M62: PEOPLE'S DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF REVOLUTIONARY MAFIA GAME THREAD!

[aarodactyl]

I hate Durga's reads so much...

I enjoy that you waited until she died to say this

[ghug]

I hate Durga's reads so much...

I enjoy that you waited until she died to say this

I was skiing.

[aarodactyl]

I hate Durga's reads so much...

I enjoy that you waited until she died to say this

I was skiing.

My bad. I hope you had a good time. There was a lot of talking going on so I assumed you were there

[Hellenic Riot]

I hate Durga's reads so much...

I enjoy that you waited until she died to say this

I was skiing.

Skiing involves snow
Snow involves ice
Ice involves ice picks
Ice picks are used to kill glorious communists
ghug confirmed Eden Loyalist

[ghug]

I enjoy that you waited until she died to say this

I was skiing.

Skiing involves snow
Snow involves ice
Ice involves ice picks
Ice picks are used to kill glorious communists
ghug confirmed Eden Loyalist

I ski to gulag. Check in on Jamie

[ghug]

Bona, can you give me some idea of your thoughts on the game at the moment?

Doesn't have to be reads. Just whatever you find relevant.

[Bonatogether]

Bona, can you give me some idea of your thoughts on the game at the moment?

Doesn't have to be reads. Just whatever you find relevant.

This is a lot of junk in no particular order.

I think that the mafia's going to be playing it cool, since Durga knocked them good. There's 3 mafia, one of which 1 is guaranteed to be a goon. There's also a smuggler and/or a coordinator. I figure any goons are the ones more actively tripping the town up, the smuggler being a little more careful and trying to defend the coordinator, if they're there, and the coordinator is probably waffling a lot, or chasing false leads. I think we can then say that the players who are willing to go out on a limb are solid, and vice versa.

Aaro seems more fixated on me than normal, what with the whole bit about how chaqa knew my age and then with my whole goon thing, so I'd put him as townlean.

HR seemed active but then hasn't been talking much this phase. Probably just asleep or smth. Based off of stuff before, townlean.

Celaph has been trying to fit in for ages, which I put (surprise!) as leanscum. Same for Vecna, but less.

Mafia probably wants to kill a low-activity townie, unless they can nail someone who's getting a little too close to home without anyone noticing. Assuming that's right, I'd guess their shortlist to be Chaqa, Balki, damo, and Tom.

[aarodactyl]

Bona, can you give me some idea of your thoughts on the game at the moment?

Doesn't have to be reads. Just whatever you find relevant.

This is a lot of junk in no particular order.

I think that the mafia's going to be playing it cool, since Durga knocked them good. There's 3 mafia, one of which 1 is guaranteed to be a goon. There's also a smuggler and/or a coordinator. I figure any goons are the ones more actively tripping the town up, the smuggler being a little more careful and trying to defend the coordinator, if they're there, and the coordinator is probably waffling a lot, or chasing false leads. I think we can then say that the players who are willing to go out on a limb are solid, and vice versa.

Aaro seems more fixated on me than normal, what with the whole bit about how chaqa knew my age and then with my whole goon thing, so I'd put him as townlean.

HR seemed active but then hasn't been talking much this phase. Probably just asleep or smth. Based off of stuff before, townlean.

Celaph has been trying to fit in for ages, which I put (surprise!) as leanscum. Same for Vecna, but less.

Mafia probably wants to kill a low-activity townie, unless they can nail someone who's getting a little too close to home without anyone noticing. Assuming that's right, I'd guess their shortlist to be Chaqa, Balki, damo, and Tom.

Smuggler = goon now by the way. Also that’s a very funny shortlist.

[ghug]

Bona, can you give me some idea of your thoughts on the game at the moment?

Doesn't have to be reads. Just whatever you find relevant.

This is a lot of junk in no particular order.

I think that the mafia's going to be playing it cool, since Durga knocked them good. There's 3 mafia, one of which 1 is guaranteed to be a goon. There's also a smuggler and/or a coordinator. I figure any goons are the ones more actively tripping the town up, the smuggler being a little more careful and trying to defend the coordinator, if they're there, and the coordinator is probably waffling a lot, or chasing false leads. I think we can then say that the players who are willing to go out on a limb are solid, and vice versa.

Aaro seems more fixated on me than normal, what with the whole bit about how chaqa knew my age and then with my whole goon thing, so I'd put him as townlean.

HR seemed active but then hasn't been talking much this phase. Probably just asleep or smth. Based off of stuff before, townlean.

Celaph has been trying to fit in for ages, which I put (surprise!) as leanscum. Same for Vecna, but less.

Mafia probably wants to kill a low-activity townie, unless they can nail someone who's getting a little too close to home without anyone noticing. Assuming that's right, I'd guess their shortlist to be Chaqa, Balki, damo, and Tom.

Why does aaro's fixation on you make him town to you?
Is the HR townread based fully on activity?
Can you provide examples of celaph and Vecna trying to fit in?
Do you think all the people on your scum kill shortlist are definitely town?
Why do you think they'd kill someone inactive?

[Bonatogether]

Why does aaro's fixation on you make him town to you?
Is the HR townread based fully on activity?
Can you provide examples of celaph and Vecna trying to fit in?
Do you think all the people on your scum kill shortlist are definitely town?
Why do you think they'd kill someone inactive?

1) Because scum wants to fit in and go with the herd. There's not been a large push on me yet.

2) I like some of his stuff. I haven't reread it yet.

3)

Also, I support the motion to get yoyo to talk more. ##vote yoyo

-I think that aaro was rather competent when it came to properly handling Durga's info and getting the most out of that situation. I think this supports the claim that his lack of reads early on is more due to lack of familiarity with the online format than scummy-ness. I have a much better feeling from him than I got from EoD2.

This was in a streak of people townreading aaro (posts 5643 and 5640)

Can you find an example of celaph going against the grain?

4) No, this is just my guesses.

5) Because killing inactives doesn't tell the town anything. Killing an active player prompts like 5 people to reread everything they ever posted, and then they can go from there.

[ghug]

Yeah Bona's the new player everyone should be townreading.

[Chaqa]

15 people left. Assume town dies tonight.

14 people (11-3 split)

Mis-DK and it's 9-3

Mis-DK and it's 7-3

Mis-DK and it's 5-3

We have three mis-kills and a no-kill.

I think everyone should give a priority list of their top 3 scumreads tonight.

[ghug]

Why does aaro's fixation on you make him town to you?
Is the HR townread based fully on activity?
Can you provide examples of celaph and Vecna trying to fit in?
Do you think all the people on your scum kill shortlist are definitely town?
Why do you think they'd kill someone inactive?

1) Because scum wants to fit in and go with the herd. There's not been a large push on me yet.

2) I like some of his stuff. I haven't reread it yet.

3)

Also, I support the motion to get yoyo to talk more. ##vote yoyo

-I think that aaro was rather competent when it came to properly handling Durga's info and getting the most out of that situation. I think this supports the claim that his lack of reads early on is more due to lack of familiarity with the online format than scummy-ness. I have a much better feeling from him than I got from EoD2.

This was in a streak of people townreading aaro (posts 5643 and 5640)

Can you find an example of celaph going against the grain?

4) No, this is just my guesses.

5) Because killing inactives doesn't tell the town anything. Killing an active player prompts like 5 people to reread everything they ever posted, and then they can go from there.

1) I like.
2) You need to flesh out. HR is pretty good at this game.
3) I agree with you on celaph. Do you have Vecna examples?
5) Generally scum kill PR reads or more active players. I'd be surprised if you were right.

What do you think of Maniac?

[ghug]

15 people left. Assume town dies tonight.

14 people (11-3 split)

Mis-DK and it's 9-3

Mis-DK and it's 7-3

Mis-DK and it's 5-3

We have three mis-kills and a no-kill.

I think everyone should give a priority list of their top 3 scumreads tonight.

I'm glad you spent your time off doing something productive. Counting is a skill that will serve you for years to come.

What's your priority list? Who do you townread?

[Fluminator]

Is there something specific you want me to read?

How much have you read? It's okay if you haven't read everything.

I haven’t read a lot of the last few days since we’ve been waiting to kill Jamiet and Bunnygo. I have skimmed some, but not all.

rip, this game slipped my mind tonight. Let's chat tomorrow.

[Chaqa]

15 people left. Assume town dies tonight.

14 people (11-3 split)

Mis-DK and it's 9-3

Mis-DK and it's 7-3

Mis-DK and it's 5-3

We have three mis-kills and a no-kill.

I think everyone should give a priority list of their top 3 scumreads tonight.

I'm glad you spent your time off doing something productive. Counting is a skill that will serve you for years to come.

What's your priority list? Who do you townread?

Townreads on Flum, HR, Balki, Maniac.

My top 3 scum would be like Bozo, Yoyo, and one of the newbies. idk which one

[ghug]

Why?

[Fluminator]

Lol, it's probably almost better for town if yoyo's slot gets modkilled.

[ghug]

Exactly, it means you're a confirmed townie so all your posts can be read in that context, and you're still here to post, for now. Of course thanks to Eden's mechanics changes you were already pretty much confirmed town, but, oh well.

What mechanics changes made me confirmed town??

Ah, it's better talked about after the game really.

By the way FWIW, if you guys do want to hammer me, I'd be supportive of a solution whereby if there's a totally unanimous hammer vote, the Day ends after 24 hours. That way the phase time doesn't alter, just everything moves up by 24 hours.

##CALL GM would you let them do that?

I think this post captures all of it.


I'm not sure what could have happened, but this strikes me as honest frustration from Jamie, and given the weirdness around the rolebock, I think it's pretty possible the scum got blindsided by some mechanical ruling that night.

1) Does anyone have any theories as to what he could have been talking about?

2) When I was scum with bozo with M60, he asked about two million questions about mechanics. Part of this was about bo's subpar rule writing (I asked about a million questions myself, and poor Jamie was stuck answering all of them), but I think this is probably how he operates in general. I'd be pretty surprised if bozo ever got confused about what his team's actions meant. I hard townread bozo again.

[Fluminator]

ghug which final reads of Durga's did you hate?