M61 - The Mastermind's Revenge - Game Thread - HIDDEN

[Chaqa]

Seth could probably be in the middle group based on it seeming unlikely scum woiuld kill Maniac if seth is scum.

[Vecna]

Yeah. Vecna looks a lot better today. He's wrong about a lot of things, but he's obviously solving. Also I really liked his "gotcha" moment with me and how quickly he took that back after Jamie's claim.

Vecna/darg/Jamie in my top townreads.

I never took that back. The fact you didnt think of the fact that you claiming was likely to out a town doc to scum looks hella bad on you

[Chaqa]

Yeah. Vecna looks a lot better today. He's wrong about a lot of things, but he's obviously solving. Also I really liked his "gotcha" moment with me and how quickly he took that back after Jamie's claim.

Vecna/darg/Jamie in my top townreads.

I never took that back. The fact you didnt think of the fact that you claiming was likely to out a town doc to scum looks hella bad on you

Can you expand on this? Did I miss a kgray claim?

[ghug]

I think Macca has a good chance at being scum. The way they "pick and choose" what they understand and how it affects their reads doesn't seem authentic to me and I think they're overplaying the newb card.

Would also be happy with wagons on seth/damo/bunny.

Apparently town is all fine letting Chaqa get away with this.

##vote ghug

Hate this post.

[kgray]

Yeah. Vecna looks a lot better today. He's wrong about a lot of things, but he's obviously solving. Also I really liked his "gotcha" moment with me and how quickly he took that back after Jamie's claim.

Vecna/darg/Jamie in my top townreads.

I never took that back. The fact you didnt think of the fact that you claiming was likely to out a town doc to scum looks hella bad on you

I meant when you unvoted. And again, not commenting on this.

[ghug]

Yeah. Vecna looks a lot better today. He's wrong about a lot of things, but he's obviously solving. Also I really liked his "gotcha" moment with me and how quickly he took that back after Jamie's claim.

Vecna/darg/Jamie in my top townreads.

I never took that back. The fact you didnt think of the fact that you claiming was likely to out a town doc to scum looks hella bad on you

Can you expand on this? Did I miss a kgray claim?

She claimed she wasn't saved.

[Vecna]

all these people currently talking are way too efficient at charming theirselves into my good graces

How's this, then...
Vecna: Your’e short, your belly button sticks out too far and you’re a terrible burden on your poor mother.

You take that back! Im actually too tall for my wife (we look sort of awkward when walking together), my bellybutton is inverted way too much, and my poor mother wishes id call her more often

[Vecna]

this game really needs a higher dose of Macca, Rdrivera, Bunny and Damo figuring things out

I am here. What do you want from me?

I am a 100% confirmed vanilla town and you should know it by now.

indeed I should. But I dont. And that is not something u can blame on me for once

[Vecna]

I really feel like Macca is not the answer here. Still a solid townread.

The only thing really giving me pause on kgray at this point is that she was a plausible Maniac target, but that really just means scum have a faith healer if she is scum, so I'm ok with her as a wagon.

Bunny and Seth have been coasting long enough that I can't townread either in good conscience anymore.

What has Macca actually done besides continuously pretending/showing they have no clue about the mechanics of the game? And every time after called out he does the "oh I did somethign silly again"? And instead of figuring out what it is, he waits for people to point it out.

If you really would feel embarassed about it, you'd try to fix it after the first time, no? Not double down and bank on it completely?

[ghug]

I really feel like Macca is not the answer here. Still a solid townread.

The only thing really giving me pause on kgray at this point is that she was a plausible Maniac target, but that really just means scum have a faith healer if she is scum, so I'm ok with her as a wagon.

Bunny and Seth have been coasting long enough that I can't townread either in good conscience anymore.

What has Macca actually done besides continuously pretending/showing they have no clue about the mechanics of the game? And every time after called out they does the "oh I did somethign silly again"? And instead of figuring out what it is, he waits for people to point it out.

If you really would feel embarassed about it, you'd try to fix it after the first time, no? Not double down and bank on it completely?

How did they act when they were scum in past games?

[Jamiet99uk]

I never took that back. The fact you didnt think of the fact that you claiming was likely to out a town doc to scum looks hella bad on you

Can you expand on this? Did I miss a kgray claim?

She claimed she wasn't saved.

Interestingly, she would not know.
The Faith Healer is told if they save the life of the target.
The target is apparently *not* told they have been saved.
This is what the GM said to me when I asked.

[kgray]

I really feel like Macca is not the answer here. Still a solid townread.

The only thing really giving me pause on kgray at this point is that she was a plausible Maniac target, but that really just means scum have a faith healer if she is scum, so I'm ok with her as a wagon.

Bunny and Seth have been coasting long enough that I can't townread either in good conscience anymore.

What has Macca actually done besides continuously pretending/showing they have no clue about the mechanics of the game? And every time after called out they does the "oh I did somethign silly again"? And instead of figuring out what it is, he waits for people to point it out.

If you really would feel embarassed about it, you'd try to fix it after the first time, no? Not double down and bank on it completely?

How did they act when they were scum in past games?

When I was scum with Macca (M1015) they were mostly hesitant to post reads, avoided commenting on most players, and didn't really give reasons for their reads or votes. They came off very well as overwhelmed, confused townie.

[kgray]

Can you expand on this? Did I miss a kgray claim?

She claimed she wasn't saved.

Interestingly, she would not know.
The Faith Healer is told if they save the life of the target.
The target is apparently *not* told they have been saved.
This is what the GM said to me when I asked.

I claimed I was not targeted by Maniac.

[dargorygel]

Can you expand on this? Did I miss a kgray claim?

She claimed she wasn't saved.

Interestingly, she would not know.
The Faith Healer is told if they save the life of the target.
The target is apparently *not* told they have been saved.
This is what the GM said to me when I asked.

Hold on.
@kgray... Any comment on this?

[ghug]

What has Macca actually done besides continuously pretending/showing they have no clue about the mechanics of the game? And every time after called out they does the "oh I did somethign silly again"? And instead of figuring out what it is, he waits for people to point it out.

If you really would feel embarassed about it, you'd try to fix it after the first time, no? Not double down and bank on it completely?

How did they act when they were scum in past games?

When I was scum with Macca (M1015) they were mostly hesitant to post reads, avoided commenting on most players, and didn't really give reasons for their reads or votes. They came off very well as overwhelmed, confused townie.

You were townreading them until recently, yes? What changed?

[dargorygel]

Cross post

[ghug]

Has Macca been town? What were they like then?

[kgray]

How did they act when they were scum in past games?

When I was scum with Macca (M1015) they were mostly hesitant to post reads, avoided commenting on most players, and didn't really give reasons for their reads or votes. They came off very well as overwhelmed, confused townie.

You were townreading them until recently, yes? What changed?

Yeah, because I didn't think it was likely they'd force a townslip when answering bozo's question.

The way they have continued to play the confused card is suspicious to me, especially considering their willingness to vote me based on your "claim," them lessening their scumread of me when they realized you were joking, and their vote following you onto me after having just said they scumread you more than me. It's not consistent with them trying to figure out who's lying/manipulating people.

[kgray]

Has Macca been town? What were they like then?

afaik, only in M59 which got scrapped early. I thought they seemed a lot more open and willing to give their opinions on things in that game than in M1015.

[ghug]

Has Macca been town? What were they like then?

afaik, only in M59 which got scrapped early. I thought they seemed a lot more open and willing to give their opinions on things in that game than in M1015.

Do you think I'm more likely scum than Macca?

Are we likely to be scum together?