MAFIA 63: THE SCOURGE [HIDDEN]

[President Eden]

No the cop shouldn't claim. Are you on crack PE?

I just wanna vote end on HB, what's so wrong with that?

[BunnyGo]

bunny is drunk and we should ignore them

I'll have you know....I'm out of beer, going to Allagash later today.

Not drunk. Just pissed (and not like that Jamie).

[aarodactyl]

Unless the cop has beem remarably unlucky or incompetent they must have some decent info to share.

Bozotype survey - Is it time for the cop to hardclaim and reveal? YES or NO.

I'll kick off with a YES. Doc can probably save tonight so we're very likely to fet a further scan.

Cop Survey

YES 1
NO 0

14 votes outstanding

Only if it's HB.

I think we all agree that HB should claim, so I'll put you down as a no

[Fluminator]

This Bunny vs Bona bit is so... what's that word Flum?... that I am having trouble sorting it out. I feel like I'm watching a wrestling bout.

I've seen town Bunny like this before. It's NAI with him.

[damo666]

No the cop shouldn't claim. Are you on crack PE?

Anyone voting YES and believing it isn't helping town run through the end. We don't need 2 townclears. We need scum caught. Get the data. Find them all.

What if the cop is NK'd tonight without having revealed? We've lost all the data.

[Chaqa]

Have you played this game with Brainbomb before?

I know brainbomb used to fake claim a lot as town, but I think he usually had a reason when he was scum.

He was the godfather...fake claim, retract. Get Bona deaded (either goon or town), and when scanned by cop who wonders what's up, gets a clean. We all think "oh brainbomb...you did it again!"

This is what I believe as well.

[Jamiet99uk]

Question: if hamilton is scum, why not vote Bona?

What? How does the second part of the question relate to the first part?

Sorry...timing issue:

If hamilton is scum, why did he not vote Bona in the last 30 seconds?

Ah, I like this question better now, thanks.

I initially read it as if it said "If you think hamilton is scum, why not vote for bona today?" (i.e. encouraging people scumreading HB to leave him today and vote Bona instead).

Now I understand your question I actually think it's a pretty important question for anyone behaving as though Hamilton is obv-scum.

[BunnyGo]

No the cop shouldn't claim. Are you on crack PE?

Anyone voting YES and believing it isn't helping town run through the end. We don't need 2 townclears. We need scum caught. Get the data. Find them all.

What if the cop is NK'd tonight without having revealed? We've lost all the data.

Oh my god...Oh oh oh...I never thought that they could LET US KNOW LATER!!! (or more subtly)

[President Eden]

HB is being so evasive about the cop question that he's probably mafia on principle.

If he were VT, he would be happy to play along with the game after being so fired up about the Balki/HR fakeclaim play last game.

If he were the actual Cop, he wouldn't put his teammates through the unnecessary tedium when we had all known since EOD2 that he was the Cop.

[Hellenic Riot]

No the cop shouldn't claim. Are you on crack PE?

Anyone voting YES and believing it isn't helping town run through the end. We don't need 2 townclears. We need scum caught. Get the data. Find them all.

What if the cop is NK'd tonight without having revealed? We've lost all the data.

There is a debate to be had over whether the cop should claim with reports at the final second at EoN

It is not the same debate as the cop outing now for no reason whatsoever

[Chaqa]

This is the second most annoyed I've ever been by a person or thing called Hamilton.

[President Eden]

This is the second most annoyed I've ever been by a person or thing called Hamilton.

I'm going to tell Doctor Watson and Tink!!!!!

[bozotheclown]

Yes. To clarify, that list is "bozotheclown, celaph, Hamilton Brian, worcej". I think the chance that all three scum are in this list is very small. However, it's also the list of people that haven't made a strong case of HB (as far as I can tell. and yes, I include HB in that list)

If Hamilton is scum, which is looking likely, his teammates are probably already voting for him.

HR and EMC?

Or Donny, or you.

[damo666]

No the cop shouldn't claim. Are you on crack PE?

I just wanna vote end on HB, what's so wrong with that?

Nothing. He's had a chance to explain and failed miserably.

[BunnyGo]

This is the second most annoyed I've ever been by a person or thing called Hamilton.

....what's the first?

[President Eden]

Actually I'm changing my answer to the survey to NO. We should just kill HB and let the Cop call their own shot.

[Jamiet99uk]

No the cop shouldn't claim. Are you on crack PE?

Anyone voting YES and believing it isn't helping town run through the end. We don't need 2 townclears. We need scum caught. Get the data. Find them all.

Agree. At this stage, with so many people still alive, townclears will just become corpses anyway.

[Fluminator]

How is the narrative of this day about whether a cop should essentially claim for no reason and a poll. Like wtf am I reading.

I have a hard time believing PE would be driving this narrative as town. Especially when we're probably really close to an auto if they're covered a bit longer.

[President Eden]

How is the narrative of this day about whether a cop should essentially claim for no reason and a poll. Like wtf am I reading.

I have a hard time believing PE would be driving this narrative as town. Especially when we're probably really close to an auto if they're covered a bit longer.

Cross-post, I changed my mind after thinking about it more.

[Hellenic Riot]

How is the narrative of this day about whether a cop should essentially claim for no reason and a poll. Like wtf am I reading.

I have a hard time believing PE would be driving this narrative as town. Especially when we're probably really close to an auto if they're covered a bit longer.

Damo and Aarodactyl are the people pushing this most, not PE.