M62: PEOPLE'S DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF REVOLUTIONARY MAFIA GAME THREAD!

[ghug]

Wasn't the argument that we needed to take care of CCs the day before kylo? That's now, right?

That was when we had two people claiming priest

It's a trade off.

If someone hard claims Priest today, we know any CC tomorrow is false.

BUT, if someone hard claims Priest today, we lose the Priest overnight.

I suggested this before because I thought Balki's night claim meant he was protecting HR, and I wanted to keep them both alive. I figured we'd get a retraction and not have to kill either of them. If they weren't ever going to retract, then we would have had time to kill both of them.

Now, keeping the priest alive through the night ensures that we have a confirmed townie deciding between two people tomorrow, as opposed to three nonclears. If we're wrong today, anyone who wants to claim priest should do so just before EoN, telling us who they're protecting.

[aarodactyl]

Yeah please do, and let me know if you still think that.

Ok, I just reread it and it seems like it was reaction test instead.

And when he basically said it was a reaction test, for you, you still thought at the time he was shitposting?

No. That's why I said in past test that I thought it was a shitpost. I had the details of the exchange when you just asked, but remembered the order when you asked me to reread.

[aarodactyl]

That was when we had two people claiming priest

It's a trade off.

If someone hard claims Priest today, we know any CC tomorrow is false.

BUT, if someone hard claims Priest today, we lose the Priest overnight.

I suggested this before because I thought Balki's night claim meant he was protecting HR, and I wanted to keep them both alive. I figured we'd get a retraction and not have to kill either of them. If they weren't ever going to retract, then we would have had time to kill both of them.

Now, keeping the priest alive through the night ensures that we have a confirmed townie deciding between two people tomorrow, as opposed to three nonclears. If we're wrong today, anyone who wants to claim priest should do so just before EoN, telling us who they're protecting.

I think this is a good plan.

[Chaqa]

That was when we had two people claiming priest

It's a trade off.

If someone hard claims Priest today, we know any CC tomorrow is false.

BUT, if someone hard claims Priest today, we lose the Priest overnight.

I suggested this before because I thought Balki's night claim meant he was protecting HR, and I wanted to keep them both alive. I figured we'd get a retraction and not have to kill either of them. If they weren't ever going to retract, then we would have had time to kill both of them.

Now, keeping the priest alive through the night ensures that we have a confirmed townie deciding between two people tomorrow, as opposed to three nonclears. If we're wrong today, anyone who wants to claim priest should do so just before EoN, telling us who they're protecting.

That makes sense. It just shifts the town clear from the Priest to the non-claimant.

[kgray]

Okay well then I'm still going to talk about one priest theory I have, which is that Chaqa is the last scum who thought ghug was the priest until ghug's early EON post where he claimed not priest. I think Chaqa might have seen that and switched his kill order to celaph, who was largely townread but was questioning Chaqa, and who honestly had a decent chance at being priest based on his reaction to HR's priest claims.

It's obviously possible that anybody could have done this, but I didn't notice aaro or bozo online near EON so I think if this is what happened it makes the most sense for it to have been Chaqa.

[ghug]

Okay well then I'm still going to talk about one priest theory I have, which is that Chaqa is the last scum who thought ghug was the priest until ghug's early EON post where he claimed not priest. I think Chaqa might have seen that and switched his kill order to celaph, who was largely townread but was questioning Chaqa, and who honestly had a decent chance at being priest based on his reaction to HR's priest claims.

It's obviously possible that anybody could have done this, but I didn't notice aaro or bozo online near EON so I think if this is what happened it makes the most sense for it to have been Chaqa.

I feel like Chaqa would have been a little more understanding of all of the fakeclaiming, whereas I think it's very plausible that aaro didn't kill me because he didn't want to fall for another VT claiming priest and didn't kill you because you're townreading him hard.

[ghug]

Okay well then I'm still going to talk about one priest theory I have, which is that Chaqa is the last scum who thought ghug was the priest until ghug's early EON post where he claimed not priest. I think Chaqa might have seen that and switched his kill order to celaph, who was largely townread but was questioning Chaqa, and who honestly had a decent chance at being priest based on his reaction to HR's priest claims.

It's obviously possible that anybody could have done this, but I didn't notice aaro or bozo online near EON so I think if this is what happened it makes the most sense for it to have been Chaqa.

Also the way kgray had this theory but wasn't sure she should talk about it is super townie.

[Chaqa]

Okay well then I'm still going to talk about one priest theory I have, which is that Chaqa is the last scum who thought ghug was the priest until ghug's early EON post where he claimed not priest. I think Chaqa might have seen that and switched his kill order to celaph, who was largely townread but was questioning Chaqa, and who honestly had a decent chance at being priest based on his reaction to HR's priest claims.

It's obviously possible that anybody could have done this, but I didn't notice aaro or bozo online near EON so I think if this is what happened it makes the most sense for it to have been Chaqa.

This is what I was wondering, except that instead of me, it's one of you.

I was playing Among Us or Minecraft basically all day yesterday. I wish I had been streaming it now :p

[Chaqa]

Okay well then I'm still going to talk about one priest theory I have, which is that Chaqa is the last scum who thought ghug was the priest until ghug's early EON post where he claimed not priest. I think Chaqa might have seen that and switched his kill order to celaph, who was largely townread but was questioning Chaqa, and who honestly had a decent chance at being priest based on his reaction to HR's priest claims.

It's obviously possible that anybody could have done this, but I didn't notice aaro or bozo online near EON so I think if this is what happened it makes the most sense for it to have been Chaqa.

Also the way kgray had this theory but wasn't sure she should talk about it is super townie.

Yeah... I kinda am coming around on her.

I'm gonna feel real stupid if she wins this, but today especially the interactions have been screaming town to me.

[Chaqa]

##Vote Bozo

Gonna trust my gut and my VCA and Flum's gut for now

[kgray]

Okay well then I'm still going to talk about one priest theory I have, which is that Chaqa is the last scum who thought ghug was the priest until ghug's early EON post where he claimed not priest. I think Chaqa might have seen that and switched his kill order to celaph, who was largely townread but was questioning Chaqa, and who honestly had a decent chance at being priest based on his reaction to HR's priest claims.

It's obviously possible that anybody could have done this, but I didn't notice aaro or bozo online near EON so I think if this is what happened it makes the most sense for it to have been Chaqa.

I feel like Chaqa would have been a little more understanding of all of the fakeclaiming, whereas I think it's very plausible that aaro didn't kill me because he didn't want to fall for another VT claiming priest and didn't kill you because you're townreading him hard.

I see your aaro point, but I don't get what you're saying about Chaqa - if he were scum he'd be more understanding about HR/Balki's fakeclaiming? Or he'd be less likely to believe you were the priest?

[kgray]

Okay well then I'm still going to talk about one priest theory I have, which is that Chaqa is the last scum who thought ghug was the priest until ghug's early EON post where he claimed not priest. I think Chaqa might have seen that and switched his kill order to celaph, who was largely townread but was questioning Chaqa, and who honestly had a decent chance at being priest based on his reaction to HR's priest claims.

It's obviously possible that anybody could have done this, but I didn't notice aaro or bozo online near EON so I think if this is what happened it makes the most sense for it to have been Chaqa.

Also the way kgray had this theory but wasn't sure she should talk about it is super townie.

Yeah... I kinda am coming around on her.

I'm gonna feel real stupid if she wins this, but today especially the interactions have been screaming town to me.

But Chaqa, how can you change your read of me since there haven't been more EODs you can use for VCA?

[ghug]

Okay well then I'm still going to talk about one priest theory I have, which is that Chaqa is the last scum who thought ghug was the priest until ghug's early EON post where he claimed not priest. I think Chaqa might have seen that and switched his kill order to celaph, who was largely townread but was questioning Chaqa, and who honestly had a decent chance at being priest based on his reaction to HR's priest claims.

It's obviously possible that anybody could have done this, but I didn't notice aaro or bozo online near EON so I think if this is what happened it makes the most sense for it to have been Chaqa.

I feel like Chaqa would have been a little more understanding of all of the fakeclaiming, whereas I think it's very plausible that aaro didn't kill me because he didn't want to fall for another VT claiming priest and didn't kill you because you're townreading him hard.

I see your aaro point, but I don't get what you're saying about Chaqa - if he were scum he'd be more understanding about HR/Balki's fakeclaiming? Or he'd be less likely to believe you were the priest?

More likely to be understanding of Balki and HR, and less likely to be swayed by me saying I'm not the priest.

[kgray]

I really don't know, ghug. I still think aaro's D3 (especially after Bunny was outed) feels so towny...

[Chaqa]

Also the way kgray had this theory but wasn't sure she should talk about it is super townie.

Yeah... I kinda am coming around on her.

I'm gonna feel real stupid if she wins this, but today especially the interactions have been screaming town to me.

But Chaqa, how can you change your read of me since there haven't been more EODs you can use for VCA?

Ouch.

[ghug]

I really don't know, ghug. I still think aaro's D3 (especially after Bunny was outed) feels so towny...

I get that, and I'd probably be similarly steadfast if it were bona here, but everyone else is acting like town and aaro has done jack shit for days.

[Chaqa]

I feel like Chaqa would have been a little more understanding of all of the fakeclaiming, whereas I think it's very plausible that aaro didn't kill me because he didn't want to fall for another VT claiming priest and didn't kill you because you're townreading him hard.

I see your aaro point, but I don't get what you're saying about Chaqa - if he were scum he'd be more understanding about HR/Balki's fakeclaiming? Or he'd be less likely to believe you were the priest?

More likely to be understanding of Balki and HR, and less likely to be swayed by me saying I'm not the priest.

This game is gonna end with me still not knowing if you're the Priest or not.

[kgray]

I really don't know, ghug. I still think aaro's D3 (especially after Bunny was outed) feels so towny...

I get that, and I'd probably be similarly steadfast if it were bona here, but everyone else is acting like town and aaro has done jack shit for days.

Well, I agree with that. I mean, he really could just be worn out - this is a long game... But I don't know, maybe I just keep making excuses for him.

[kgray]

@ghug if bozo is scum he doesn't go back on his aaro scumread, right? And then he probably pushes for Chaqa as the final miskill?

[ghug]

@ghug if bozo is scum he doesn't go back on his aaro scumread, right? And then he probably pushes for Chaqa as the final miskill?

Yeah, I feel like the push on you today is bozo's version of townie paranoia.

I suppose it's also possible that he knew there were only two people who'd vote for aaro and needed somebody who wasn't him on the chopping block.