M62: PEOPLE'S DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF REVOLUTIONARY MAFIA GAME THREAD!

[Fluminator]

Well mafia were obviously allergic to being on the same wagon day 1 so the final scum is clearly bona or maniac.

[aarodactyl]

Observations about my colored voting lists:

-the known scum didn't have any overlap with voting in both days. If damo was here, I'd probably ask them for the odds of that happening.
-continuing off of that, bona didn't overlap with any of the scum on days one or two. Maniac didn't on day 1. Someone with more experience, please let me know if this is relevant or not
-there aren't any scum on the D2 train for HB. Since it was TvT, I don't know if that's relevant. However, I'd expect to find one of them there based on how spread out their voting was.

[aarodactyl]

Well mafia were obviously allergic to being on the same wagon day 1 so the final scum is clearly bona or maniac.

weirdly this applies to day 2 as well

[Bonatogether]

Well mafia were obviously allergic to being on the same wagon day 1 so the final scum is clearly bona or maniac.

weirdly this applies to day 2 as well

if celaph is scum, then this hold for d2.

[aarodactyl]

Well mafia were obviously allergic to being on the same wagon day 1 so the final scum is clearly bona or maniac.

weirdly this applies to day 2 as well

if celaph is scum, then this hold for d2.

to be fair, if you're scum, this holds for d1 and d2. I think that's a long shot, but worth noting.

I do agree that I would expect scum to hide on the HB wagon though

[kgray]

I didn't think day 5 would be helpful with the coloring.

What?? Why wouldn't it be helpful?

[aarodactyl]

@celaph what's your top 5 scum list look like?

[Tom Bombadil]

Well mafia were obviously allergic to being on the same wagon day 1 so the final scum is clearly bona or maniac.

weirdly this applies to day 2 as well

if celaph is scum, then this hold for d2.

I take it you still think celaph is scum then?

[aarodactyl]

I didn't think day 5 would be helpful with the coloring.

What?? Why wouldn't it be helpful?

I had brain fart and forgot we had townclears, so I forgot coloring would be helpful

Votes Day 5
------------
damo666 (8): bozotheclown, kgray, aarodactyl, celaph, Chaqa, Fluminator, Tom Bombadil, ghug
celaph (5): Bonatogether, Hellenic Riot, Balki Bartokomous, damo666, Maniac

[aarodactyl]

weirdly this applies to day 2 as well

if celaph is scum, then this hold for d2.

I take it you still think celaph is scum then?

It's going to turn out that maniac is the last scum and the game will end and and Bona and celaph will still be scumreading each other.

[kgray]

I didn't think day 5 would be helpful with the coloring.

What?? Why wouldn't it be helpful?

I had brain fart and forgot we had townclears, so I forgot coloring would be helpful

Votes Day 5
------------
damo666 (8): bozotheclown, kgray, aarodactyl, celaph, Chaqa, Fluminator, Tom Bombadil, ghug
celaph (5): Bonatogether, Hellenic Riot, Balki Bartokomous, damo666, Maniac

Okay you were right though, it's not that helpful lol

[aarodactyl]

What?? Why wouldn't it be helpful?

I had brain fart and forgot we had townclears, so I forgot coloring would be helpful

Votes Day 5
------------
damo666 (8): bozotheclown, kgray, aarodactyl, celaph, Chaqa, Fluminator, Tom Bombadil, ghug
celaph (5): Bonatogether, Hellenic Riot, Balki Bartokomous, damo666, Maniac

Okay you were right though, it's not that helpful lol

I probably should have included it for completeness though

[aarodactyl]

@tom and @HR can you do include some of your thoughts on who the last scum is before EON?

[Tom Bombadil]

@tom and @HR can you do include some of your thoughts on who the last scum is before EON?

Yes. I will

[celaph]

Some initial thoughts after EoD:

@HR If I remember I'll go back and look at the posts I listed regarding Vecna.

@ghug I can respect the play in hindsight, but was not a fan in the moment.

@HR, if you weren't conf town by mechanical means, I would want you out of this game so badly.

@Bona, your reaction perplexes me.

Regarding hammers, I'm starting to better understand why people like them, but I think today is also an example of their weaknesses. I think we risk hammering damo today if it's an option and then we lose the EoD conversation.

I'd be stunned if kgray was scum here. I'd go so far as to say I'd believe that the GM's messed up and sent me the wrong PM and I'm actually scum over believing that kgray is town

[celaph]

Observations about my colored voting lists:

-the known scum didn't have any overlap with voting in both days. If damo was here, I'd probably ask them for the odds of that happening.
-continuing off of that, bona didn't overlap with any of the scum on days one or two. Maniac didn't on day 1. Someone with more experience, please let me know if this is relevant or not
-there aren't any scum on the D2 train for HB. Since it was TvT, I don't know if that's relevant. However, I'd expect to find one of them there based on how spread out their voting was.

If there were any scum on the HB train, then there was overlap in voting D1.

[celaph]

if celaph is scum, then this hold for d2.

I take it you still think celaph is scum then?

It's going to turn out that maniac is the last scum and the game will end and and Bona and celaph will still be scumreading each other.

For the record, I null read bona in my EoD notes.

[aarodactyl]

Observations about my colored voting lists:

-the known scum didn't have any overlap with voting in both days. If damo was here, I'd probably ask them for the odds of that happening.
-continuing off of that, bona didn't overlap with any of the scum on days one or two. Maniac didn't on day 1. Someone with more experience, please let me know if this is relevant or not
-there aren't any scum on the D2 train for HB. Since it was TvT, I don't know if that's relevant. However, I'd expect to find one of them there based on how spread out their voting was.

If there were any scum on the HB train, then there was overlap in voting D1.

What's your opinion on bona and maniac these days?

[aarodactyl]

I take it you still think celaph is scum then?

It's going to turn out that maniac is the last scum and the game will end and and Bona and celaph will still be scumreading each other.

For the record, I null read bona in my EoD notes.

oh ok. I just asked this. I guess I forgot about that.

[Hellenic Riot]

@tom and @HR can you do include some of your thoughts on who the last scum is before EON?

Aye, there's plenty extra info to comb over now