MAFIA 63: THE SCOURGE [HIDDEN]

[President Eden]

Where's your list, aaro?

[Jamiet99uk]

Bona is either

a) scum
b) cop with inno on Jamie
c) not thinking through his tier classification very well

Which is it Bona?

a

Don't be silly Brainbomb.

Oh wait...

[President Eden]

Bona is either

a) scum
b) cop with inno on Jamie
c) not thinking through his tier classification very well

Which is it Bona?

a

Why do I believe you all of a sudden

[Bonatogether]

Bona is either

a) scum
b) cop with inno on Jamie
c) not thinking through his tier classification very well

Which is it Bona?

a

Why do I believe you all of a sudden

do you think that there were 3 scum on the block d2

[Bonatogether]

a

Why do I believe you all of a sudden

do you think that there were 3 scum on the block d2

and do you think i'd bus brain when we just nailed ghug

[President Eden]

I just want to point out that although my final vote was in the wrong place, the whole ghug/brainbomb thing should basically lock clear me as town.

It's quite clear from brainbomb's hard claim Cop that brainbomb had no interest in being the patsy to save ghug, and that ghug's push could not have been preplanned or coordinated as an attempt to split the vote and save ghug, as I had previously thought. Plus, brainbomb was the more valuable power role. Rather, it's clear that ghug was trying to put distance between himself and brainbomb.

When I actually pulled the trigger on voting, ghug felt compelled to follow. That put enough pressure on the Godfather for him to effectively claim mafia by hard claiming Cop.

If I were mafia, I'd have known what was going on with ghug trying to distance. Why pile onto brainbomb and effectively out him? Why not just kill Bona instead and whip votes that way?

[President Eden]

Why do I believe you all of a sudden

do you think that there were 3 scum on the block d2

and do you think i'd bus brain when we just nailed ghug

You apparently think I would

[damo666]

Bona's reads, in order of post count d3:

Tier 1: bona, jamie
Tier 2: aaro, chaqa, hb
Tier 3: eden, damo, emc, flum, donny, rivera, hr, bozo
Tier 4: worcej, rivera, celaph, bunny

Eden: I know a lot of people townread him but I'm not as much of a fan of him. His d2 was wrong, and his post lamenting that he should have been on the ghug wagon felt off to me. Also he was the first vote for brain. However, he's put out solid reads today. We should vote him at some point if he's not nked in the next couple days.

aaro: his d2 reads post was somewhat accurate. I'm also getting town vibes from him.

damo: "no bussers on ghug" is dumb. Claiming scum is 4 people on me plus maybe celaph. Also one of the early voters of brain.

chaqa: Not getting scum vibes. campaigned against voting ND d1, which is town. Also this post is good. Voted ghug.

Jamie: caught ghug. This cannot have been a bus because brain wouldn't have felt obligated to try and sacrifice himself if it was. town

emc: I had to read his iso cause I could only remember him calling ghug daddy. Hasn't contributed much. also that stuff from today about him. hasnt posted reads. is a goon

flum/durga: apparently there was a thing with summit where durga/ghug/bozo bussed him d1, and there are similarities to this. idk about this, but durga was evidently thinking about summit d1 because she posted "whatever happened to summit". flum hasn't done a lot of stuff to solve. d2 tied me with ghug and emc.

worcej: possibly scum if the mafia tried to do the same thing they did d2 on d1. That would also mean HR would be scum. We should vote worcej tomorrow to find out.

Donny: campaigned against nd wagon d1. voted me d2. Had a good post about how early lead towns often lose. Did a ghug/brain analysis post. I'm not sure.

rivera: argued with HR a lot d1, but then they stopped and went after me for no apparent reason. made me a wagon. see HR comment

HR: helped start my wagon. argued a lot with rivera d1, but then they went for me for no apparent reason. argued that ghug didnt scumslip. went for brain.

bozo: hasn't put out anything of value. went for ND. went for worcej. voted me. a

HB: voted ghug. apparently is cop???? if someone could explain that to me I'd really appreciate it.

celaph: still feeling like they're imitating last game.

bunny: eden's theory is bunk. voted brain d2, then did the weird "sheep the inno" junk. claimed vig when THERE AINT ONE.

also why is going to do a thing where you'll be gone for a while now called "doing a bona"

Bona is either

a) scum
b) cop with inno on Jamie
c) not thinking through his tier classification very well

Which is it Bona?

What are you basing this off of? Just the fact jamie is his top town read? Because that's pretty true for me as well.

He has Jamie in the same Tier as himself implying he KNOWS Jamie's alignment.

[Bonatogether]

He has Jamie in the same Tier as himself implying he KNOWS Jamie's alignment.

Tier 1 is the "I'd never vote them aside from mechanical confirmation of scum" category. Not the 100% clear.

Also if I was scum why would I do this that blatantly.

[President Eden]

I love how we all jumped to Options A & B when Option C is well over 90% to be the case.

[damo666]

He has Jamie in the same Tier as himself implying he KNOWS Jamie's alignment.

Tier 1 is the "I'd never vote them aside from mechanical confirmation of scum" category. Not the 100% clear.

Also if I was scum why would I do this that blatantly.

Ok. I was just mocking your Tiers.

I don't think anyone thinks you are scum.

How you have me in Tier 3 astounds me.

[damo666]

I love how we all jumped to Options A & B when Option C is well over 90% to be the case.

Of course it's C.

[Bonatogether]

Ok. I was just mocking your Tiers.

I don't think anyone thinks you are scum.

How you have me in Tier 3 astounds me.

I put a lot of people in tier 3

[damo666]

Ok. I was just mocking your Tiers.

I don't think anyone thinks you are scum.

How you have me in Tier 3 astounds me.

I put a lot of people in tier 3

Yes, well done.

[Bonatogether]

we should vote worcej

[damo666]

Ok. I was just mocking your Tiers.

I don't think anyone thinks you are scum.

How you have me in Tier 3 astounds me.

I put a lot of people in tier 3

Yes, well done.

Includes EMC who you describe as goon yet you have 4 people in Tier 4. There are only 3 outstanding scum. Frankly your Tier system is crap.

[damo666]

we should vote worcej

We should await copscan data before determining who to vote.

[Bonatogether]

I put a lot of people in tier 3

Yes, well done.

Includes EMC who you describe as goon yet you have 4 people in Tier 4. There are only 3 outstanding scum. Frankly your Tier system is crap.

idk if emc is an actual goon but they are a goon.

so? I'm not claiming to be 100% on the money here. Is hedging my bets wrong?

[Bonatogether]

we should vote worcej

We should await copscan data before determining who to vote.

but worcej is a solid vote anyways

[worcej]

I just want to point out that although my final vote was in the wrong place, the whole ghug/brainbomb thing should basically lock clear me as town.

It's quite clear from brainbomb's hard claim Cop that brainbomb had no interest in being the patsy to save ghug, and that ghug's push could not have been preplanned or coordinated as an attempt to split the vote and save ghug, as I had previously thought. Plus, brainbomb was the more valuable power role. Rather, it's clear that ghug was trying to put distance between himself and brainbomb.

When I actually pulled the trigger on voting, ghug felt compelled to follow. That put enough pressure on the Godfather for him to effectively claim mafia by hard claiming Cop.

If I were mafia, I'd have known what was going on with ghug trying to distance. Why pile onto brainbomb and effectively out him? Why not just kill Bona instead and whip votes that way?

I don’t think anyone gets any town credit for voting BB tbh