MAFIA 64 - The Z Files - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[BunnyGo]

okay so a genius, is there a reason hes town?

celaph said so

[BunnyGo]

okay so a genius, is there a reason hes town?

celaph said so

When he had every reason to believe we had constructed a mech-guilty on him.

[ghug]

##VOTE jasnah

I just started my read (game's in the 2nd over...already 1-1 with India at bat).

What are you seeing?

The obstinance is a shield front having opinions rather than a shield from sharing their justifications. It makes sense as scummy behavior and at the very least it's going to make her impossible to sort out without a flip or mechanical info. She's in the alien POE pool and I kinda believe that mafia is gone, and I don't really see a use in flipping celaph today.

[brainbomb]

im drinking stella and crown apple rightt now so youre sorta making sense and you seem really excited I just dont have a clue what youre even claiming or who it implicates. So good job?

[ghug]

im drinking stella and crown apple rightt now so youre sorta making sense and you seem really excited I just dont have a clue what youre even claiming or who it implicates. So good job?

Who?

[brainbomb]

##VOTE jasnah

I just started my read (game's in the 2nd over...already 1-1 with India at bat).

What are you seeing?

The obstinance is a shield front having opinions rather than a shield from sharing their justifications. It makes sense as scummy behavior and at the very least it's going to make her impossible to sort out without a flip or mechanical info. She's in the alien POE pool and I kinda believe that mafia is gone, and I don't really see a use in flipping celaph today.

I sorta agree but tonally jasnah is just like nothing ive ever seen. why jasnah over someone like like donny who is smart enough to know lovers probably were a free claim

[brainbomb]

im drinking stella and crown apple rightt now so youre sorta making sense and you seem really excited I just dont have a clue what youre even claiming or who it implicates. So good job?

Who?

bun bun
I have no idea what hes so excited about. I cant understand what hes claiming, who hes claiming attacked him, when he even got attacked or what it all even means

[Ezio]

im drinking stella and crown apple rightt now so youre sorta making sense and you seem really excited I just dont have a clue what youre even claiming or who it implicates. So good job?

Who?

bun bun
I have no idea what hes so excited about. I cant understand what hes claiming, who hes claiming attacked him, when he even got attacked or what it all even means

Well to my eyes it looks like Bunny is claiming bunny was saved the night I was roleblocked, so there actually isn't any mechanical reason to assume I'm scum. The prevailing theory was that I was the mafia who was assigned to do the night kill, but was roleblocked and that is why there was no mafia kill.
No attempted kill+Ezio roleblock=Ezio mafia assigned to the kill.

If Bunny was actually saved, suddenly that equation looks like:
Attempted kill+Ezio roleblock=Ezio wasn't the mafia assigned to the kill.
When you combine that with Celaph claiming I'm not mafia, it suddenly looks a lot like I'm not mafia.

[brainbomb]

alrighty, you are town
bunny is town

no one objected.

let us move on and find the last assholes and call it good.

[brainbomb]

im drunk someone please make sense

[brainbomb]

oh boy im gonna have to try

[brainbomb]

bunny you seem like a liar and I want you to die. nobody would wait to reveal like you have

[Maniac]

I don’t believe Celaph regards their RB. But it doesn’t really matter. At some point he dies. The info has has given so far is useful even if the mafia clears he has provided need to be taken with a pinch or two of salt.

I’m not sure that he is the best kill today however. If Damo was saved N2 then we definitely have at least one mafia or SK out there that can kill night after night. We are firm favourites for this game but until we find the night killer we can’t win. Celaph can wait even if he doesn’t get any more scans for us.

Unless they can be verified as mafia and SK clears, we need to kill from Ezio, Bona, Donny, Jasnah, Bob, Bunny first. Then if we haven’t found the killer look at vecna, Ghug, HB.

I hereby hardclaim the one-shot commuter.

[Maniac]

##vote Ezio

[Vecna]

Town clears:
brain
Demon
rdr

Almost certain town:
damo
Hamilton

Very likely town:
ghug
Vecna
Bunny

Not mafia (Assuming Vecna is town) in order from towniest to most extra-terrestrial:

EMC
Maniac

jasnah

Aliens:
celaph

Everyone else (in order from towniest to scummiest):

Bonatogether
Ezio
BobMcBob
Donny Dude

look at this kid chipping himself and ghug in with me, lmao

[Vecna]

##Call GM

If the Alien prober targets person X, but is also targeted by the Parrot, how would this resolve? Would he still RB person X and get a result there?

Second question: Would the alien prober's action be roleblocked if he got roleblocked by a different role? How is the priority ordering there?

[Maniac]

##Call GM

If the Alien prober targets person X, but is also targeted by the Parrot, how would this resolve? Would he still RB person X and get a result there?

Second question: Would the alien prober's action be roleblocked if he got roleblocked by a different role? How is the priority ordering there?

Janie has already answered that one road block doesn’t stop another roadblock. If a prober is RB his scan won’t deliver a result.

[jasnah]

@ Maniac hard claims commuter after many times claiming to have discarded commuter?

If any more scum, probably Bob more than Donny Dude or Bunny

##vote celaph

[rdrivera2005]

Well, if celaph doesn't have a scan for us and there's no likelihood of him getting a scan off again while he gets rbed again and again, we might as well
##vote celaph.

This smells like the aliens decided they didn't want us getting more scans out, and they even might lie about future scan results now. Rather than risking that, we should eliminate celaph.

I'd honestly rather have no scan results than wifom scan results from here on in.

This sounds like lazy town opportunism.

If I was RB'd by JOAT then they can't target me again. If I was RB'd by parrot they just have to not target me and I get actual results.

Why Parrot would target you? This doesn't make any sense. Mafia JOAT could be possible, but why would he roleblock you instead of Vecna? The only real possibility I see here is Bob (or Bunny is making a really elaborated plan).
Another possibility is Celaph isn't the Prober, so he can't give a result right now.

[rdrivera2005]

I don’t believe Celaph regards their RB. But it doesn’t really matter. At some point he dies. The info has has given so far is useful even if the mafia clears he has provided need to be taken with a pinch or two of salt.

I’m not sure that he is the best kill today however. If Damo was saved N2 then we definitely have at least one mafia or SK out there that can kill night after night. We are firm favourites for this game but until we find the night killer we can’t win. Celaph can wait even if he doesn’t get any more scans for us.

Unless they can be verified as mafia and SK clears, we need to kill from Ezio, Bona, Donny, Jasnah, Bob, Bunny first. Then if we haven’t found the killer look at vecna, Ghug, HB.

I hereby hardclaim the one-shot commuter.

Humm. I think we found an Alien...