MAFIA 64 - The Z Files - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[brainbomb]

ghig jealous of my life or something? I dunno go eat some bacon itll chill you out

The thing that gives me pause is that you're clearly trying to start a fight with me under the guise of being upset about a push that is no longer happening.

you are still pushing it as far as I can see

[BobMcBob]

I thought there was a minute possibility I guessed bobs exact role

Ooooh, can you whisper it in my ear? I'd like to hear this.

[kgray]

I'm not scumreading him anymore.

Why not?

If I'm being totally honest I couldn't remember why I scumread him in the first place by the time I voted for him, and I think he's more inclined to avoid reacting emotionally to being the second place wagon halfway through D1 if he's scum. I'm not convinced he's town yet either, but emotional brain has always been someone I've been able to read, so I'm not too concerned.

Hate this post.

Also you just said that you misread him last game you were town because he was acting emotionally, so....

[brainbomb]

I thought there was a minute possibility I guessed bobs exact role

Ooooh, can you whisper it in my ear? I'd like to hear this.

cannibal alien, buddy with bunny.

[BunnyGo]

My guess at deal distribution is

8 town town
3 scum scum
10 mixed

And I would guess 3 of the mixed discarded town.

My prediction is 1 SK 5 mafia/alien 15 town

Confidence interval?

[Donny Dude]

demonrhk has been pretty solidly town. the pushes by jasnah are bizarre, and she keeps bringing up vecna as if vecna is her mentor

I agree on those points.
I was hoping she would post about why demon is scum in more detail, but nothing.

Having had a *very* long conversation with her about diplomacy play styles, I would describe hers as “strong tactics, gut emotional motivations”. I expect something similar here as town or scum.

Alright, that is good to know.

[BobMcBob]

## vote ghug

Because Vecna seems like a sensible person to follow and I'm not sure I'll remember to check this thread again

Why does Vecna seem like a sensible person to follow?

Hi Jasnah - I don’t think we’ve played together before. Vecna’s Not the worst person to follow, but try and make your own decisions. Some players have such good scum games they can lead you astray so easily. If you have to follow anyone, follow me. I usually solve the game at some point. Ask anyone.

Thank you Maniac. It's only a pity they haven't made you mod yet so you can solve the site's cheating problems as well. But I agree, it's good to make your own decisions about things in this game.

[brainbomb]

im not afraid of being called scum, what I am absolutely offended by is being treated as expendable meat on day 1. And to do so when there isnt a single voter on me actually explaining why im scum is the more offensive act

[BobMcBob]

I thought there was a minute possibility I guessed bobs exact role

Ooooh, can you whisper it in my ear? I'd like to hear this.

cannibal alien, buddy with bunny.

Of course, how could I forget. (Wait, so we're both cannibal alien? Fun times ahead)

[kgray]

What do you make of kgray criticizing my wagon while she's content to sit on it for limited reasons?

What do you make of it?

It rubs me the wrong way, but I can't put my finger on whether I'm just grumpy because you're voting for me or not.

I bet you're still grumpy that I said I got Bunny more than you

[BobMcBob]

based on the data the only thing weve learned is that its unlikely there wiuld be more than one maf goon if there are even any

What’s the logic behind this?

there were 5 maf goon cards, 3 have been discarded

3 have *apparently* been discarded, one or more could be goons and lying. It's somewhat unlikely but definitely a possibility.

[bozotheclown]

Vibes of nanook.

No idea who this person is, but they seemed to barely even play Diplomacy, and what little they did, not well. Why sign up for webDiplomacy if you have no interest in playing Diplomacy?

+1000000

We should all play more Diplomacy. One day I'm going to get that mafia game going. Celaph and HR are have already sold their souls and volunteered to join me

Can I sign up for this game?

[Bonatogether]

im not afraid of being called scum, what I am absolutely offended by is being treated as expendable meat on day 1. And to do so when there isnt a single voter on me actually explaining why im scum is the more offensive act

I'm keeping my vote on you.

[ghug]

ghig jealous of my life or something? I dunno go eat some bacon itll chill you out

The thing that gives me pause is that you're clearly trying to start a fight with me under the guise of being upset about a push that is no longer happening.

you are still pushing it as far as I can see

Then you're not reading the posts you're replying to.

[BunnyGo]

What’s the logic behind this?

there were 5 maf goon cards, 3 have been discarded

3 have *apparently* been discarded, one or more could be goons and lying. It's somewhat unlikely but definitely a possibility.

Claim of 4 now...

[ghug]

Why not?

If I'm being totally honest I couldn't remember why I scumread him in the first place by the time I voted for him, and I think he's more inclined to avoid reacting emotionally to being the second place wagon halfway through D1 if he's scum. I'm not convinced he's town yet either, but emotional brain has always been someone I've been able to read, so I'm not too concerned.

Hate this post.

Also you just said that you misread him last game you were town because he was acting emotionally, so....

No, because he wasn't acting emotionally.

[kgray]

No idea who this person is, but they seemed to barely even play Diplomacy, and what little they did, not well. Why sign up for webDiplomacy if you have no interest in playing Diplomacy?

+1000000

We should all play more Diplomacy. One day I'm going to get that mafia game going. Celaph and HR are have already sold their souls and volunteered to join me

Can I sign up for this game?

YES!!!

[BobMcBob]

It's very easy for any scum to lie about this information though. If they desired, they could just claim they discarded the role they actually chose, and it wouldn't look any different from a town claiming a discard. (Once again, I would rather talk about this later when bozo comes along with a long speech about how it narrows the miskill pool, confirms 50-70% of scum roles in play with 80-90% certainty and outs at least one guaranteed scum or something like that).

fyi, we're not using that word anymore.

Scumslip

Who is scumslipping where?

[kgray]

If I'm being totally honest I couldn't remember why I scumread him in the first place by the time I voted for him, and I think he's more inclined to avoid reacting emotionally to being the second place wagon halfway through D1 if he's scum. I'm not convinced he's town yet either, but emotional brain has always been someone I've been able to read, so I'm not too concerned.

Hate this post.

Also you just said that you misread him last game you were town because he was acting emotionally, so....

No, because he wasn't acting emotionally.

Oh, I see what you meant. In that case, I hate your post slightly less.

[bozotheclown]

Why not?

Are you going to tell what you discarded, or are you taking a position against claiming that?

Neither

In that case, can you explain why you are not going to reveal what you discarded?