M62: PEOPLE'S DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF REVOLUTIONARY MAFIA GAME THREAD!

[kgray]

The argument that I, as scum with damo, would have any motivation whatsoever to shackle myself to him like that is one that I'm certainly all-ears to hear

I think it's totally possible. Look how townread scum!damo was last game. It's not dangerous to shackle yourself to him. And most of the scum "strategy" last game was dominated by Chaqa and I tunneling each other. Why not do the opposite? Nobody would expect it, right? Because the default assumption is what you're arguing now.

And for the record, I wouldn't be too shocked if damo is town and you're scum. Your read of him is so unnatural from my POV that if he is town, then your read only makes sense if you already knew that.

[ghug]

Flum, HR, if either of you is town, you have to stop sucking.

Where do you disagree with my schpeel on HR?

"schpeel"

I think HR is kinda scummy at this point, but you're not doing much better, and y'all spending most of your time interacting with the game arguing in circles with each other doesn't reflect well on either of you.

[Hellenic Riot]

No counter to what? I'm not interested in rehashing the exact same thing again and again, and I'm quite content to go down without a fight

[Hellenic Riot]

The argument that I, as scum with damo, would have any motivation whatsoever to shackle myself to him like that is one that I'm certainly all-ears to hear

I think it's totally possible. Look how townread scum!damo was last game. It's not dangerous to shackle yourself to him. And most of the scum "strategy" last game was dominated by Chaqa and I tunneling each other. Why not do the opposite? Nobody would expect it, right? Because the default assumption is what you're arguing now.

And for the record, I wouldn't be too shocked if damo is town and you're scum. Your read of him is so unnatural from my POV that if he is town, then your read only makes sense if you already knew that.

I didn't read last game, so I'm afraid I have no idea how widely townread damo was by the end of the game. Shackling myself to a teammate who's being widely scumread whilst simultaneously bussing teacon takes some serious logic failures

[kgray]

The fact that it's taken until now, two days after people started scumreading me, for someone to suggest I'm scum *without* damo, after what happened last time I was scum, is certainly quite bizarre

I considered this N2, comparing you to scum!xorxes in a previous game who was buddying town!damo. I don't know what happened in your previous scum game.

[Fluminator]

Flum, HR, if either of you is town, you have to stop sucking.

Where do you disagree with my schpeel on HR?

"schpeel"

I think HR is kinda scummy at this point, but you're not doing much better, and y'all spending most of your time interacting with the game arguing in circles with each other doesn't reflect well on either of you.

Well then tell me where I'm wrong so I stop wasting time.

HR is claiming all his absurd posts about damo being town was because I was sheeping him. Do you think it makes sense he'd do that based on this one post I made mentioning it?

Ok brain is officially a scumread now too.

Every other post from him today is him talking about how he tried to save teacon and it almost sounds jubilant and smug with how much he brings it up along with the excitement behind it.
It really feels he's going into his "I'm so crazy and whacky" meta to cover his tracks to get away with it and loving every minute it's working.
I feel like town brain would not be like this.

Brain, Brian, probably one of ghug/Vecna/Balki, probably a couple out of the pool of lurkers/new players/Maniac.
I'd put damo in there too but I'll trust HR's read on him for now and there's an abundance of scummy behaviour this game to go around.

Bunny is still kind of scummy too lol.

[ghug]

The fact that it's taken until now, two days after people started scumreading me, for someone to suggest I'm scum *without* damo, after what happened last time I was scum, is certainly quite bizarre

I considered this N2, comparing you to scum!xorxes in a previous game who was buddying town!damo. I don't know what happened in your previous scum game.

He irrationally townread town emc for days and it led to us scumreading both of them and miskilling emc.

[kgray]

The argument that I, as scum with damo, would have any motivation whatsoever to shackle myself to him like that is one that I'm certainly all-ears to hear

I think it's totally possible. Look how townread scum!damo was last game. It's not dangerous to shackle yourself to him. And most of the scum "strategy" last game was dominated by Chaqa and I tunneling each other. Why not do the opposite? Nobody would expect it, right? Because the default assumption is what you're arguing now.

And for the record, I wouldn't be too shocked if damo is town and you're scum. Your read of him is so unnatural from my POV that if he is town, then your read only makes sense if you already knew that.

I didn't read last game, so I'm afraid I have no idea how widely townread damo was by the end of the game. Shackling myself to a teammate who's being widely scumread whilst simultaneously bussing teacon takes some serious logic failures

Hmm. I didn't think damo was being wildly scumread at the time. I tried to get a wagon going on him D2 (emc was already there) and only Durga joined me.

[ghug]

Where do you disagree with my schpeel on HR?

"schpeel"

I think HR is kinda scummy at this point, but you're not doing much better, and y'all spending most of your time interacting with the game arguing in circles with each other doesn't reflect well on either of you.

Well then tell me where I'm wrong so I stop wasting time.

HR is claiming all his absurd posts about damo being town was because I was sheeping him. Do you think it makes sense he'd do that based on this one post I made mentioning it?

Ok brain is officially a scumread now too.

Every other post from him today is him talking about how he tried to save teacon and it almost sounds jubilant and smug with how much he brings it up along with the excitement behind it.
It really feels he's going into his "I'm so crazy and whacky" meta to cover his tracks to get away with it and loving every minute it's working.
I feel like town brain would not be like this.

Brain, Brian, probably one of ghug/Vecna/Balki, probably a couple out of the pool of lurkers/new players/Maniac.
I'd put damo in there too but I'll trust HR's read on him for now and there's an abundance of scummy behaviour this game to go around.

Bunny is still kind of scummy too lol.

Maybe

[kgray]

fwiw Flum, I was convinced HR was doing some sort of reaction test and was going to take back his strong townread of damo in his EoN2 reads.

[kgray]

The fact that it's taken until now, two days after people started scumreading me, for someone to suggest I'm scum *without* damo, after what happened last time I was scum, is certainly quite bizarre

I considered this N2, comparing you to scum!xorxes in a previous game who was buddying town!damo. I don't know what happened in your previous scum game.

He irrationally townread town emc for days and it led to us scumreading both of them and miskilling emc.

Well then if he's town and really thought damo was town, it seems like a pretty major mistake to do that same thing here.

[Hellenic Riot]

I considered this N2, comparing you to scum!xorxes in a previous game who was buddying town!damo. I don't know what happened in your previous scum game.

He irrationally townread town emc for days and it led to us scumreading both of them and miskilling emc.

Well then if he's town and really thought damo was town, it seems like a pretty major mistake to do that same thing here.

Tbh half of it was wanting to see if I'd be able to get away with ever doing that again for next time I roll scum

[kgray]

He irrationally townread town emc for days and it led to us scumreading both of them and miskilling emc.

Well then if he's town and really thought damo was town, it seems like a pretty major mistake to do that same thing here.

Tbh half of it was wanting to see if I'd be able to get away with ever doing that again for next time I roll scum

So your story is you, as a town PR, did something to draw scumreads to yourself and your strongest townread at the time just to see if you could get away with doing it later?

[Hellenic Riot]

I shall spell it out for you, step by step, one final time:

- I townread damo and notice it got sheeped (by Flum)
- I decide to have some fun with this and see if it can carry on being sheeped, because it'll be useful info for future games
- It does continue, past a point at which I think it's reasonable to do so (again by Flum)
- I take it to absolutely absurd extremes, Flum yet again continues
- I scumread Flum because the amount of trust he was willing to put into that one read made no sense whatsoever
- We discuss the same thing over and over again

[Hellenic Riot]

Well then if he's town and really thought damo was town, it seems like a pretty major mistake to do that same thing here.

Tbh half of it was wanting to see if I'd be able to get away with ever doing that again for next time I roll scum

So your story is you, as a town PR, did something to draw scumreads to yourself and your strongest townread at the time just to see if you could get away with doing it later?

Don't worry, I'm probably not actually the Priest

[Hellenic Riot]

And now that I've done that, you guys can go and see where Flum just slipped.


Because during today's discussion of it, he said he thought I was softing an inno on damo. Whereas a few days ago, he said I thought I had a PR Read on Damo and that it was damo softing the inno on HB


So he's now suggesting that he thought I was softing an inno on someone he thought was the cop

[Hellenic Riot]

Game, set, match

See ya'll later

[ghug]

Let's all claim priest first thing tomorrow and vote HR.

[Fluminator]

I shall spell it out for you, step by step, one final time:

- I townread damo and notice it got sheeped (by Flum)
- I decide to have some fun with this and see if it can carry on being sheeped, because it'll be useful info for future games
- It does continue, past a point at which I think it's reasonable to do so (again by Flum)
- I take it to absolutely absurd extremes, Flum yet again continues
- I scumread Flum because the amount of trust he was willing to put into that one read made no sense whatsoever
- We discuss the same thing over and over again

I direct everyone to my post last page so you can see how this doesn't add up to what really happened. Not even close

[Fluminator]

And now that I've done that, you guys can go and see where Flum just slipped.


Because during today's discussion of it, he said he thought I was softing an inno on damo. Whereas a few days ago, he said I thought I had a PR Read on Damo and that it was damo softing the inno on HB


So he's now suggesting that he thought I was softing an inno on someone he thought was the cop

Town HR is not this stupid