You always say too little, regardless of alignment.
TOWNIER END
GUYS!!! Vecna made a mistake. Conf scum here!!! Come get him. $$vote vecna
I don't hate third parties, but this particular third party is way too powerful.
I don't think it's anyone's "fault". This is how ND has designed his game. The setup has an intentionally strong third party which both the Town and the Mafia need to worry about, and may even have to temporarily collaborate to stop. It's like that intentionally because that's how ND has written the setup.
I know I have been talking about it too, but I think we should let to discuss the setup after the game ends.Jamiet99uk wrote: ↑Mon Mar 22, 2021 9:43 pmI don't think it's anyone's "fault". This is how ND has designed his game. The setup has an intentionally strong third party which both the Town and the Mafia need to worry about, and may even have to temporarily collaborate to stop. It's like that intentionally because that's how ND has written the setup.
Obviously I know Celaph is mistaken, but is there anyone who still thinks Celaph is scum here?celaph wrote: ↑Mon Mar 22, 2021 8:12 pmTOWNIER END
Jamie -- If he's somehow scum then we just concede that the luck was not in our favor and try to win M66. Treat him like conf town.
rdr -- I've been saying this since the beginning, but I'm not getting any scum vibes from this man. Couple this with being almost conf non-alien (conf assuming Vecna is telling the truth which I think is the case) makes him a very bad kill in the coming days.
ghug -- If this is ghug's scum game then it's a really clean scum game. I think he has picked up on the right details and argued over the right points in a way that feels very natural and genuine. For examples, see how he worked around Jamie's PR status, how he has challenged Vecna, and how he has handled my infected status.
Bob -- I could see this slot being scum (more likely alien imo), but if so then kudos to him for the confidence that he has played with. I willingness to behave like that D1 and absorb the pressure unnecessarily. The lack of hesitation in shooting Bunny. I also townread the hell out of his activity pattern. He feels the right mixture of please how we've preformed against scum and lost in dealing with the alien.
Vecna -- Vecna has played like a town person probably playing a townier game that both Bob and ghug. But at times something feels just not quite right with how he's acting. I think both ghug and rdr have done a better job than I at highlighting why that is at various times. Treat him as a town, but carefully. Be extra careful if Fox flips scum.
Worcej -- Total gut read here. I'll hedge here so I don't look like a fool if I'm wrong, but I like Worcej here.
Fox -- He strikes me as sharp, yet struggles to convert that sharpness into towny-ness. His early analysis of the early wagon was poor. The way he handled the GM "slip" with his item felt awkward. The person he reminds me most of is Donny from M63 who ended up town so I might be wrong here.
Maniac -- I hate that I'm doing this, but to some extent I'm scumreading Maniac's towniness. I really hope that I'm wrong because that would show change to his town game that I really like, but he's caught my attention in positive ways that remind me of our time as alien together. For example, I think his current read of the situation is decent, but I just worry that it is coming from a place of knowledge.
Damo -- He is doing a mixture of things that feel towny and feel really scummy. He doesn't really feel mafia-y so I'm guessing that this is our alien, but I don't have huge confidence in my ability to read him.
SCUMMIER END
Hey, that's how I feel.
Users browsing this forum: Ernst_Brenner
