MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[dargorygel]

Is anyone else having trouble with the bot?

[dargorygel]

NVM fixed it

[foodcoats]

It's hard to remember a lot of food's performances - they've been rather forgetful since they've primarily featured a lot of lurking.

I don't think food is a lurker?

Food and Flash blend into one person to me. Probably the f names and all that...

If you don’t remember something worcej, why comment on it in a way that suggests you do? I remember you usually being aggro-snark D1, not sloppy and possibly misleading town.

Very scummy IMO.

[foodcoats]

celaph has been making a disproportionate amount of fluffy posts. Several players have been brought up as suspicious already for enthusiastic intros - myself, Macca, Maniac, yavu. But that’s largely fallen off in these cases. Celaph however seems to be stuck in theme/RP land which I can’t help but find to actually be suspicious.

##VOTE celaph

[rdrivera2005]

Hello fine town people and some evil bastards.

Tried to catch up last night but just felt asleep on page 2, seems Darg and Brain talking is good for insomnia. Will try again now.

[dargorygel]

For all those folk who think it's fun to crumb... don't.

[kgray]

##VOTE kgray

You don't get townpoints for this anymore.

Wasn't I scum the time you did give them to me?

Twice, if you count the werewolf game. Hence it no longer being towny.

[yavuzovic]

Does anyone remember any game damo played as mafia? How was he? I find his messages detailed and careful but in a towny way. I guess I have town vibes from him.

[kgray]

She's overrated but still good. I like her and enjoy pushing her buttons.

I bullshit vote at the start of every game. Where have you been?

Lies. I'm neither good nor overrated.

Give yourself some credit. You can be good at this game while still making mistakes.

Catching a few scum here and there doesn't exactly make up for blowing the game in kylo multiple times.... And you're gonna have to try a lot harder than that if you want to pocket me this time

[kgray]

Respect of a strong player in any alignment?

Do you think that ghug and food's votes are out of respect for kgray? Do you think it's a good idea to vote strong players without other suspicion?

Second part that I forgot to respond to - I think voting strong scum players out early is entirely acceptable for a D1 vote.

It's really not. It's no better than voting out players you think are "bad" as town.

[kgray]

Ah it’s started. I’ve missed having a reason to waste time playing forum games.

A big hello and how are you to the new players. Or players that I haven’t played with before. If you haven’t played with me before, what’s your experience of Mafia?

##vote Jamie - because I know it annoys him.

Maniac is scum.

This was also the exact same initial impression I had

Why? It didn't stand out to me at all.

[kgray]

##VOTE kgray

You don't get townpoints for this anymore.

bit boring of a response that sort of feels like its coming from a place of "I guess I -have- to do this".

Boring votes deserve boring responses.

[foodcoats]

Do you think that ghug and food's votes are out of respect for kgray? Do you think it's a good idea to vote strong players without other suspicion?

Second part that I forgot to respond to - I think voting strong scum players out early is entirely acceptable for a D1 vote.

It's really not. It's no better than voting out players you think are "bad" as town.

Agreed with kgray here. I found this a weird statement to be made by worcej who is usually the champion of town-lives-and-dies-together. The general hypothesis being advanced is kgray=good-either-way so the logical town move is wait-and-see, but worcej is subtly advocating a kgray votekill.

[kgray]

It's hard to remember a lot of food's performances - they've been rather forgetful since they've primarily featured a lot of lurking.

I don't think food is a lurker?

He quite often is as non-town alignments. Much rarer as town.

But my memory on him is sort of fuzzy. Too many other players with similar non-distinguishable non-unique playstyles. Sick burn

I don't think you're right. iirc the last game he was in I incorrectly scumread him for lurking, but when I went back and checked his previous games I didn't find anything AI about it.

[kgray]

this is a nice analytical foodcoats though

if he starts trying to narrow down pr lists gun him down

Huh? Mafia know which PRs are in the game already.

First thing I've read this game worthy of discussion.

So is this

A) a brainbomb townslip
B) scum brainbomb wanting it to seem like A
C) scum brainbomb not realising his own advantage?

None of these would surprise me. I'm going to assume A for the timebeing.

Since when are you not suspicious of townslips?

[kgray]

So a quick review of the setup says that there's always:
8 VT
1 Miller

And then all of the other roles on each side except, missing one of these pairs:
(1) Town Roleblocker / Janitor
(2) Inventor / Ninja
(3) Doctor / Goon
(4) Watcher / Driver
(5) Journalist / Godfather
(6) Cop / Stalker

So we can probably figure out the exact setup down the line, but we should wait until the Werewolf has been neutralized.

Helpful townChaqa or naughty scumChaqa pretending to be helpful?
Assuming town for now.

How was that helpful? lmao

[kgray]

celaph has been making a disproportionate amount of fluffy posts. Several players have been brought up as suspicious already for enthusiastic intros - myself, Macca, Maniac, yavu. But that’s largely fallen off in these cases. Celaph however seems to be stuck in theme/RP land which I can’t help but find to actually be suspicious.

##VOTE celaph

Interesting. Please elaborate more on how Maniac has moved away from suspicion since his opening post?

Also why do you think Macca's posts have been less fluffy than celaph's?

[brainbomb]

this is a nice analytical foodcoats though

if he starts trying to narrow down pr lists gun him down

Huh? Mafia know which PRs are in the game already.

werewolfy doesnt

[brainbomb]

I think celaph is a terrible vote presently. everyones posts are in establishment phases; which you need. Gonna strongly disagree with your assessment fudcoots

[brainbomb]

Vecna entry is a bit simplistic and agreeable as opposed to scathing. I dont feel intimidated by vecna entry.

rivera entry feels oddly campy as well.