MAFIA 64 - The Z Files - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[brainbomb]

I also know who the raptor is

[kgray]

I think we should vote from the Mafia goon claimants as being the most likely to hold interesting scum roles.

Let's start with ##vote Bona

Are you even reading this game? Bona is the most obv-town person here.

[brainbomb]

I think we should vote from the Mafia goon claimants as being the most likely to hold interesting scum roles.

Let's start with ##vote Bona

Are you even reading this game? Bona is the most obv-town person here.

ehh idk bout that he did out the coroner

[kgray]

Also, celaph gives me bad vibes. They're the wrong colour (they're like a pink-orange, with hints of red). (everyone's got a colour) (you're like a green blue, with orange polka dots; which is good)

Orange is the worst color, I could get behind a celaph wagon again.

[damo666]

I think we should vote from the Mafia goon claimants as being the most likely to hold interesting scum roles.

Let's start with ##vote Bona

Are you even reading this game? Bona is the most obv-town person here.

I thought I was

[damo666]

Also, celaph gives me bad vibes. They're the wrong colour (they're like a pink-orange, with hints of red). (everyone's got a colour) (you're like a green blue, with orange polka dots; which is good)

Orange is the worst color, I could get behind a celaph wagon again.

No. Not celaph today.

[BobMcBob]

If y'all want to ask questions while I can answer them, they need to be soon.

Hmm, okay. Top scumread and top townread. Who and why? Broad question but might as well ask since you haven't given any lately.

Well... You just missed my cut off, but here we are.

Top Town:
BB or kgray.

Frankly, I love playing with brain bomb, so as well as thinking that you're helping, wishful thinking is probably involved.

Kgray, well, she's always out there, fighting the good fight. She's pointing out inconsistencies, helping people who are missing knowledge, and saying things I agree with.


Top scum?

Well, when you posted this, it was Bozo, but clearly not now.

Other than that, maybe Bona? I really didn't like his EOD1, but hey, I've never been on at EOD, maybe it is that chaotic.

Also, celaph gives me bad vibes. They're the wrong colour (they're like a pink-orange, with hints of red). (everyone's got a colour) (you're like a green blue, with orange polka dots; which is good)

What the actual heck? I know you're slightly confused in this game normally but these colours sound like you're completely pulling them out of thin air. I don't buy it. I'll need a better reason for a celaph scumread than that, even if this was largely joking.

EoD is usually fairly chaotic, but chaoticising the EoD is not scum indicative. What bona did was counterproductive but seemed pretty townie anyway.

[kgray]

I live for the reality where HR drew two loud roles and then can't act because he claimed his discard.

He should probably have lied about his discard in that case lol

Is lying to the town not bad? If he tries to claim something else, he'll get cc'd. Especially if his role involves him being spotted, I feel that this is a bad plan to take.

If HR got a loud town role and the loud mafia role to choose from, and he picked the town role, he should just claim he discarded VT. Because if he doesn't, he can't use his role without drawing ridiculous amounts of pressure and it would be virtually impossible to convince people he's not the loud mafia role he discarded.

The only benefit to loud-town!HR outing that he discarded the loud mafia role is that once he flips, if there's another loud role, that person is cleared. But that's not worth it, especially not on D1.

But it doesn't matter, because he claimed he discarded loud mafia, and as I've explained earlier, any loud person is now clear.*

*except under the wildest of tinfoil theories which I'm not willing to entertain at the moment.

[BobMcBob]

I live for the reality where HR drew two loud roles and then can't act because he claimed his discard.

He should probably have lied about his discard in that case lol

Is lying to the town not bad? If he tries to claim something else, he'll get cc'd. Especially if his role involves him being spotted, I feel that this is a bad plan to take.

He claimed discarding the loud mafia role, which is an awful play if he kept it because if someone hears his visit they will almost certainly report it and he will get daykilled.

[damo666]

I think we should vote from the Mafia goon claimants as being the most likely to hold interesting scum roles.

Let's start with ##vote Bona

Are you even reading this game? Bona is the most obv-town person here.

OK

How about

##vote brain

the only maf goon discard claimant who was not on top 2 wagons D1

[brainbomb]

I think we should vote from the Mafia goon claimants as being the most likely to hold interesting scum roles.

Let's start with ##vote Bona

Are you even reading this game? Bona is the most obv-town person here.

OK

How about

##vote brain

the only maf goon discard claimant who was not on top 2 wagons D1

pat pat
nice work

[kgray]

Also, celaph gives me bad vibes. They're the wrong colour (they're like a pink-orange, with hints of red). (everyone's got a colour) (you're like a green blue, with orange polka dots; which is good)

Orange is the worst color, I could get behind a celaph wagon again.

No. Not celaph today.

Why? Do you townread him? You don't even seem to have strong scumreads that could be other candidates, so what's wrong with celaph?

[brainbomb]

I think we should vote from the Mafia goon claimants as being the most likely to hold interesting scum roles.

Let's start with ##vote Bona

Are you even reading this game? Bona is the most obv-town person here.

OK

How about

##vote brain

the only maf goon discard claimant who was not on top 2 wagons D1

bunny was a 6 wagon and in the lead when I got in my car. not much I can do about that

[BobMcBob]

I think we should vote from the Mafia goon claimants as being the most likely to hold interesting scum roles.

Let's start with ##vote Bona

Why start with bona? What makes you vote him over ghug or celaph?

Firstly alphabet, secondly I townread ghug, thirdly celaph is not a good dk target. fourthly why did you omit brain?

Because I heavily townread brain, I do not suggest him as an alternate vote over bona.

[Hamilton Brian]

I don't want to miss out on asking this in case of forgetting.

@Ezio, did you discard Town Doctor or Loud Doctor?

[kgray]

I think we should vote from the Mafia goon claimants as being the most likely to hold interesting scum roles.

Let's start with ##vote Bona

Are you even reading this game? Bona is the most obv-town person here.

OK

How about

##vote brain

the only maf goon discard claimant who was not on top 2 wagons D1

He was gone for an interview. He was active during EOD up to then, so why does him not being on a top 2 wagon mean he's scummy? You think scum!brain decided to make a bunch of noise and push lots of wagons, then when it mattered in the end, he pretended to be busy so he didn't have to take accountability for his vote? How does that track?

[Hamilton Brian]

Sorry for being MIA

Been a busy few days. I’ve spent a lot of time at my wife’s grave.

She’s not dead. She thinks I’m digging a pond.

I’ll be back on later.

Good lord.

[kgray]

@Bob I'd like your current top 3 scumreads, please.

[BobMcBob]

I'm going to go out on a limb and say two or three of kgray, brain, demon, and celaph are on the same non-town team.

I'm going to take your limb (for dinner) and say you're wrong.

As you take the limb, what makes you suggest Bona is wrong?

Kgray and bb are probably my two strongest townreads, which in itself is enough to say I doubt his prediction is correct. On top of that I cannot see any way to inherently connect them in such a way you can be sure 3 are on the same team. That's just extra unlikeliness though. I'm keeping his limb though. Makes a nice stew.

[kgray]

@damo, who do you actually scumread?