M59 - Duck Season? - Game Thread

[summit_fever]

seth had no interactions with tom or moscow. Townread tom at the top and hasn't done anything townie.

Just shoot seth.

[Jamiet99uk]

GM NOTE

Please try to avoid using the L-word. Ta.

[kgray]

If we're doing a test is bozo the best one though? Like, if this theory is wrong I'm feeling pretty towny about bozo.

meh, if bozo did screw the scumteam by outing them like that we can make a strong statement by showing hes the lynch so they cant wriggle out of it
and just like, concede or w/e.

I feel it fits quite nicely, and if he flips traitor its a done deal for the rest of em

I still say bozo is not that incompetent.

Yet you thought Tom might so blatantly signal that he was the traitor? If this signal is real, bozo's is much less obvious until scum start flipping. And he did defend Moscow pretty hard at EOD.

[Vecna]

If we're doing a test is bozo the best one though? Like, if this theory is wrong I'm feeling pretty towny about bozo.

meh, if bozo did screw the scumteam by outing them like that we can make a strong statement by showing hes the lynch so they cant wriggle out of it
and just like, concede or w/e.

I feel it fits quite nicely, and if he flips traitor its a done deal for the rest of em

I still say bozo is not that incompetent.

well youre on the proposed scumteam, so you would say that.

[Jamiet99uk]

VOTE COUNT 2.0

worcej (3) - TrPrado, kgray, goldfinger0303
foodcoats (2) - Hellenic Riot, rdrivera2005
Hellenic Riot (1) - Fluminator
bozotheclown (1) - Vecna
goldfinger0303 (1) - BunnyGo

WORCEJ is set to be erased.

Most of the time is left.

[goldfinger0303]

I support the worcej wagon, but now that I’ve given him a 1 day reprieve does anyone else see how scummy goldie is? He’s playing exactly like his matrix game. He’s anchoring reasons to not be here, and then shows up as much as I do. Shoot him Flum. ##vote Gold (lets get 2 good options...worcej is also good)

I mean, I *have* been absent for good 5-6 hour chunks of the game, which is unlike me. Yesterday I really only checked in briefly once since lunchtime to see the results of the daykill, and then not again for ~6 hours more. I don't see why trying to engage despite being busy is a bad thing. Bash me for reads (or lack of), lines of questioning, logic, votes. Something tangible.

[Fluminator]

I'm not going to hipfire lol. And HR knew I wouldn't.

I think I'll shoot whoever the top wagon is in 24 hours. That way we can maximize information and get essentially two daykills in. As hard as it is for me to not just yolo a shot.

[summit_fever]

##vote seth

[Vecna]

or just hipfire bozo. that way we either confirm that theory and end the game, or we can put the theory out of our minds and use the day for actual scumhunting.

[Hellenic Riot]

I'm not really seeing the worcej case over food or Durga here

Can you read the interaction between worcej and I on pages 36-40 and tell me if you agree that it looks like he was doing everything he could to make my questioning of Moscow look fabricated and insincere?

It's definitely possible I'm taking it too personally, but the last time I felt this way about someone who brushed off my points and constantly misunderstood what I was saying, it was scum!Bunny trying to get me flustered and dismissed.

I just went back and read these, and I don't really agree. In those *exact* pages while he was questioning your push on Moscow he was also repeatedly making his own push on Tom Bombadil, and also questioning your own townread on... Himself. I find it very hard to believe that he would try to take pressure off of one teammate by putting it onto himself AND another teammate. I'm more opposed to the worcej wagon than I was before after that reread.

[BunnyGo]

seth had no interactions with tom or moscow. Townread tom at the top and hasn't done anything townie.

Just shoot seth.

That’s a nice idea too.

[worcej]

I'm not going to hipfire lol. And HR knew I wouldn't.

I think I'll shoot whoever the top wagon is in 24 hours. That way we can maximize information and get essentially two daykills in. As hard as it is for me to not just yolo a shot.

I like this, but also think you don’t actually have the gun and are just making noise.

[Fluminator]

Bozo would be the most surprising scumflip to me out of Bunny/Durga/Bozo.
But I also don't really want to kill Bunny or Durga yet lol.

Bunny, when can drunk bunny make an appearance?
Durga, you feel like you've given up. Shouldn't you be excited at this point? Let's win this.

[Hellenic Riot]

meh, if bozo did screw the scumteam by outing them like that we can make a strong statement by showing hes the lynch so they cant wriggle out of it
and just like, concede or w/e.

I feel it fits quite nicely, and if he flips traitor its a done deal for the rest of em

I still say bozo is not that incompetent.

Yet you thought Tom might so blatantly signal that he was the traitor? If this signal is real, bozo's is much less obvious until scum start flipping. And he did defend Moscow pretty hard at EOD.

The alternative here is plausible: The reason Bunny started calling Tom out as being traitor is because Bunny is the Traitor and he knew Tom was his teammate.

[BunnyGo]

I'm not going to hipfire lol. And HR knew I wouldn't.

I think I'll shoot whoever the top wagon is in 24 hours. That way we can maximize information and get essentially two daykills in. As hard as it is for me to not just yolo a shot.

I like this, but also think you don’t actually have the gun and are just making noise.

Also good.

[bozotheclown]

or just hipfire bozo. that way we either confirm that theory and end the game, or we can put the theory out of our minds and use the day for actual scumhunting.

This is a fairly poor suggestion. What if I am a town PR?

[BunnyGo]

I still say bozo is not that incompetent.

Yet you thought Tom might so blatantly signal that he was the traitor? If this signal is real, bozo's is much less obvious until scum start flipping. And he did defend Moscow pretty hard at EOD.

The alternative here is plausible: The reason Bunny started calling Tom out as being traitor is because Bunny is the Traitor and he knew Tom was his teammate.

That is also a good theory. I did see the signal bozo could have been giving right away, but discounted because I’m Town.

[BunnyGo]

Bozo would be the most surprising scumflip to me out of Bunny/Durga/Bozo.
But I also don't really want to kill Bunny or Durga yet lol.

Bunny, when can drunk bunny make an appearance?
Durga, you feel like you've given up. Shouldn't you be excited at this point? Let's win this.

I’ve started drinking. Probably 2 hours.

[Hellenic Riot]

Anyway, I hate to risk the voodoo that is Night Kill Analysis after the shitshow last game... But why the hell is Damo the mafia kill N1? It's categorically not a fearkill (top memes if it actually was), which means they must have thought he was a PR.


And when Damo + PR come to mind... That brings us back to his push on foodcoats. And if they thought that Damo was the PR who was misreading Foodcoats as setting up for a cc against him, that also implies the scumteam had prior knowledge that foodcoats was not the PR in the first place.

[worcej]

or just hipfire bozo. that way we either confirm that theory and end the game, or we can put the theory out of our minds and use the day for actual scumhunting.

This is a fairly poor suggestion. What if I am a town PR?

Of all people that play here, you are the one that never gives a crap about protecting PRs over information.

We get info if you die, so why try to protect yourself now?