Mafia 65: Dreamland II [Hidden]

[Jamiet99uk]

remaining scumteam is likely thamrick, fox, maniac, damo
bob is likely the alien

Why do you think that Bob is the Alien?

[brainbomb]

##End

lets hammer tham actually

[Jamiet99uk]

##End

lets hammer tham actually

Yes that's good but why do you think Bob is the Alien?

[brainbomb]

What?

[damo666]

@Jamie Bob is likely town but he could be alien with a gun couldn't he? Shoots Bunny and we all assume he's town.

and he writes in alien

[brainbomb]

bob was born amidst salt and goo

[damo666]

Re item claim it's today or never I think but I have really looked at all the items to work out the pros and cons tbh.

[Jamiet99uk]

What?

You said "Bob is likely Alien" and I'm asking you why you think so.

[ghug]

@tham, if you're the alien, claim now and we'll leave you alive as long as you let us direct your kill.

[rdrivera2005]

remaining scumteam is likely thamrick, fox, maniac, damo
bob is likely the alien

Do you think scumteam jailed Thamrick or just didn't Jail anyone to give him credit? With a Cop in the open? Bold move from scum.

[Jamiet99uk]

##End

lets hammer tham actually

Oh, Brainbomb, do you realise your vote needs to be on Thamrick to do that?

Check out this guy, he doesn't even know who he's voting for.

[damo666]

@Jamie Bob is likely town but he could be alien with a gun couldn't he? Shoots Bunny and we all assume he's town.

and he writes in alien

However he's not because there is only one alien and that is Tham. The GM error implies Tham is not town, being jailed implies not scum (probably), ergo Tham is the alien.

[brainbomb]

Jamie how do you feel about basing thamricks alignment off of GM error

[worcej]

I am totally okay with the vote, but you gave him only 9 minutes to respond lol...

Actually he's had over 150 hours.

And, you'll notice, Thamrick absolutely did just go offline and offer no thoughts, no reads, no nothing.

We're halfway through Day 3. Let me just summarise Thamrick's game up to this point:

Day One:
Said he was busy in real life. Promised to catch up by EoD 1.
Voted for Chaqa at EoD1 without posting any thoughts or comments so either didn't catch up or didn't want to help us.

Night 1:
No posts at all.

Day Two:
Says he is caught up and offers townreads on Bob, Jasnah, Celaph, plus scumreads on Bona and Fox, with no commentary on any of these supposed reads.
Says he is busy in real life and so can't participate more. Votes Foxcastle.

Night 2:
In jail presumably.

Day Three (today):
Claims jailed. Says there's not much to report from the Jailor QT.
Says he is busy in real life. Gets snarky at me for demanding participation. Fucks off without commenting further, despite being a lead wagon.

I said very clearly yesterday and last night that today was Thamrick's final chance to make a contribution for town or he should die.

He should die. I'm entirely content with my endvote on him.

Sure, I am also voting him - it makes sense to flip thamrick.

I was just commenting you went from asking for answers and times up in 9 minutes lol...

[BobMcBob]

Unvote (4) Bonatogether BobMcBob rdrivera2005 damo666
BunnyGo (3) celaph Maniac Foxcastle

yea this days going great

BunnyGo had just flipped and those people had not yet moved their votes.

Again, WTF is going on with Brainbomb's sudden horrible attitude after Bunny's flip?

yeah, it is strange
because the day actually was going pretty great
and votes at the beginning of the day mean next to nothing

[BobMcBob]

I will just say I am not cumreading anyone

You had several scumreads last night, what happened to all of them? They can't all be invalidated by Bunny's flip.

More weirdness from Brainbomb.

to be fair, this was in response to a rather amusing splling mistake by rdr
although does brain have any reads right now?

[BobMcBob]

##CALL GM

-If the deputy dies, will his death message/role pm reveal to us what his sanity was? Will we learn if he was paranoid/insane etc?

-Did your last answer mean that the alien can actually be targeted by investigative actions?

-What does the alien night immunity extend to exactly? This is rather important for the remainder of the game. His role pm states it applies to everything -except certain items-.

-What message does a PR or item-user receive if they targetted the alien with an action that the alien is immune to.

1. I wasn't planning on revealing the sanity in the flip but I will speak to Darg about it.
2. Alien is immune to being killed at night. It also will appear to be town aligned. The alien researcher however can detect alien DNA if the alien does not night kill. Apart from that it can be effected by items, roles, etc as anyone else can be.
3. They would simply receive a similar message that a commuting player -ritual- might receive, aka your target is untargetable.

so this means the alien is immune to basically no night actions
odd way to phrase nk immunity in the setup

[Jamiet99uk]

Jamie how do you feel about basing thamricks alignment off of GM error

I'm not a great fan of such things, and it's not the reason I'm voting Thamrick.

[Jamiet99uk]

Sure, I am also voting him - it makes sense to flip thamrick.

I was just commenting you went from asking for answers and times up in 9 minutes lol...

No, he went from being online and useless to not being online.

[Jamiet99uk]

I will just say I am not cumreading anyone

You had several scumreads last night, what happened to all of them? They can't all be invalidated by Bunny's flip.

More weirdness from Brainbomb.

to be fair, this was in response to a rather amusing splling mistake by rdr
although does brain have any reads right now?

Yes, he reads you as the Alien.