M59 - Duck Season? - Game Thread

[dargorygel]

Here is the player list from this rendition... please indicate whether you can start again on Tuesday.

PLAYER LIST

Starters:
Durga
Vecna
kgray
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
seth24c
goldfinger0303
summit_fever
worcej
damo666
bozotheclown
Macca573
BunnyGo
foodcoats
MoscowFleet
hthefourth
Fluminator
Tom Bombadil
TrPrado
flash2015
yavuzovic

Subs:
Hamilton Brian
e.m.c^42
ghug

[Jamiet99uk]

PLAYER LIST

Starters:
Durga - definitely will play
Vecna
kgray
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
seth24c
goldfinger0303
summit_fever
worcej
damo666
bozotheclown
Macca573 - cannot play
BunnyGo
foodcoats
MoscowFleet
hthefourth
Fluminator
Tom Bombadil
TrPrado
flash2015
yavuzovic

Subs:
Hamilton Brian
e.m.c^42
ghug

[dargorygel]

I have not heard from bo if he is able to host again... this list signup sorta depends on that.
But starting the list seemed like a good idea.

[dargorygel]

cross post with Jamie... sorry

[dargorygel]

(I am sure that some people are unable to play again... so newcomers would be welcome to add their name to the bottom)

[Vecna]

Had the team found you yet? You weren’t told which scum was which? Who was last team member?

Flum the Lawyer

For real?????

My d1 reads were pretty on point

[Vecna]

what was the hint in the witch doctor video that I missed?

[Fluminator]

Lol Vecna you were annoying. How did you kill Tom though. We thought you were very possibly the jailor but the RB was useless.
Me and Goldie did not read the roles very well apparently.

[Vecna]

My role pm was missing a bit of info.

I was told in the last 15 minutes of d1 that I had to pick a target during the day lol. After entering the kill, I received the role block pm, and then still got the pleasant surprise that tom still died (and that the RB transfered to the day).

[damo666]

PLAYER LIST

Starters:
Durga - definitely will play
Vecna
kgray
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
seth24c
goldfinger0303
summit_fever
worcej
damo666 Yes
bozotheclown
Macca573 - cannot play
BunnyGo
foodcoats
MoscowFleet
hthefourth
Fluminator
Tom Bombadil
TrPrado
flash2015
yavuzovic

Subs:
Hamilton Brian
e.m.c^42
ghug

[Jamiet99uk]

Lol Vecna you were annoying. How did you kill Tom though. We thought you were very possibly the jailor but the RB was useless.
Me and Goldie did not read the roles very well apparently.

Our reasoning as GMs was as follows:

The Jailor is a roleblocking role. If it could be roleblocked at night this would prevent the jailing in the first place, rather than only preventing the kill. This, however, is impossible to implement in practice since the jailed person is removed from normal play at the *start* of the night.

We therefore took the view that the most balanced outcome would be to have a Roleblock on the Jailor cause them to lose their next jailing opportunity (i.e. a Roleblock on the Jailor N1 causes them to jail nobody on N2).

[Fluminator]

Also, sure I'll play again.

I'd recommend giving the scum team in the PMs to the scum players.
Also think you should take out the informed townie.
Other than that good setup

[Durga]

Also, sure I'll play again.

I'd recommend giving the scum team in the PMs to the scum players.
Also think you should take out the informed townie.
Other than that good setup

You have to tell the scum team who the other scum is IN the PM, otherwise it's too easy to play d1 without knowing. Which means the game is skewed

[Jamiet99uk]

PLAYER LIST

Starters:
Durga - YES
Vecna
kgray
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
seth24c
goldfinger0303
summit_fever
worcej
damo666 - YES
bozotheclown
Macca573 - cannot play
BunnyGo
foodcoats
MoscowFleet
hthefourth
Fluminator - YES
Tom Bombadil
TrPrado
flash2015
yavuzovic

Subs:
Hamilton Brian
e.m.c^42
ghug

[Jamiet99uk]

Also, sure I'll play again.

I'd recommend giving the scum team in the PMs to the scum players.
Also think you should take out the informed townie.
Other than that good setup

You have to tell the scum team who the other scum is IN the PM, otherwise it's too easy to play d1 without knowing. Which means the game is skewed

I agree.

[Hellenic Riot]

Hmm, goldie changed it up quite well, though a guilty would've pretty much finished this off.

I guess that informed townie role explains why Macca had such an inexplicable townread on me

[Durga]

what was the hint in the witch doctor video that I missed?

There wasn't any hint. I was just telling the witch doctor that I was in love with you.

Jk, I was hoping anyone seeing that wouldn't risk killing you

[bozotheclown]

I was just a VT doing stupid shit.

Also, always remember - scum try to tie votes. I missed EOD and checked the bot several hours later and literally thought you let goldie tie it lol

I was going to move back to gold when he voted for you

I was about to vote for goldfinger also but then the game was paused. I told you scum use the self vote as a ploy, and I am always willing to vote for a town who chooses to self vote.

[Hellenic Riot]

Also, I'm in for the replay

[Vecna]

PLAYER LIST

Starters:
Durga - YES
Vecna - yes
kgray
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
seth24c
goldfinger0303
summit_fever
worcej
damo666 - YES
bozotheclown
Macca573 - cannot play
BunnyGo
foodcoats
MoscowFleet
hthefourth
Fluminator - YES
Tom Bombadil
TrPrado
flash2015
yavuzovic

Subs:
Hamilton Brian
e.m.c^42
ghug