MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[Chaqa]

Actually... it’s probably better if Jamie doesnt reveal, right?

Mafia knowing WW would mean they don’t ever miss their nightkill

[foodcoats]

I think you were trying to help town and I appreciate that.

I’m sorry for viciously scumreading you...

Third party is hard AF, I played a survivor role maybe a year or so ago... incredibly difficult.

[yavuzovic]

What about this:
Scum learned who the ww is on N1 so thry krpt RBing the wolf while dargo claimed the RB? I don't feel like doubting dargorygel until cclaimed though.
Maybe dargo isn't roleblocked tonight and it was ww who got roleblocked? Dargo??

Yavu, on balance, do you think darg is scum or town?

I think he's town cop. I doubted him whem kak claimed but I don't think dargo is scum.

[yavuzovic]

I think revealing WW doesn't gelp town anyway. We should cooperate. Ww needs mafia to be daykilled today. Town also needs mafia to be killed today. We can ignore the WW as long as they try to hit scum.

[yavuzovic]

Actually werewolf knows that we will have to kill him anyway so Jamie should reveal the werewolf and the werewolf should tell us whether Jamie is scum or not. I mean, it's very likely that werewolf was trying to consume a VT since half of us are VTs. If werewolf tried for WW and failed to consume Jamie, well, we would vote for jamie and bam, scum gone.

[Chaqa]

Actually werewolf knows that we will have to kill him anyway so Jamie should reveal the werewolf and the werewolf should tell us whether Jamie is scum or not. I mean, it's very likely that werewolf was trying to consume a VT since half of us are VTs. If werewolf tried for WW and failed to consume Jamie, well, we would vote for jamie and bam, scum gone.

By that logic WW should our first if Jamie is scum

[Chaqa]

Actually werewolf knows that we will have to kill him anyway so Jamie should reveal the werewolf and the werewolf should tell us whether Jamie is scum or not. I mean, it's very likely that werewolf was trying to consume a VT since half of us are VTs. If werewolf tried for WW and failed to consume Jamie, well, we would vote for jamie and bam, scum gone.

By that logic WW should our first if Jamie is scum

*out

[damo666]

I think we must assume ww guessed Janitor Jamie.

If ww were to guess VT there were more probable meals than Jamie.

So Jamie is not Janitor ww. So he is 70% town 30% scum.

I think Jamie should reveal. If we don't DK him today he can easily consume tonight and get dk immunity.

It also might help with VCA.

Jamie can't be lying because if he is ww scum can nk him at will and if he is scum we can dk him. Therefore Jamie is telling the truth.

[damo666]

I think we must assume ww guessed Janitor Jamie.

If ww were to guess VT there were more probable meals than Jamie.

So Jamie is not Janitor ww. So he is 70% town 30% scum.

I think Jamie should reveal. If we don't DK him* today he can easily consume tonight and get dk immunity.

It also might help with VCA.

Jamie can't be lying because if he is ww scum can nk him at will and if he is scum we can dk him. Therefore Jamie is telling the truth.

* him/her/them (I am referring to the ww, not Jamie)

[Chaqa]

I think we must assume ww guessed Janitor Jamie.

If ww were to guess VT there were more probable meals than Jamie.

So Jamie is not Janitor ww. So he is 70% town 30% scum.

I think Jamie should reveal. If we don't DK him today he can easily consume tonight and get dk immunity.

It also might help with VCA.

Jamie can't be lying because if he is ww scum can nk him at will and if he is scum we can dk him. Therefore Jamie is telling the truth.

The wolf can’t be night killed. But I do think he’s telling the truth.

I wonder what the WW’s wrong guesses were?

[Bonatogether]

Bob and I play mafia during in person school all the time.

Git gud!

We're not allowed to bring laptops or such, and my county has so tight internet restrictions on their chromebooks that they blocked google maps. Webdip is blocked and there is no way around it.

Peterbot isn't blocked though, so I can still follow the conversation.

That sucks.

Last week, our school blocked Wikipedia for a couple of hours, which was strange.

That's weird. Wikipedia is good.

[Jamiet99uk]

Ok I'm just going to reveal it.

HAMILTON BRIAN is the WEREWOLF

[Bonatogether]

I see your point re J.

Unless bona's D1 vote was a reckless diamond hard Mohs scale 10 bus I can only see him as scum if both Kak and HB also are.

I will examine Bona Kak HB + ? teams and report back. Busy at mo so will be a while but before EON.

Is there a reason you're discounting the chance that Bona was bussing? I agree that he looks really good for it and it's one of the main reasons I'm hesitant to kill him, but I wouldn't put it past him.

You can't keep bringing up this one thing as a justification to not townread me even though everyone admits it was an extremely townie thing to do.

[Bonatogether]

Ok I'm just going to reveal it.

HAMILTON BRIAN is the WEREWOLF

##vote hb

[Jamiet99uk]

Ok I'm just going to reveal it.

HAMILTON BRIAN is the WEREWOLF

##vote hb

That's good.

Now since you're here please answer my question.

[damo666]

##vote Hamilton Brian

Hard luck HB

[Chaqa]

I did the math and there’s not any reason for scum!Jamie to lie about who the WW is, as far as I can tell. If Jamie named a town member and got a mis-kill, tomorrow it would still be 5-4-1 and the Wolf + town would have a 6-4 lead to flip him and keep us out of MYLO/KYLO or whatever the new acronyms are

[Bonatogether]

I still want a proper answer from Bonatogether.

Dude I can't respond during in person school. Next week I don't have in person school, so I will be correspondingly more active.

This is nonsense.

Look at this, everybody.

You can't answer a simple question until NEXT WEEK?

Sub out of the game if you're unable to participate.

Fucking nonsense.

##VOTE BONATOGETHER

I'm not in school the whole day. This is ridiculous.

[Jamiet99uk]

I did the math and there’s not any reason for scum!Jamie to lie about who the WW is, as far as I can tell. If Jamie named a town member and got a mis-kill, tomorrow it would still be 5-4-1 and the Wolf + town would have a 6-4 lead to flip him and keep us out of MYLO/KYLO or whatever the new acronyms are

I'm not lying.

[Bonatogether]

This is nonsense.

Look at this, everybody.

You can't answer a simple question until NEXT WEEK?

Sub out of the game if you're unable to participate.

Fucking nonsense.

##VOTE BONATOGETHER

Get over yourself.

That is not what he said. He said his activity level will be up next week. There will still be responses, they are just slower.

Not everyone can devote every waking hour of their life to the game Jamie. And you of all people should know that there are not subs to swap out with.

Exactly