M61 - The Mastermind's Revenge - Game Thread - HIDDEN

[teacon7]

Did you really ask
About replacements for [word]
And also use [word]?

...so I did. This habit is going to be tough to change. I didn't even notice that one.

[ghug]

I will buy Fluminator a pizza if you are scum.

Happy?

Nope. I am not, no
Not happy at all at all
Never pizza for ghug

5-7-6...SCUM!!!

kidding. I agree with your sentiment.

Ghug's syllables: zero
Obviouslyly. Also
I am tired right now

[bozotheclown]

@bo_sox
@Chaqa
@dargorygel
@Hamilton
@HR
@Maniac
@Vecna

Can you please tell me what choices you would have made if you were scum and were making the decision for the mafia?

If not, can you please tell me why you can't or don't want to answer the question?

I don't know, because I have only glanced at the setup. I know the mafia pick some roles out of a hat and recruit someone. I know they have money or some shit to do things with. I would probably have recruited someone who obvtowned during the pregame, which from my perspective excludes Jamie, ghug, and Vecna, and gone into major debt to get some fancy toys assuming that we can all lurk our way to not dying D1 (which means that Chaqa isn't on my team).

OK, I will add you to the pile of players who have indicated they could not be scum because they did not read or understand the setup and therefore could not have considered what roles to select in the first 24 hours.

[ghug]

@bo_sox
@Chaqa
@dargorygel
@Hamilton
@HR
@Maniac
@Vecna

Can you please tell me what choices you would have made if you were scum and were making the decision for the mafia?

If not, can you please tell me why you can't or don't want to answer the question?

I don't know, because I have only glanced at the setup. I know the mafia pick some roles out of a hat and recruit someone. I know they have money or some shit to do things with. I would probably have recruited someone who obvtowned during the pregame, which from my perspective excludes Jamie, ghug, and Vecna, and gone into major debt to get some fancy toys assuming that we can all lurk our way to not dying D1 (which means that Chaqa isn't on my team).

OK, I will add you to the pile of players who have indicated they could not be scum because they did not read or understand the setup and therefore could not have considered what roles to select in the first 24 hours.

Bo's feels forced, scumlean
Can you group all the answers
Into single post?

[bozotheclown]

Teacon's really not living up to my memory of him as a perpetual lurker

I do not remember teacon ever lurking.

[ghug]

We should not kill Flum
Yet. I like him, mechanics
Are a bad reason

[ghug]

Teacon's really not living up to my memory of him as a perpetual lurker

I do not remember teacon ever lurking.

Mafia twenty two
Is perhaps the most striking
It is his meta

[bozotheclown]

I am not going to be online at EOD.

One concern I have is that if Durga asked for a sub because she is too busy, she would be more likely to do so as scum.

##VOTE BunnyGo

[Hellenic Riot]

I am not going to be online at EOD.

One concern I have is that if Durga asked for a sub because she is too busy, she would be more likely to do so as scum.

##VOTE BunnyGo

I'd love this to be true just because we could then say Durga pulled a Chaqa

[BunnyGo]

First, a couple replies to Bunny.

I don't recall ever playing with you before. Have we played together? I think I'd remember you.

We played as reavers together in m52:
http://mafia.peterlund.se/m52/game_status.txt

You don't remember this? We worked hard enough at passing the silly press rules that we didn't get caught by town so much as dinged on minor things by the GM. Fun game.

OH YEAH!! I had a lot of fun baiting you as Wash, and then having to work around all my ground game when I was town. Reaver!Bunny was very upset with Pilot!Bunny.

[worcej]

GM Note:
Please ensure you submit your orders for actions to both Donny and myself in the event one of us is unavailable to process phases.

[Hamilton Brian]

I am not going to be online at EOD.

One concern I have is that if Durga asked for a sub because she is too busy, she would be more likely to do so as scum.

##VOTE BunnyGo

That's a hell of a lot of hopping through some hoops (sorry Bunny) to arrive at, but it might have legs. It's not foolproof but it's a good as any other vote thus far.

[bo_sox48]

I don't know, because I have only glanced at the setup. I know the mafia pick some roles out of a hat and recruit someone. I know they have money or some shit to do things with. I would probably have recruited someone who obvtowned during the pregame, which from my perspective excludes Jamie, ghug, and Vecna, and gone into major debt to get some fancy toys assuming that we can all lurk our way to not dying D1 (which means that Chaqa isn't on my team).

OK, I will add you to the pile of players who have indicated they could not be scum because they did not read or understand the setup and therefore could not have considered what roles to select in the first 24 hours.

Bo's feels forced, scumlean
Can you group all the answers
Into single post?

Your grammar is bad
y u no english better
Muy estupido

[Hamilton Brian]

I can't get past the mutual antipathy being shown between ghug and jamie. While I might think, "that's kind of scummy of you two," I also feel like there have been some contributions that make me think they're on the level.

I'm hot and cold on Flum being scum, but teacon has also come under some scrutiny. At this point I don't think they've necessarily acquitted themselves enough for me to say, "they're definitely town."

[BunnyGo]

I am not going to be online at EOD.

One concern I have is that if Durga asked for a sub because she is too busy, she would be more likely to do so as scum.

##VOTE BunnyGo

That's a hell of a lot of hopping through some hoops (sorry Bunny) to arrive at, but it might have legs. It's not foolproof but it's a good as any other vote thus far.

This would be the most spectacular way I get miskilled D1 yet.

I think it's pretty obvious why she quit...this game is insane. Honestly, it'd take less work as scum because I'd know something about the mechanics. This partial open partial closed format is crazy. It means we just have to read people. Which takes effort.

[teacon7]

Teacon's really not living up to my memory of him as a perpetual lurker

I do not remember teacon ever lurking.

Mafia twenty two
Is perhaps the most striking
It is his meta

My ineptitude
and lurking, has since proven
to be NAI.

...but whatever.

[damo666]

##vote Flum

I think he's got caught and is flapping.

Flum the sealion

You think Flum is "flapping" because he made an obvious joke scumslip?

No, because he's backtracking on the massclaim suggestion

[Hamilton Brian]

##vote Flum

I think he's got caught and is flapping.

Flum the sealion

You think Flum is "flapping" because he made an obvious joke scumslip?

No, because he's backtracking on the massclaim suggestion

Is it backtracking or just a resigned, "massclaiming is a bad idea; fine."

[damo666]

You think Flum is "flapping" because he made an obvious joke scumslip?

No, because he's backtracking on the massclaim suggestion

Is it backtracking or just a resigned, "massclaiming is a bad idea; fine."

I'd say such resignation was merely a subset of backtracking.

[Jamiet99uk]

That conclusion came from what I would have done and confirmed by rdrivera and dargorygel as reasonable, but I am still allowing for the possibility the mafia went the way damo suggested.

You conducted a survey and then drew some conclusions based on what you would have done, using the very limited survey results as reference data.

I see. This is very poor work from a quantitative research perspective.