M62: PEOPLE'S DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF REVOLUTIONARY MAFIA GAME THREAD!

[ghug]

I'm playing in the WDC tomorrow so I'm going actually on ##VOTE aaro now just in case I last until the deadline.

[kgray]

I'm playing in the WDC tomorrow so I'm going actually on ##VOTE aaro now just in case I last until the deadline.

I thought you hated Diplomacy?

[kgray]

But actually, good luck! Although you shouldn't vote for aaro.

[ghug]

I'm playing in the WDC tomorrow so I'm going actually on ##VOTE aaro now just in case I last until the deadline.

I thought you hated Diplomacy?

I do. I'm already regretting it.

[kgray]

I'm playing in the WDC tomorrow so I'm going actually on ##VOTE aaro now just in case I last until the deadline.

I thought you hated Diplomacy?

I do. I'm already regretting it.

Just be bad and get eliminated quick?

[ghug]

I thought you hated Diplomacy?

I do. I'm already regretting it.

Just be bad and get eliminated quick?

I only have one speed.

[ghug]

Unless I get eliminated quick and then that's totally what I did on purpose because I hate Diplomacy.

[kgray]

Well best of luck in dying quick then, so you have time to come back and change your vote

[ghug]

Why can't you just sheep your priest?

[kgray]

Why can't you just sheep your priest?

Because I really really think aaro is town. And I stopped going to church as soon as I moved out of my parents' house, so I'm not particularly convinced by a holy man.

[ghug]

Why can't you just sheep your priest?

Because I really really think aaro is town. And I stopped going to church as soon as I moved out of my parents' house, so I'm not particularly convinced by a holy man.

What if I call myself a shepherd? Then you have to be sheep.

[kgray]

Why can't you just sheep your priest?

Because I really really think aaro is town. And I stopped going to church as soon as I moved out of my parents' house, so I'm not particularly convinced by a holy man.

What if I call myself a shepherd? Then you have to be sheep.

The role is "priest" not "messiah"

[ghug]

Because I really really think aaro is town. And I stopped going to church as soon as I moved out of my parents' house, so I'm not particularly convinced by a holy man.

What if I call myself a shepherd? Then you have to be sheep.

The role is "priest" not "messiah"

Who said anything about a role?

[Fluminator]

I totally skipped out on writing my case on Bozo today. Was busy playing minecraft with some friends.

We had a christmas tree and we were placing ornaments. As a joke I put a TNT on the tree to freak them out. But apparently the ornament beside it was a redstone block so it blew up. They were not impressed.

To make it even worse I had 5 puppies with me and one blew up and died.
It's been a rough day.

Anyway, I'll definitely try to go over bozo tomorrow.

[bozotheclown]

Nightkill analysis is actually kind of interesting this game. I never think it's smart to write things off as wifom.

Vecna was killed before the clears for a reason. I'm also wondering which player would fear him enough to nightkill him before then? Damo posted in the first day Vecna usually gets things wrong so unless he was lying he doesn't have a super high opinion of Vecna and I doubt he'd make a fearkill for the sake of fearkilling unless Vecna was pretty accurate this game. I don't know if I see one of the new players fearkilling Vecna either unless he was pretty accurate too. But that wouldn't make much sense for the new town players considering Vecna townread all the new players.

Vecna did scumread Bozo when he died though (but it was in a grouping of other now flipped townies so it's not like he had the entire scumteam nailed). I do think his townreads are generally accurate though and he must have had at least a good chunk of his reads right which leads me to think he was correct on most of his townreads.

Ghug and Kgray are players who might kill Vecna just for the sake of killing him, but I don't think they're scum.
Idk I think Bozo makes the most sense here as he's aware Vecna is usually pretty good, he had a lot of correct townreads, and had his eyes set for him in the future, (but killing him there wouldn't make him look bad at all)

I also think he makes sense killing Balki first. Originally I thought a new/inexperienced person would kill Balki because obvious HR was the priest. But jokes on me lol. Whoever scum was must have picked up on stuff to make them think HR wasn't actually the priest and I think scum Bozo would have picked that up much more likely than newer players.

Why are you arguing that damo wouldn't NK Vecna when we know that he participated in NKing Vecna?

I don't see him taking the lead on that with a new player scum partner. And I don't see a new scum player taking the lead on that either.

Vecna was scum reading damo, so I don't see why he wouldn't NK him. Do you believe everything scum said D1 was true?

[bozotheclown]

I still think the way aarodactyl has been very careful with his votes and been concerned with how his votes look makes him a good scum candidate.

##VOTE aarodactyl

This is pretty typical new player behavior as any alignment. It's NAI.

What do you think of aarodactyl criticizing my probability calculation about his vote at the same time as Yoyoyozo instead of just dismissing it as a coincidence?

[bozotheclown]

Maybe it is bozo.

What has changed your opinion of bozo?

Just that I'm having a hard time deciding that anyone is scum. And I think it's possible that bozo is focusing on aaro because aaro is newer and he keeps contradicting himself, so it's easy for bozo to keep looking like he's hunting.

From your perspective, assuming you are town, 1/3 of the remaining scum possibilities are new players, are you not looking at them because they are new?

What do you think of aarodactyl saying he thinks I am town in his reads list, but when I asked him to rank his reads, he put me as the second mist likely scum?

[Fluminator]

Why are you arguing that damo wouldn't NK Vecna when we know that he participated in NKing Vecna?

I don't see him taking the lead on that with a new player scum partner. And I don't see a new scum player taking the lead on that either.

Vecna was scum reading damo, so I don't see why he wouldn't NK him. Do you believe everything scum said D1 was true?

I was going off his final scumreads, but I forgot that post was literally minutes before eon so that wouldn't be the list to go off regarding if he was fearkilled.
His interactions with damo that day/night was mainly questioning him why he was so inconsistent with his read on you, and putting him in the scumpool.

His scumpool was HR/Bozo/Damo/Balki/Maniac. And he was townreading all the new players.
I think it's much more likely he was fearkilled because he had both scum in that group and his townreads and defense of aaro and celaph (and bona) would prove annoying.
I still don't see Aaro/Damo or Celaph/Damo killing Vecna before clears there.

[Fluminator]

I still think the way aarodactyl has been very careful with his votes and been concerned with how his votes look makes him a good scum candidate.

##VOTE aarodactyl

This is pretty typical new player behavior as any alignment. It's NAI.

What do you think of aarodactyl criticizing my probability calculation about his vote at the same time as Yoyoyozo instead of just dismissing it as a coincidence?

It would help if you repost it, but I remember several people criticizing your calculation, not just aaro.

[ghug]

"Don't pick on the new guy" kinda irritates me when y'all just killed the one new player who actually obvtowned.