MAFIA 63: THE SCOURGE [HIDDEN]

[damo666]

Here are ND's D1 post counts in his most recent games (I went back to include his 2 most recent known scum games):

M63 (?): 4
M62 (town): 77
M52 (town): 71
M51 (town): 20
M49 (scum): 12
M46 (3P): 35
M1007 (town): 123
M43 (town): 16
M42 (town): 59
M41 (town): 14
M1006 (town): 18
M40 (town): 57
M39 (scum): 3

I know D1 was over a holiday, but compare ND's last post to his last D1 post in his 2 most recent scum games:

M63:

I hope to be able to play some tomorrow I got alot going on tonight sry

M49:

Havent had much time this game. Hopefully will have more time later on

M39:

Honestly, I haven't had much time for this, but I am really trying to get into it today. If all the 1st week of school paperwork i have cooperates. Anyway, Tom is pretty scummy has been from the start. My wager is on him. ##VOTE TOM

For Chaqa

[Fluminator]

Ghug and bozo have felt fine so far. I don't think they're worthy of wagons.

Worcej has felt much more diplomatic than i remember as town, but i could see a town motive for it so I'd feel kind of icky killing him for it.

I understand suspicion of Vecna but if he's claiming roleblock he can survive imo. It could be a scum gambit but as long as we have PRs we can let him scum gambit.

Don't really want to vote for any of those 4 today.

[damo666]

Damo, do you enjoy playing as town or scum more?

I enjoy them both in different ways.

As town I enjoy the challenge of solving the puzzle and my enjoyment increases as the game progresses and we have more data. I tend to find D1 a chore.

As scum I enjoy the bluff and misdirection and find glee in seeing town barking up wrong trees.

Of the two I guess I prefer being town.

I found being scum 3 times in a row (I think, too lazy to check) a bit strenuous so was hoping to roll town this time. I'm happy.

[Fluminator]

Wow damo jumping over my question to answer Chaqa

[Fluminator]

Lol perfect timing for a ninja

[damo666]

Ghug and bozo have felt fine so far. I don't think they're worthy of wagons.

Worcej has felt much more diplomatic than i remember as town, but i could see a town motive for it so I'd feel kind of icky killing him for it.

I understand suspicion of Vecna but if he's claiming roleblock he can survive imo. It could be a scum gambit but as long as we have PRs we can let him scum gambit.

Don't really want to vote for any of those 4 today.

Who do you want to vote for?

[aarodactyl]

I understand the ghug and Bozo voters.

Worcej voters... why?

All D1 subs are scum (according to bozo)

[Fluminator]

Ghug and bozo have felt fine so far. I don't think they're worthy of wagons.

Worcej has felt much more diplomatic than i remember as town, but i could see a town motive for it so I'd feel kind of icky killing him for it.

I understand suspicion of Vecna but if he's claiming roleblock he can survive imo. It could be a scum gambit but as long as we have PRs we can let him scum gambit.

Don't really want to vote for any of those 4 today.

Who do you want to vote for?

Scum

[Chaqa]

Hmmm. It's fairly strong evidence, but the holidays happened, and ND didn't just low post, he never posted following his disappearance, so I think it's fair to say it's different?

Look at his profile:

https://webdiplomacy.net/userprofile.php?userID=68782

Last online Friday 5 PM (EST).

I think he just ghosted.

[aarodactyl]

Hmmm. It's fairly strong evidence, but the holidays happened, and ND didn't just low post, he never posted following his disappearance, so I think it's fair to say it's different?

Look at his profile:

https://webdiplomacy.net/userprofile.php?userID=68782

Last online Friday 5 PM (EST).

I think he just ghosted.

To add to this, I recall ND almost missing the deadline to confirm his sign up.

[Bonatogether]

I've got some questions for bona

• In your EoN1 reads list you list Vecna's performances D1 and N1 as doodoo, yet your overall read on him is null. Why is there this discrepancy?
• In your D2 reads list so say that I'm trying to fake town play. What are you seeing in my messages that feels fake? I didn't post between these two reads lists so why did your mind change? Lastly, why do you say that I'm less accurate? Do you know who the mafia are and know that I'm missing them?

On the topic of Bona, their comment about using hammer to get them out, showed way less resistance to being the DK than I remember from last game.

I don't view poor play as scum indicative. We should vote people out for poor play, but it doesn't mean that they're scum. There's no discrepancy to address.

I've already talked on how you are posting in a different way.

If you recall, the day I was voted out last game I barely posted until minutes before EoD.

[damo666]

I understand the ghug and Bozo voters.

Worcej voters... why?

All D1 subs are scum (according to bozo)

The number of day 1 subs that turn out to be scum seems to be statistically significant. (Impression rather than hard analysis).

[aarodactyl]

This theory might be bogus but I think Vecna is scum.

I think the roleblocker doesn’t use their power n1. There’s such a low chance to hit town PR. And if they hit medic, there’s a good chance it won’t matter. So I think they’d not block anyone and then let one of them claim they were role blocked if they need the clear.

[Hamilton Brian]

Hi everyone; ya'll are busy through the evening hours. Aaro...pretty strong post. In my notes I am writing, I've got you almost jumping from tier 2 to tier 1.

Allow me the privilege of catching up while also presuming to do some work (back to it after the holidays).

[Tom Bombadil]

Vote Count 2.1

ghug: 4 (worcej, Chaqa, Jamiet99uk, e.m.c^42)
worcej: 3 (bozotheclown, Vecna, damo666)
bozotheclown: 3 (aarodactyl, President Eden, Donny Dude)
rdrivera2005: 2 (Hellenic Riot, brainbomb)
Hellenic Riot: 1 (Fluminator)
aarodactyl: 1 (ghug)
Bonatogether: 1 (rdrivera2005)

ghug is set to be killed

Bonatogether, BunnyGo, celaph and Hamilton Brian must place valid votes

About 9.5 hours left in D2

[Fluminator]

##vote HB let's tunnel HB again another game

[Jamiet99uk]

My work is quiet as some of my colleagues do not return from their festive slumber until tomorrow. So here I am.

[Jamiet99uk]

I understand the ghug and Bozo voters.

Worcej voters... why?

a) Bozo's mad theory
b) Worcej will probably go sooner or later anyway due to the D1 vote

These are bad reasons to vote for Worcej. Bozo's theory is bad, and reason (b) smacks of laziness.

[Hamilton Brian]

##vote HB let's tunnel HB again another game

Bring a good shovel.

[Jamiet99uk]

Bozo seemed to imply he was signalling something with his use of multiple colours. I've no idea what this might be but is it more likely as town or scum?

Would you like to tell us what you meant Bozo?

Bozo enjoys thinking to himself that he is some kind of cryptic puzzler edgelord. He likes to do weirdo random shit D1 to make it look as if he's clever.

.emag eht gnivlos otni troffe emos tup yllautca eh fi retteb eb dluow tI