MAFIA 64 - The Z Files - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[BunnyGo]

Well, let's just wait a second. Let's run this through.

As far as my notes have it, the unscanned seem to be myself and Bunny.

Everyone else is either confirmed town, or to some degree non-mafia or non-alien.

Pros for Bunny being a kill?

Cons for Bunny being a kill?

I had an initial problem with Celaph's scans but if they are a straightshooter like Maniac is having us believe, then Ezio and Ghug are clear of being mafia.

Pros: Bunny had 0 mech clearing
Con: Bunny is towny af for anyone reading and solving
Pro: Bunny doesn’t mind
Con: Bunny doesn’t mind

[ghug]

Well, let's just wait a second. Let's run this through.

As far as my notes have it, the unscanned seem to be myself and Bunny.

Everyone else is either confirmed town, or to some degree non-mafia or non-alien.

Pros for Bunny being a kill?

Cons for Bunny being a kill?

I had an initial problem with Celaph's scans but if they are a straightshooter like Maniac is having us believe, then Ezio and Ghug are clear of being mafia.

Pros: Bunny had 0 mech clearing
Con: Bunny is towny af for anyone reason and solving
Pro: Bunny doesn’t mind
Con: Bunny doesn’t mind

Pro: Bunny lists Bunny not minding as a con.

[Donny Dude]

Well, let's just wait a second. Let's run this through.

As far as my notes have it, the unscanned seem to be myself and Bunny.

Everyone else is either confirmed town, or to some degree non-mafia or non-alien.

Pros for Bunny being a kill?

Cons for Bunny being a kill?

I had an initial problem with Celaph's scans but if they are a straightshooter like Maniac is having us believe, then Ezio and Ghug are clear of being mafia.

Pros: Donny had 0.000001121 mech clearing
Con: Donny is kinda towny for anyone reading and solving
Pro: Donny doesn’t mind
Con: Donny doesn’t mind

[BunnyGo]

Well, let's just wait a second. Let's run this through.

As far as my notes have it, the unscanned seem to be myself and Bunny.

Everyone else is either confirmed town, or to some degree non-mafia or non-alien.

Pros for Bunny being a kill?

Cons for Bunny being a kill?

I had an initial problem with Celaph's scans but if they are a straightshooter like Maniac is having us believe, then Ezio and Ghug are clear of being mafia.

Pros: Bunny had 0 mech clearing
Con: Bunny is towny af for anyone reason and solving
Pro: Bunny doesn’t mind
Con: Bunny doesn’t mind

Pro: Bunny lists Bunny not minding as a con.

Yes!

[brainbomb]

Maniac should be shooting in the pool of potential alien targets. mafia may not exist anymore

[brainbomb]

also maybe if we could start rereading bona d1 and d2 and see who both macca and bona ignore most, or if they shared a mutual scumread whoch neither pushed

[brainbomb]

Aliens are probably jacked

I would assume this is not just cheap talk. Bona might be serious here indicating a very small scumteam

[e.m.c^42]

@EMC? You getting this?

Don't tempt me now.

Consider it my last request

You've already gotten one with your star-crossed, secret agent love story with Jamie ;p

[brainbomb]

At the very least, Damo seems conflicted.

So Damo, if you're making no false statements, are you mafia?

and are you alien?

I just dont think mafia member asks this to fellow mafia member

[e.m.c^42]

Aliens are probably jacked

I would assume this is not just cheap talk. Bona might be serious here indicating a very small scumteam

I'm leaning towards no veteran players on scum team due to kills lol

[e.m.c^42]

Maniac should be shooting in the pool of potential alien targets. mafia may not exist anymore

I...may have lost the logic here.

[brainbomb]

That's not how mafia works. Follow your gut. Vote for who you think is scum, because that information is very valuable to us. We don't get good VCA from someone trying to make false competition in the wagons (I think).

Bob, we could make the wagons closer and get some sweet sweet VCA if we both vote for bona

From what I've read so far I don't dig it yet. Maybe I'll change my mind later, but I like your thinking .

This is an interesting response to kgray from bob

[brainbomb]

You are lurking. Your questions are like little flags planted to announce you've been here.

Anyways, it is 8 hours into a very weird day 1. I'm just saying, kgray is always suspicious. But you don't seem to be you from the last 2 games.


(I'm kidding about my kids joke. It's only funny with the adorable and enthusiastic delivery...you'd have to be here or imagine it)

I'm the 4th most active person so far, so I don't see how you can accuse me of lurking.

People said this last game too.

I say this from a bit too much experience, people tend to get suspicious when your posts are largely irrelevant, have little content, are uncertain or hedgy or contain little to no original thoughts. Which always annoyed me personally because I was always bad at it whether I was scum or not, and always gathered suspicion. Btw, how many games has bona played?

I feel like bob dances around bona a bit too much to be natural

[brainbomb]

So, I believe I haven't played a game with bona yet, so can somebody who has give me a quick rundown on his standard play as town?

then he repeats it with less words for some reason

[e.m.c^42]

Hm, I wouldn't mind Maniac shooting Bob. Put my vote down for that.

[brainbomb]

iirc celaph (or someone) said he did that last game too? Btw bona, it is not a good voting method, vote based on who you think is scum, not to make competitive wagons.

It's d1 and every wagon is based on the flimsiest junk. Barring an honest-to-god scumslip, this day is data collection.

That's not how mafia works. Follow your gut. Vote for who you think is scum, because that information is very valuable to us. We don't get good VCA from someone trying to make false competition in the wagons (I think).

coaching a scum buddy?

[brainbomb]

Macca, I see you lurking here. Please start responding to things or giving some substantial posts or reads.

coaching

[ghug]

Bob, we could make the wagons closer and get some sweet sweet VCA if we both vote for bona

From what I've read so far I don't dig it yet. Maybe I'll change my mind later, but I like your thinking .

This is an interesting response to kgray from bob

Brain, nobody's allowed to traditionally scumhunt this game. Get with the program.

[brainbomb]

and What if my role is on that list? am I still worth just sacrificing for vca

it'd hurt, but I'd still be more in favor of it than a Macca, lfischl, or Ezio wagon

I agree with Donny and others, bona really rubs me the wrong way with his VCA, competitive wagons and completely counterintuitive daykill opinions. But I kinda townlean him, given what I've heard of his meta and stuff. Just seems misguided/quirky imo.

Passes off bona as just being quirky

[brainbomb]

Holey Smokes!

So very sorry for today. I am now a prefect, and the things I've had to do took much longer than expected.

I starting reading through at about 9:30 (it's now 9pm is Queensland, for reference) in my spare time, and have only just caught up to the present now.

Bob is right, I like to mark all posts I want to respond to, and then do them all at once. I will be writing those replies now.

Very sorry again.

referencing bobs defense of him is interesting. maybe too overstated