M62: PEOPLE'S DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF REVOLUTIONARY MAFIA GAME THREAD!

[Chaqa]

I think we should make aaro, celaph, Chaqa, and Flum vote before anyone else tips their hand.

Give me a little time to do some new VCA?

You've had like a week but ok

I’ve been a bit checked out. I didn’t expect the game to go on once we got Bona, and then the Balki/HR thing has shocked me too. I’m 100% lost at this point.

[celaph]

I think we should make aaro, celaph, Chaqa, and Flum vote before anyone else tips their hand.

My first instinct is to $$vote celaph as a tribute to our fallen comrade Bonatogether. May he rest in peace.

My second instinct is to ##vote Flum here, though perhaps my ego not wanting to be wrong about aaro is weighing on me. Probably worth some review. Of the three you listed (obviously not considering me), I think I kill Chaqa last for the argument I made last night. I'm also not completely sold on town Bozo yet, but for now will bow to people with superior wisdom.

[celaph]

I realised N4 or whenever that I was an almost certain miskill so drawing the NK was the best thing I could do for the town. I suspect Balki realised the same thing a night later. With so many miskills available the chance the actual priest cc'd was also pretty low (because scum claiming priest there would be insane), so it was really optimal play by the pair of us

Far be it from me to say nice things about you, but I can't in good conscience disagree.

Kudos to the priest ghug for holding their tongue and letting you do it.

That explains why you accepted priest HR's non-claim so quickly while the rest of us were losing our minds...

[Hellenic Riot]

I think we should make aaro, celaph, Chaqa, and Flum vote before anyone else tips their hand.

Give me a little time to do some new VCA?

What part of me being non-priest town changes your previous VCA?

[kgray]

I actually think HR is a VT, so I retract.

##vote Maniac

You guys! Look at this in hindsight! I should never have doubted Balki.

[Chaqa]

Remaining suspects with a very quick-hit VCA of the relevant days

Aerodactyl
Day 1 - Votes limited to Flum and ND. Only voted for by Flum.
Day 2 - Nothing strikes me super suspicious here, at least for scum connections.
Day 5 - Damo voter through and through.

Bozo
Day 1 - Previously stated vote connections to Jamiet and Yoyo.
Day 2 - Jamie cast a vote on Yoyo on Day 2, then on Bozo, before eventually winding up on Maniac and then brain. A bit suspicious to me. Yoyo also voted for him Day 2 at one point, as did damo.
Day 5 - Basically drove the Damo wagon (with ghug, I guess). Either town or heavy bussing.

Celaph
Day 1 - Cast one single vote against Maniac. None against.
Day 2 - Voted for Yoyo before switching to HB.
Day 5 - Joined damo wagon and didn't leave. Town+

Flum
Day 1 - Cast several votes before settling on teacon. Had a few assorted votes againat him.
Day 2 - Voted for Yoyo for a bit (to be fair lots of people were).
Day 5 - Seemed relucant to join the main wagons. Joined damo once it was in the lead when he could have tied it up. Town++

Ghug
Day 1 - Primarily on the ND wagon. No obvious links to any of the scum on D1.
Day 2 - Nothing strikes me as suspicious about his D2.
Day 5 - Day 5 is where I find the most suspicious ghug behavior. He did start the damo wagon, but then left it to help kickstart the celaph wagon. I'm not immediately sure scum!ghug would do this in that situation, but it's not outside the realm of possibility.

K. G. Ray, Esq.
Day 1 - Most suspicious thing with her is the flip off the teacon wagon, then to Bunny, then to ND. It's very odd to me that she left the teacon wagon, only to not return to it and instead go to ND.
Day 2 - Had a very brief vote on damo at one point. Damo also sat his vote on her for *nearly* the entire day.
Day 5 - More or less steadfast on Damo wagon.


------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Based on this and the general reads I had already, I would rank people like this:

Scum

Kgray
Bozo
Aero
ghug
Celaph
Flum

Town

Some of these are a bit arbitrary. I rank Bozo high due to VCA and my suspicion he would be willing to bus. Flum is still my strongest townread, but at this point I basically think anyone could be a deep-cover scum.

##Vote kgray

[Chaqa]

I think we should make aaro, celaph, Chaqa, and Flum vote before anyone else tips their hand.

Give me a little time to do some new VCA?

What part of me being non-priest town changes your previous VCA?

Well, I now know for a fact you aren't the last scum, which I didn't when I did it last.

[kgray]

woah.

[Fluminator]

This is the bad-Chaqa town I'm used to. I was starting to get a little paranoid he was too good this game.
Godo job townreading me though <3

[ghug]

woah.

You're only just realizing you look terrible by VCA?

[Hellenic Riot]

@Chaqa

Why do you give celaph credit for not leaving the damo wagon when he was the only alternative?

[kgray]

woah.

You're only just realizing you look terrible by VCA?

No, I'm surprised at how his reads are almost the opposite of mine.

[aarodactyl]

I'm Bona's honor, I'm going to start doing a lot of +1s.

[Fluminator]

Chaqa did you ever respond to my question about bona calling you out as you died? About how this is your scum meta?
Do you agree with that, or is he mistaken?

[aarodactyl]

I'm going to put my vote down as Chaqa. ##vote chaqa

[ghug]

woah.

You're only just realizing you look terrible by VCA?

No, I'm surprised at how his reads are almost the opposite of mine.

You townread aaro more than me?

[Chaqa]

@Chaqa

Why do you give celaph credit for not leaving the damo wagon when he was the only alternative?

Lack of application of critical thinking.

[Chaqa]

woah.

You're only just realizing you look terrible by VCA?

No, I'm surprised at how his reads are almost the opposite of mine.

You should share your reads

[Chaqa]

Chaqa did you ever respond to my question about bona calling you out as you died? About how this is your scum meta?
Do you agree with that, or is he mistaken?

Did you read his post? He said I'm scum because I was "controlling the conversation".

Like... how am I doing that?

[Fluminator]

idk ghug, I'm rereading aaro's iso and I'm still not seeing anything super suspicious. The sheer volume is impressive and I feel like he'd have at least a few cracks as scum. Like he's had no filter all game on top of the amount of the posts he has. Are you sure this isn't just a situation where you tunneled town Squiggs to death who was also super talkative with no filter?