M61 - The Mastermind's Revenge - Game Thread - HIDDEN

[BunnyGo]

Umm. I guess that means he’ll be here at EOD?

Not sure what the ordering on us was.

Why does it mean that?

It's clear his top scumread is still Chaqa.

That’s why chaqa was in the middle! ITS SO OBVIOUS!!

[Chaqa]

Yeah, I'm a bit lost by Flum's votes. Bunny first, then a list of people, then me?

But I'm in the middle of the list...

what does it mean?

[BunnyGo]

Yeah, I'm a bit lost by Flum's votes. Bunny first, then a list of people, then me?

But I'm in the middle of the list...

what does it mean?

My interpretation is above:

1) Bunny first means "bunny's question is to be answered"
2) Then the answer (but the order confuses me)
3) Then back to his actual vote.

[BunnyGo]

Umm. I guess that means he’ll be here at EOD?

Not sure what the ordering on us was.

Did you forget your own code? You asked who he'd be willing to follow us onto. Presumably that's his preferences, although it's kind of backwards from his earlier reads... So maybe he changed his mind?

Flum can you vote me if I'm right and Bunny if I'm wrong, please?

I didn't forget. But Chaqa in the middle threw me off.

[dargorygel]

Oh yeah. You and Chaqa were bussing each other all game, but know that all you need is a misskill you start to have doubts.
I don't think we should follow Flum blindly. I am voting you, but unfortunately I am not gathering enough support.
But you are smart enough to see why we need to consolidate on milo. We don't need to consolidate right now, but closer to EOD we can't have more then 2 wagons.

If we have two wagons... scum can dogpile on their choice, yes? As long as both wagons are scum, fine. But if one of them is town, we lose.

Is my math wrong?

If the 4 town and Flum are on the same scumbag there is nothing scum can do even if it is SvT

That's a mighty iffy if...

[dargorygel]

We have 'feelings' and 'expectations' about what others would do, but maybe we are wrong. You, for instance, I think believe that I scum read you (judging from your response yesterday, saying something about 'if that makes me scum vote for me') But you have been a steady townread for me.

Incorrect. I assumed you were townreading me. I said "if that makes me scum, vote for me" based on the assumption that you didn't think I was scum - my point was I was trying to find out why you were making such a big fuss about my joke.

I stand corrected.
I didn't think I was making a fuss, I was clarifying what they were asking... but yeah... it WAS clearly a joke.

[dargorygel]

If nothing else, I have seen real effort go into trying to solve the game from Jamie, Dargo, Bunny, Damo.

I've not seen nearly as much of that from Kgray, Rivera, or Macca.

Kinda feeling those three as scum. Last one is probably Bunny or Damo, or maaaaaybe Dargo or Jamie.

Hmmm... kind of a meaningless post. He says K,R, and M are scum because of lack of solvey-quotient... but then INCLUDES the solvey-folk in the end as the 'fourth' scum. Meaning that solvey really doesn't bear into chaqa's reasoning.

[Fluminator]

##Vote BunnyGo
##Vote Chaqa
##Vote Damo
##Vote Dargorygel
##Vote Jamiet99uk
##Vote Kgray
##Vote Macca
##Vote Rdrivera

[Fluminator]

##Vote Chaqa

[kgray]

Flum can you vote for me if that's your current scum-to-town list, and vote for Bunny if it isn't?

[Chaqa]

If nothing else, I have seen real effort go into trying to solve the game from Jamie, Dargo, Bunny, Damo.

I've not seen nearly as much of that from Kgray, Rivera, or Macca.

Kinda feeling those three as scum. Last one is probably Bunny or Damo, or maaaaaybe Dargo or Jamie.

Hmmm... kind of a meaningless post. He says K,R, and M are scum because of lack of solvey-quotient... but then INCLUDES the solvey-folk in the end as the 'fourth' scum. Meaning that solvey really doesn't bear into chaqa's reasoning.

Umm... no.. not what I'm saying.

I'm saying that I expect one scum is probably faking being solvy, but the others are the three who aren't.

Why do you misinterpret things I say?

[Chaqa]

##Vote BunnyGo
##Vote Chaqa
##Vote Damo
##Vote Dargorygel
##Vote Jamiet99uk
##Vote Kgray
##Vote Macca
##Vote Rdrivera

Well that's just alphabetical.

[dargorygel]

Surely this helps scum decide who the easiest mis-kill is going to be?

I know you scumread me today, but is it possible we can talk through the mechanics/wisdom of this? We have to do more than take a myriad of pot-shots today.

@darg who's your strongest scumread? You left Chaqa's wagon because you thought we were being set up for a miskill, right? But you jumped back on just to consolidate. Can you see how problematic that is?

I do, kgray.
Some of us are simply focussing in our THING (like stats for damo, for instance.) I find that narrow. Regarding my swich, I am trying to balance a bunch of things. My gut-reads... cases people put forward... voting... And when I left chaqa it WAS from the sudden realization that we might be setting ourselves up for a misskill. But THEN I realized that consolidation is key. WIFOM was/is killing me here.

But in answer to your question... my topscum (the one i am most confident in) is macca. But I see no traction there, and my topscum rating for him is FEELING... and still seeing a lot of bursty-posting (like he is getting advice in the QT.) Not enough to try to persuade others, and there are FOUR scum, yes? I am not sure I need to be voting at this point in the game for MY top.

Looking to find common ground.

[Fluminator]

##Vote BunnyGo

[dargorygel]

Yeah, I'm a bit lost by Flum's votes. Bunny first, then a list of people, then me?

But I'm in the middle of the list...

what does it mean?

My interpretation is above:

1) Bunny first means "bunny's question is to be answered"
2) Then the answer (but the order confuses me)
3) Then back to his actual vote.

The only odd thing, then, is that flum is NOT voting his top scumread. And since he can't talk clearly in this seance, he is seeing that others will join him on chaqa, most likely?

[kgray]

Can you vote for me if you only posted that because it's alphabetical, and you're trolling us?

[dargorygel]

If nothing else, I have seen real effort go into trying to solve the game from Jamie, Dargo, Bunny, Damo.

I've not seen nearly as much of that from Kgray, Rivera, or Macca.

Kinda feeling those three as scum. Last one is probably Bunny or Damo, or maaaaaybe Dargo or Jamie.

Hmmm... kind of a meaningless post. He says K,R, and M are scum because of lack of solvey-quotient... but then INCLUDES the solvey-folk in the end as the 'fourth' scum. Meaning that solvey really doesn't bear into chaqa's reasoning.

Umm... no.. not what I'm saying.

I'm saying that I expect one scum is probably faking being solvy, but the others are the three who aren't.

Why do you misinterpret things I say?

Because I didn't understand it?

[damo666]

##Vote BunnyGo
##Vote Chaqa
##Vote Damo
##Vote Dargorygel
##Vote Jamiet99uk
##Vote Kgray
##Vote Macca
##Vote Rdrivera

Well that's just alphabetical.

Maybe he's saying he's clueless and willing to vote anyone?

[BunnyGo]

##Vote BunnyGo
##Vote Chaqa
##Vote Damo
##Vote Dargorygel
##Vote Jamiet99uk
##Vote Kgray
##Vote Macca
##Vote Rdrivera

Well that's just alphabetical.

Which suggests he's willing to sheep a large group of people he townreads to any of us. He's doing alphabetical to show no preference. Then back to Chaqa for his preference.

[Fluminator]

##Vote Damo