MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[Kakarroto]

[...] my reads

I'm assuming you're down talking your reads because you don't read anyone as scum or even null-ish. Assuming the whole scum team isn't in your null reads, do you have a sense of why scum seem to have acquired town credit in your reads? Does that make you more suspicious of the demon voters or those that Demon voted for?

I wanted to go to sleep over an hour ago but with all that I remembered I wanted to respond to this.

I haven't considered the votes for demon for my reads; I base them normally mostly on the behaviour, the responses and my gut read. Maybe I just have to relearn from the basics.

That said, from my townreads, food, chaqa and kgray voted D1 for demon. I wasn't too sure about food at first, after an isolated read of his posts they felt very town to me, that should've been around N1 I think, if I remember correctly. There are many instances where I think he has the right idea, some where I disagree but understand where his comment came from. I shall reread him again for the days after that and see if I still see this. chaqa was very active (thanks ghug btw) (even when you were mafia that game), I like his style this game, he decreased a bit in the last bit but he seems still thoughtful and protown. kgray, I think, resonated best with my thoughts, was agreeable but also asked good questions. I guess she reading me as town had the greatest impact compared to others, but it also feels natural.

damo, dargo and brain voted me, the same with demon. well brain is obviously not mafia, dargo is practically confirmed doc, damo also looks goodish, even when I'm having some questionmarks of some posts from him. towards your original question, I would be more concerned about people voting demon than being on the wagon he voted. It would fit the tinfoil theory of mine that mafia caused the elimination of demon, if only for towncred. However it's more likely that my townreads aren't these or, if anything, only one of them.

for the sense of possibly why? thoughtful arguments that feel from town perspective, some train of thoughts that overlayed with mine, reading me as town (though not to a huge amount or else brain would've been weredevilfather in my eyes)

when I read this first I was thinking that this sounded really great from celaph. reading it again, I'm not as excited and looked a bit closer to the phrasing and reasoning, maybe some hidden trail to be thinking, but nothing I could see. Maybe I'm just not open minded enough and didn't subconsciously like 'being taught something'. Then again, I liked learning in school and documentaries. Also i wanted to go to sleep nearly 2 hours ago ...

[Hamilton Brian]

@HB, can you comment on your read of me?

Your vote and the shade you threw at my Damo question suggest that you scum read me. Your justification seems to be an assumption that BB had some mechanical info on me and I'm concerned that you're hiding behind that.

Let me come back to it later. If I don't approach it tonight, remind me tomorrow. In short though, I am reading you less as scum.

[Kakarroto]

what is this question for the question, is that a direct question back?

As I am catching up, I think to myself, "They're asking a question; questions are asked with some assumption behind them." I wanted food to put their thoughts out there.

ok, I guess food didn't get that you asked him his own question back again and wanted for him to answer

@food what do you think of hamilton asking you something wanting an answer and not asking more often (if I haven't overlooked it and it's too late to search for it right now or I oversleep for work I guess)? does he want an answer? does he want to look like questioning? is the game over 200 pages which equals 1000 minutes to read, if I got Macca's speed correct (btw that would be 16 hours and 40 minutes)? something completly different?

[foodcoats]

what is this question for the question, is that a direct question back?

As I am catching up, I think to myself, "They're asking a question; questions are asked with some assumption behind them." I wanted food to put their thoughts out there.

ok, I guess food didn't get that you asked him his own question back again and wanted for him to answer

@food what do you think of hamilton asking you something wanting an answer and not asking more often (if I haven't overlooked it and it's too late to search for it right now or I oversleep for work I guess)? does he want an answer? does he want to look like questioning? is the game over 200 pages which equals 1000 minutes to read, if I got Macca's speed correct (btw that would be 16 hours and 40 minutes)? something completly different?

I probably missed it because it was in blue text and my eyes bled.

I answered elsewhere but I think yavu looked better than rdr. Rdr seems a little... petulant? This game?

[foodcoats]

##VOTE Macca

I think kak said it would be funny to kill Macca after they catch up.

But this isn’t funny.

This is Justice.

[foodcoats]

##VOTE Macca

I think kak said it would be funny to kill Macca after they catch up.

But this isn’t funny.

This is Justice.

More seriously if that’s what Macca gives us we’ll never sort them so they have to die.

[Kakarroto]

I am catched up. Posts incoming.

So that’s all this mighty 170 reread produced?

I got the feeling Macca is actually the correct and best to vote out today, which kinda makes me want to puke because I get what ghug was saying, Macca felt slightly town before all that to me and the response might be just town.

Then again, there are still some hours left, maybe I find something else. If I were you, Macca, I wouldn't bet on it though.

[Kakarroto]

votecheck! rd and yavu snuggle together, what a lovely relationship. bona is on kgray, who is on flum, who is on chaqa. dargo supports kgray. and then two four on ones (both not voting) where I, jamiet, chaqa and damo want Macca to do something and maniac, hamilton, food and ghug wants celaph gone.

jamie just wants to end all of this.

votecheck result! town is headless and mafia is riding the waves.

[Hamilton Brian]

I’ll be moving off Celaph though. I’ll explain tomorrow but I’m a simple man, I feel like it’s staring us in the face.

[ghug]

I’ll be moving off Celaph though. I’ll explain tomorrow but I’m a simple man, I feel like it’s staring us in the face.

Why not explain now?

[ghug]

Hi Brian

[Bonatogether]

I'm going to in person school every day but wednesday this week, so I will not be active during school cause webdip is blocked. Peterbot might not be, so I'll try to read that during class.

[TheMadMonarch]

So that’s all this mighty 170 reread produced?

Some got cut. Question that were answered, or directed at dead players (mostly BB).

[Chaqa]

So that’s all this mighty 170 reread produced?

Some got cut. Question that were answered, or directed at dead players (mostly BB).

Yeah, that’s not good enough.

Sorry, you’re clearly not putting effort in. Either step up or step out.

[Fluminator]

Is this normal for Chaqa to be this engaged? It's been a long time since I played a game here.

[ghug]

Is this normal for Chaqa to be this engaged? It's been a long time since I played a game here.

We killed him D1 last game in what kind of amounted to a referendum on his behavior. So it's abnormal but kind of expected.

[damo666]

[...] my reads

I'm assuming you're down talking your reads because you don't read anyone as scum or even null-ish. Assuming the whole scum team isn't in your null reads, do you have a sense of why scum seem to have acquired town credit in your reads? Does that make you more suspicious of the demon voters or those that Demon voted for?

I wanted to go to sleep over an hour ago but with all that I remembered I wanted to respond to this.

I haven't considered the votes for demon for my reads; I base them normally mostly on the behaviour, the responses and my gut read. Maybe I just have to relearn from the basics.

That said, from my townreads, food, chaqa and kgray voted D1 for demon. I wasn't too sure about food at first, after an isolated read of his posts they felt very town to me, that should've been around N1 I think, if I remember correctly. There are many instances where I think he has the right idea, some where I disagree but understand where his comment came from. I shall reread him again for the days after that and see if I still see this. chaqa was very active (thanks ghug btw) (even when you were mafia that game), I like his style this game, he decreased a bit in the last bit but he seems still thoughtful and protown. kgray, I think, resonated best with my thoughts, was agreeable but also asked good questions. I guess she reading me as town had the greatest impact compared to others, but it also feels natural.

damo, dargo and brain voted me, the same with demon. well brain is obviously not mafia, dargo is practically confirmed doc, damo also looks goodish, even when I'm having some questionmarks of some posts from him. towards your original question, I would be more concerned about people voting demon than being on the wagon he voted. It would fit the tinfoil theory of mine that mafia caused the elimination of demon, if only for towncred. However it's more likely that my townreads aren't these or, if anything, only one of them.

for the sense of possibly why? thoughtful arguments that feel from town perspective, some train of thoughts that overlayed with mine, reading me as town (though not to a huge amount or else brain would've been weredevilfather in my eyes)

when I read this first I was thinking that this sounded really great from celaph. reading it again, I'm not as excited and looked a bit closer to the phrasing and reasoning, maybe some hidden trail to be thinking, but nothing I could see. Maybe I'm just not open minded enough and didn't subconsciously like 'being taught something'. Then again, I liked learning in school and documentaries. Also i wanted to go to sleep nearly 2 hours ago ...

Pardon?

[damo666]

So Macca

Who are your townreads, scumreads and nullls please?

[rdrivera2005]

votecheck! rd and yavu snuggle together, what a lovely relationship. bona is on kgray, who is on flum, who is on chaqa. dargo supports kgray. and then two four on ones (both not voting) where I, jamiet, chaqa and damo want Macca to do something and maniac, hamilton, food and ghug wants celaph gone.

jamie just wants to end all of this.

votecheck result! town is headless and mafia is riding the waves.

At this point I agree Macca should probably go today. We can't afford him later in the game. But it will be a dead day if we just pile on him.

##vote Flum

[Kakarroto]

[...]

Pardon?

Do you have a specific question or do you dislike what I wrote in general? Or did I make a mistake?