MAFIA 64 - The Z Files - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[celaph]

kgray, is there a specific team you think I'm on, or is it a "generally shitty" sort of read?

I think you're mafia and celaph is the underdog, yeah.

Do you think that scum me is not concerned with drawing attention to ghug and myself in the way I have been?

[BunnyGo]

No, I've just been away for a little while and am working through the backlog of messages. Though I'll comply with your request. HR brought up a good point that damo outed himself to save me. Do you think that Damo takes that risk?

I’d have to reread the whole situation. I don’t remember the last game Damo was a town PR. But as scum, he tries to go deep. So the only reason he’d fake this as scum is if he games out “they’ll decide to never kill mr because there are two such investigators. And I scan alien to them anyways. So this buys me lots of time.” I can see it. As kgray says, he doesn’t like risks. But I don’t think he’d view this as a risk.

Town Damo enjoys solving. I don’t really understand what lead him to claim. Was it his silly opening post about being unsure about his roles alignment? Maybe. But then he didn’t have to go and claim PR. Just VT would have been enough.

He felt less mech sure than I’m used to from him. He’s usually very mech aware. Not necessarily having considered all the angles, but has an opinion.

This is an interesting take. Damo could very easily go very deep if he was an alien claiming conspiracy theorist, but only if he knew conspiracy theorist wasn't in play otherwise. I'd say it's unlikely, but it's a possibility at least.

There are two alien conspiracy theorist cards

[ghug]

kgray, is there a specific team you think I'm on, or is it a "generally shitty" sort of read?

I think you're mafia and celaph is the underdog, yeah.

Do you think that scum me is not concerned with drawing attention to ghug and myself in the way I have been?

Do you think you've been drawing an unusual amount of attention to the two of us?

[ghug]

I’d have to reread the whole situation. I don’t remember the last game Damo was a town PR. But as scum, he tries to go deep. So the only reason he’d fake this as scum is if he games out “they’ll decide to never kill mr because there are two such investigators. And I scan alien to them anyways. So this buys me lots of time.” I can see it. As kgray says, he doesn’t like risks. But I don’t think he’d view this as a risk.

Town Damo enjoys solving. I don’t really understand what lead him to claim. Was it his silly opening post about being unsure about his roles alignment? Maybe. But then he didn’t have to go and claim PR. Just VT would have been enough.

He felt less mech sure than I’m used to from him. He’s usually very mech aware. Not necessarily having considered all the angles, but has an opinion.

This is an interesting take. Damo could very easily go very deep if he was an alien claiming conspiracy theorist, but only if he knew conspiracy theorist wasn't in play otherwise. I'd say it's unlikely, but it's a possibility at least.

There are two alien conspiracy theorist cards

To be clear, he means two conspiracy theorist cards that are aligned with the town and detect aliens (this was confusing to me).

This is a good point though. It makes it much more likely damo would actually try to do this.

[brainbomb]

##Vote maniac

[celaph]

Was celaph on line EOD1? Did he have an opportunity to claim?

I know it's been said, but yes to both.

[BobMcBob]

I’d have to reread the whole situation. I don’t remember the last game Damo was a town PR. But as scum, he tries to go deep. So the only reason he’d fake this as scum is if he games out “they’ll decide to never kill mr because there are two such investigators. And I scan alien to them anyways. So this buys me lots of time.” I can see it. As kgray says, he doesn’t like risks. But I don’t think he’d view this as a risk.

Town Damo enjoys solving. I don’t really understand what lead him to claim. Was it his silly opening post about being unsure about his roles alignment? Maybe. But then he didn’t have to go and claim PR. Just VT would have been enough.

He felt less mech sure than I’m used to from him. He’s usually very mech aware. Not necessarily having considered all the angles, but has an opinion.

This is an interesting take. Damo could very easily go very deep if he was an alien claiming conspiracy theorist, but only if he knew conspiracy theorist wasn't in play otherwise. I'd say it's unlikely, but it's a possibility at least.

There are two alien conspiracy theorist cards

Dang I totally missed that. That makes it a bit more likely, but still a significant risk if he doesn't know that both weren't dealt.

[Bonatogether]

If you all have not seen the handfourth council video, watch it. That is funny and maybe a little too realistic. lol

Where can I find this?

[Donny Dude]

If you all have not seen the handfourth council video, watch it. That is funny and maybe a little too realistic. lol

Where can I find this?

Just look it up I could not find the original, but there are a lot of videos on it.

[celaph]

Also are people not realizing that the psychotrooper messes with ALL scans? Not just alien ones? So figuring out if that role is in play is huge, otherwise our cops are basically useless.

I think the better argument is not cops, but the other investigative roles. Cops are really just reduced to parody cops which is still pretty valuable. For the other town investigative roles it's a targeted multiperson roleblock.

[celaph]

No I actually think maniac might be disinterested town.
celaph probably an alien
ghug maybe sk or scum but very not town

What changed between your earlier opinion and this one?

[BunnyGo]

This is an interesting take. Damo could very easily go very deep if he was an alien claiming conspiracy theorist, but only if he knew conspiracy theorist wasn't in play otherwise. I'd say it's unlikely, but it's a possibility at least.

There are two alien conspiracy theorist cards

To be clear, he means two conspiracy theorist cards that are aligned with the town and detect aliens (this was confusing to me).

This is a good point though. It makes it much more likely damo would actually try to do this.

What was unclear?

[BunnyGo]

This is an interesting take. Damo could very easily go very deep if he was an alien claiming conspiracy theorist, but only if he knew conspiracy theorist wasn't in play otherwise. I'd say it's unlikely, but it's a possibility at least.

There are two alien conspiracy theorist cards

Dang I totally missed that. That makes it a bit more likely, but still a significant risk if he doesn't know that both weren't dealt.

If you were a conspiracist, would you CC here?

[ghug]

There are two alien conspiracy theorist cards

To be clear, he means two conspiracy theorist cards that are aligned with the town and detect aliens (this was confusing to me).

This is a good point though. It makes it much more likely damo would actually try to do this.

What was unclear?

"alien conspiracy theorist" implies alien alignment.

[celaph]

I think you're mafia and celaph is the underdog, yeah.

Do you think that scum me is not concerned with drawing attention to ghug and myself in the way I have been?

Do you think you've been drawing an unusual amount of attention to the two of us?

I think my townread of you as well as kgray's challenge of my townread have collectively brought a notable amount of attention to us two. It's definitely not all my doing, but I still ask the question of whether I would try and connect myself to my teammate like this after that D1.

[Bonatogether]

If you all have not seen the handfourth council video, watch it. That is funny and maybe a little too realistic. lol

Where can I find this?

Just look it up I could not find the original, but there are a lot of videos on it.

Thanks!

[BunnyGo]

Do you think that scum me is not concerned with drawing attention to ghug and myself in the way I have been?

Do you think you've been drawing an unusual amount of attention to the two of us?

I think my townread of you as well as kgray's challenge of my townread have collectively brought a notable amount of attention to us two. It's definitely not all my doing, but I still ask the question of whether I would try and connect myself to my teammate like this after that D1.

That’s why you’re scumread?!

[celaph]

There are two alien conspiracy theorist cards

Dang I totally missed that. That makes it a bit more likely, but still a significant risk if he doesn't know that both weren't dealt.

If you were a conspiracist, would you CC here?

I discourage any conspiracist CCs. It would be totally possible for them both to be telling the truth and at best you get a 1 for 1. That's not worth outing the PR at this point.

[brainbomb]

Hows life bunny

[BunnyGo]

Dang I totally missed that. That makes it a bit more likely, but still a significant risk if he doesn't know that both weren't dealt.

If you were a conspiracist, would you CC here?

I discourage any conspiracist CCs. It would be totally possible for them both to be telling the truth and at best you get a 1 for 1. That's not worth outing the PR at this point.

Exactly