Mafia 65: Dreamland II [Hidden]

[BobMcBob]

nice dk result, relatively expected
im still down for a push on fox tomorrow but depending on tonights events maybe celaph will be a good option

[ghug]

nice dk result, relatively expected
im still down for a push on fox tomorrow but depending on tonights events maybe celaph will be a good option

Are you the alien or are you just not paying attention?

[BobMcBob]

nice dk result, relatively expected
im still down for a push on fox tomorrow but depending on tonights events maybe celaph will be a good option

Are you the alien or are you just not paying attention?

my activity levels tend to drop over the course of a mafia game, but i am still (mostly) paying attention
i just dont know how much there is to do in a night phase
i like fox as a wagon, i can easily get behind maniac
there are a few others id consider if neither of those worked
there are reasons to go after celaph though, unless they suddenly got voided and it hasnt been explained at all well in the thread

[ghug]

nice dk result, relatively expected
im still down for a push on fox tomorrow but depending on tonights events maybe celaph will be a good option

Are you the alien or are you just not paying attention?

my activity levels tend to drop over the course of a mafia game, but i am still (mostly) paying attention
i just dont know how much there is to do in a night phase
i like fox as a wagon, i can easily get behind maniac
there are a few others id consider if neither of those worked
there are reasons to go after celaph though, unless they suddenly got voided and it hasnt been explained at all well in the thread

There aren't just reasons. We're at alien KILO.

[BobMcBob]

Are you the alien or are you just not paying attention?

my activity levels tend to drop over the course of a mafia game, but i am still (mostly) paying attention
i just dont know how much there is to do in a night phase
i like fox as a wagon, i can easily get behind maniac
there are a few others id consider if neither of those worked
there are reasons to go after celaph though, unless they suddenly got voided and it hasnt been explained at all well in the thread

There aren't just reasons. We're at alien KILO.

well theres a chance scum goes after celaph tonight, in which case obviously we go after someone else, unless scum kill fails on him
and if he gets uninfected tonight and we have enough reason to believe hes not alien, we perhaps dont go after him
although otherwise pretty sure he should be daykill tomorrow

[Vecna]

I'm just going to point out, for the record, that I began to air my suspicions of Thamrick during D2, and it was not until the start of D3 that the GM's clarification to Bonatogether led to some of you potentially suspecting him for mechanical reasons.

Just for those of you who like to go on about how I'm bad at this game as Town and never get anything right.

Credit is also due to Jasnah who also seriously attempted to get a Thamrick wagon going D2.

Calling out scum on D2 is so late though.

I bet tham even started lurking because I called his hunting on D1 fake and unsmoothe repeatedly

(im mostly making this post because I know certain people love it when I bloviate and aggrandize)

[damo666]

Looking at all the voting I conclude Fox is not scum.

[rdrivera2005]

Looking at all the voting I conclude Fox is not scum.

Could you explain this reasoning?

[Foxcastle]

Looking at all the voting I conclude Fox is not scum.

As much as I welcome this “analysis,” not even I see how you could have come to it.

[Jamiet99uk]

I'm just going to point out, for the record, that I began to air my suspicions of Thamrick during D2, and it was not until the start of D3 that the GM's clarification to Bonatogether led to some of you potentially suspecting him for mechanical reasons.

Just for those of you who like to go on about how I'm bad at this game as Town and never get anything right.

Credit is also due to Jasnah who also seriously attempted to get a Thamrick wagon going D2.

You finally caught scrim, after just 64 games. I'm happy for you! You must be pissed the GM stole your thunder.

We're supposed to be looking for scrim?

No wonder I was getting it wrong.

[Jamiet99uk]

I currently scrim-read Damo and Maniac and one of Ghug / Vecna.

Scrimteam: Please let me live tonight as my result may be useful.

[damo666]

Looking at all the voting I conclude Fox is not scum.

As much as I welcome this “analysis,” not even I see how you could have come to it.

Because of the amount of day 2 bussing it would imply.

All 3 dead scum were voting Fox (although Bunny and brain moved off), and of the suspects ghug rdr and Maniac all finished on Fox.

[damo666]

I currently scrim-read Damo and Maniac and one of Ghug / Vecna.

Scrimteam: Please let me live tonight as my result may be useful.

I assure you I am of this world and I am not Mafia and I still have my kit.

[Maniac]

Looking at all the voting I conclude Fox is not scum.

As much as I welcome this “analysis,” not even I see how you could have come to it.

Because of the amount of day 2 bussing it would imply.

All 3 dead scum were voting Fox (although Bunny and brain moved off), and of the suspects ghug rdr and Maniac all finished on Fox.

What is this rubbish? Thamrick ended up on Fox but bunny and BrainBomb (and ?vecna) all pushed Ifischl over the line when Fox was still the counter wagon.

I have to say Damo this is some of the worst analysis I’ve ever seen.

[Jamiet99uk]

I'll do the coloured EoD vote counts in case that helps.

[Jamiet99uk]

Day One:

Chaqa (10) - Jamiet99uk, jasnah, Vecna, lfischl, brainbomb, celaph, thamrick, ghug, e.m.c^42, damo666
Jamiet99uk (7) - Macca573, BobMcBob, Maniac, worcej, BunnyGo, Hellenic Riot, Bonatogether
jasnah (2) - Chaqa, Foxcastle


Day Two:

lfischl (9) - Foxcastle, damo666, Jamiet99uk, worcej, jasnah, celaph, BunnyGo, brainbomb, Vecna
Foxcastle (5) - Maniac, ghug, rdrivera2005, thamrick, Bonatogether
damo666 (2) - BobMcBob, Macca573

Unvoted (1) - lfischl


Day Three:

brainbomb (10) - Vecna*, Macca573, BobMcBob*, Jamiet99uk*, Bonatogether*, Foxcastle*, Maniac, ghug*, worcej*, brainbomb*
thamrick (2) - Damo666, celaph
Foxcastle (1) - rdrivera2005

Non-voter: (1) - Thamrick


Day Four:

thamrick (9) - damo666*, Jamiet99uk, Foxcastle, Macca573, Vecna, rdrivera2005, celaph, ghug, Maniac
celaph (2) - worcej, thamrick
Foxcastle (1) - BobMcBob

[Foxcastle]

I'll do the coloured EoD vote counts in case that helps.

Some people knit, other bake, Jamie does colored EOD vote counts.

(Which are appreciated.)

[Jamiet99uk]

Day Two:

lfischl (9) - Foxcastle, damo666, Jamiet99uk, worcej, jasnah, celaph, BunnyGo, brainbomb, Vecna
Foxcastle (5) - Maniac, ghug, rdrivera2005, thamrick, Bonatogether
damo666 (2) - BobMcBob, Macca573

Unvoted (1) - lfischl

I tend to agree with Maniac rather than Damo here.

To conclude that Foxcastle is not scrim, based on the voting of dead scrims, does not appear to make logic.

[Jamiet99uk]

I'll do the coloured EoD vote counts in case that helps.

Some people knit, other bake, Jamie does colored EOD vote counts.

(Which are appreciated.)

I also cook (but I don't really "bake" because I'm not interested in cakes or pastries or other sweet things). I ought to try making pies.

[Jamiet99uk]

Let's look at the three confirmed scum and their voting on D2:

Brainbomb:
Voted for me,
then Damo,
then Maniac,
then back to Damo,
then an INVALID vote for Lfischl,
then Bonatogether,
then Damo again,
then another INVALID vote for Lfishl,
then Maniac,
then Damo,
then Macca,
then Foxcastle,
then finally onto Lfischl where he ended up.

Brainbomb was on Foxcastle for an hour as EoD approached. His move off Foxcastle occurred with 8 minutes to go, when Foxcastle was only one vote behind Lfishl.


BunnyGo:
Voted for Bonatogether,
Unvoted for quite a long period,
Voted for Foxcastle,
Then finally moved off Fox onto Lfischl where he ended up.

BunnyGo's vote switch from Fox to Lfischl put Lfischl in the lead instead of Fox. BunnyGo's move off Foxcastle was the exact point at which Foxcastle ceased to be the leading wagon at EoD2.


Thamrick:
Voted for Bonatogether,
Unvoted for quite a long period,
Voted for Foxcastle and then stayed there.

Thamrick's votes follow BunnyGo's votes all day until EoD. Thamrick was online with 30 minutes or thereabouts to go until EoD.