a great reason to townread you, the best reason by a long shot. That said, as food and Damo have pointed out, the scum are either exactly Jamie rdr Macca yav, or there is a busser. So you can't just stand on that vote alone.

No, but since that one game, people soften every townread with "he played that one scumgame in a really risky way" and it's just kinda bunk.

next time i'm scum i'm going to lurk just to avoid this