Mafia 65: Dreamland II [Hidden]

[Jamiet99uk]

Yes. But this week had been hectic. I won’t be able to read all by EOD. And I’m with kids.

Ok then, to assist you, YES Lfischl claims to have eaten the Bodacious Basil, and claims to have selected Macca for the reveal.

Oh. Then it seems the decision is whether to kill lfischl, kill Macca, or strongly townread both and let the holly go.

Why would killing Macca be one of the leading options in this scenario? That doesn't make much sense to me.

[Jamiet99uk]

Will you be activating the holly today? If yes, then in whom?

What?

Don’t ask me to catch you up. But you should catch up

Again why are you asking THAMRICK if he has used an item claimed by LFISCHL ?

[BunnyGo]

What?

Don’t ask me to catch you up. But you should catch up

Again why are you asking THAMRICK if he has used an item claimed by LFISCHL ?

I was asking lfischl, no?

[jasnah]

I'm exhausted and this discussion is asinine, going around in circles on ground that I could swear had been covered around eight hours ago.

In theory I like killing Foxcastle more, but I like the people on the lfischl wagon somewhat more than the people on the Foxcastle wagon, kind of because Jamiet the mostly clear is on lfischl. And what about the three people on damo? Are any of them even here?

Help me out.

[Jamiet99uk]

Don’t ask me to catch you up. But you should catch up

Again why are you asking THAMRICK if he has used an item claimed by LFISCHL ?

I was asking lfischl, no?

No, the post you quoted was by Thamrick. T. H. A. M. Rick.

[BunnyGo]

Ok then, to assist you, YES Lfischl claims to have eaten the Bodacious Basil, and claims to have selected Macca for the reveal.

Oh. Then it seems the decision is whether to kill lfischl, kill Macca, or strongly townread both and let the holly go.

Why would killing Macca be one of the leading options in this scenario? That doesn't make much sense to me.

If the scum reads are strong enough to skip the scan?

[thamrick]

Quick break at work. Only 20 or so mins til I’ve gotta go. Of the two wagons, I much prefer the Foxcastle wagon so...

##VOTE Foxcastle

WHY do you prefer that one, Tham-anchor?

In an answer that is sure to infuriate you, mostly gut.
Foxxy seems to be needling people. Lfischl seems more genuine.

[Jamiet99uk]

BunnyGo is either being incredibly stupid or incredibly annoying at the moment.

[jasnah]

Is this just scumslip by Bunnygo? Bunnygo, thamrick and lfischl are scum. Thamrick is holding the herb, but lfischl claimed it to save his skin. So Bunny forgets who had claimed it, and asks the individual with actually the herb whether he ingested it.

[BunnyGo]

Again why are you asking THAMRICK if he has used an item claimed by LFISCHL ?

I was asking lfischl, no?

No, the post you quoted was by Thamrick. T. H. A. M. Rick.

Ok. On phone with two kids and playing chess. My bad.

[Jamiet99uk]

Oh. Then it seems the decision is whether to kill lfischl, kill Macca, or strongly townread both and let the holly go.

Why would killing Macca be one of the leading options in this scenario? That doesn't make much sense to me.

If the scum reads are strong enough to skip the scan?

The problem with that is it rewards the potential Scum!Lfischl gambit here.

[Jamiet99uk]

Is this just scumslip by Bunnygo? Bunnygo, thamrick and lfischl are scum. Thamrick is holding the herb, but lfischl claimed it to save his skin. So Bunny forgets who had claimed it, and asks the individual with actually the herb whether he ingested it.

That would be hilarious if true.

[thamrick]

Is this just scumslip by Bunnygo? Bunnygo, thamrick and lfischl are scum. Thamrick is holding the herb, but lfischl claimed it to save his skin. So Bunny forgets who had claimed it, and asks the individual with actually the herb whether he ingested it.

That would be hilarious if true.

Lol it would be but unfortunately I don’t have the herb

[celaph]

I feel a little bad killing them while they are away, but I prefer it to the lfischl wagon at the moment. I feel like he is a smart player who seems to have failed to turn thoughts and questions into reads.

I think he had some decent insight when he was commenting that Jamie was playing town or that Jasnah's response to the scumslip accusation looked bad. Yet the only "reads list" (if you can call it that) he has put out has been exceptionally minimalist and didn't give any indication of who he thought was town. He also called the votes on him pathetic, but didn't seem to turn around and draw conclusions about whether he thought that they were pathetic town or scum pushing for a miskill.

[BunnyGo]

BunnyGo is either being incredibly stupid or incredibly annoying at the moment.

BunnyGo is incredibly distracted but trying to play the eod.

[celaph]

Why would killing Macca be one of the leading options in this scenario? That doesn't make much sense to me.

If the scum reads are strong enough to skip the scan?

The problem with that is it rewards the potential Scum!Lfischl gambit here.

Do you think the way it's playing out feels like a scum gambit? It feels towny to me.

[Vecna]

I don't mind Damo being a wagon, though I understand rdr's argument to not flip him today. While the time has likely passed for making herb recommendations, I think that Damo would be a fine flip.

If Damo does end up as town, I recommend taking another look at Vecna's scumread of him today. I rather disliked how it felt couched in his use of EMC's metric on Damo at times feeling like he was building himself an out for Damo flipping town.

Ive never made it a secret I cannot read Damo.

I do draw some connection between HR dying and his allignment, yes.

Because the target that HR was deathtunneling turned out to be our PR.

My little offhand comments to EMC have little to do with me trying to not take responsibility. If I vote someone, I own it. Regardless of alignment.

Note also how im not voting Damo atm, because im not certain at all. Its definately a possibility he is scum. He is not my favored wagon. He is just the easy vote for people.

[Jamiet99uk]

If the scum reads are strong enough to skip the scan?

The problem with that is it rewards the potential Scum!Lfischl gambit here.

Do you think the way it's playing out feels like a scum gambit? It feels towny to me.

Why?

Lfischl has made a "last post" and said they won't be back. That's *exactly* what you'd do here if you were making a Wifom-based "oh scum wouldn't do that" gambit.

I refer you to my previous posts about why Lfischl was super scummy before even mentioning the herb. Did you have any thoughts on the end-voting crap?

[dargorygel]

GM Note
Apologies to all. When I saw the question about "Who is Area-51" my mind translated that as "who is scum." Thus my facetious, and in the end incorrect, answer. I hope I didn't cause too many wrong rabbit trails.

To state more clearly than ND did... apparently it is best to ask HIM stuff.

I'm about to do a VC.

[celaph]

After a reread I still think Macca is likely town.

It is an AREA-51 claim, but the Town who scan like that are gone.

I've actually gotta go now. See you all later!

This seems like if Macca were scum here they got away with freely outing the Researcher which the alien can now kill and absorb. Im sketical that after maccas post 1; they still didnt know researcher scanned as 51 too

@brain, why do you think town Macca would know that AR scans as area-51 if the GM didn't include it in a list of roles that did?