M59 - Duck Season? - Game Thread

[bozotheclown]

I am surprised there is no interest in flash today. M47 demonstrated that he will use his history of low D1 participation to his advantage as scum.

[foodcoats]

Maybe not, but I do not see any point in just ignoring what damo said.

I don't think I ignored it. I strongly objected to it.

We can return to it later if I am alive.

I do not know if leaving this speculation unresolved is helping town.

If I crumbed, and I discussed it, wouldn't you still have to decide whether I true-crumbed or whether I fake-crumbed? And if I true-crumbed, wouldn't that only benefit scum? And if I fake-crumbed, wouldn't that possibly just contribute to more WIFOM for town?

BAD. BAD BOZO. DOWN, BOY. DOWN! YOU'RE A DOG YOU DON'T KNOW HOW TO GAME THEORY. OUTSIDE! OUTSIDE! NO POTTY INSIDE!

[summit_fever]

The bozo wagon is very silly. bozo is lord and saviour of weird entrances.

I would sheep bozo because he’s great but Tom’s Taz soft is on balance more likely town, so bozo is likely wrong.

damo gave me a weird vibe and I don’t like unvotes. I fear classing damo too early but he may be scum here.

Summit I think is town for already pointing out bozo’s true meta.

worcej is spamming and I am resisting spamkilling.

Durga put in effort to make multiquotes from multiple authors in the same post but without advancing a major narrative which looks like scum tryharding.

Typical BunnyGo.

goldfinger gets a long leer.

Flum and Vecna seem like Flum and Vecna.

Yavu, HR, Macca, TrPrado and seth I’ve got nothing.

I like hthe for sincerity.

kgray votes me for lurking which is unrepresentative of me. Is that scummy?

Flash feels slightly too active to be townflash.

MoscowFleet should be “Fleet Moscow” or “F Mos” and the technical impossibility is too smarmy for my taste but otherwise seems town.

##VOTE damo666

Not sure what to think about this post; I agree with some of it, but it seems hastily put together.

Do you have a reason for disliking unvotes?

Are you asking if kgray is scummy for her reasoning or that you're scummy for looking quite different day 1 to your last game?

Hopefully we see some more from you.

You can always vote, and you must, so outside of a hammer risk, unvoting is pointless. I’ve always found it looks like reorganizing the furniture or scumfear.

I was asking kgray if she thinks my strategy when drawing scum is to think, “I know what I’ll do, I’ll lurk! They’ll never guess I’m scum that way.”

Be seeing you.

Just a heads up that unvotes are regarded as no-kill votes and are valid at end of day.

[Durga]

Food's reads just can't be real. They are so out of touch. That scum team is worse than his reads list.

[Durga]

I am surprised there is no interest in flash today. M47 demonstrated that he will use his history of low D1 participation to his advantage as scum.

This is a good point except that I thought he always had low participation. I'm not opposed to a flash kill

[bozotheclown]

I am surprised there is no interest in flash today. M47 demonstrated that he will use his history of low D1 participation to his advantage as scum.

This is a good point except that I thought he always had low participation. I'm not opposed to a flash kill

flash has limited history as scum, but what he has done D1 here most matched M47, where he was scum. I suspect he will stay away as long as he is not getting votes.

[seth24c]

Is there a reason to townread seth? I don't see it.

##vote seth

So do you scumread me? Or just not townread me.

[foodcoats]

@bozo I apologize for my comment above... that was rude. I always get too loose in this game.

I actually think you're the best player here, but I don't understand why you think we should discuss PRs.

[bozotheclown]

I don't think I ignored it. I strongly objected to it.

We can return to it later if I am alive.

I do not know if leaving this speculation unresolved is helping town.

If I crumbed, and I discussed it, wouldn't you still have to decide whether I true-crumbed or whether I fake-crumbed? And if I true-crumbed, wouldn't that only benefit scum? And if I fake-crumbed, wouldn't that possibly just contribute to more WIFOM for town?

BAD. BAD BOZO. DOWN, BOY. DOWN! YOU'RE A DOG YOU DON'T KNOW HOW TO GAME THEORY. OUTSIDE! OUTSIDE! NO POTTY INSIDE!

If you just said that you were not crumbing a role, it would put an end to the speculation.

[foodcoats]

Not sure what to think about this post; I agree with some of it, but it seems hastily put together.

Do you have a reason for disliking unvotes?

Are you asking if kgray is scummy for her reasoning or that you're scummy for looking quite different day 1 to your last game?

Hopefully we see some more from you.

You can always vote, and you must, so outside of a hammer risk, unvoting is pointless. I’ve always found it looks like reorganizing the furniture or scumfear.

I was asking kgray if she thinks my strategy when drawing scum is to think, “I know what I’ll do, I’ll lurk! They’ll never guess I’m scum that way.”

Be seeing you.

Just a heads up that unvotes are regarded as no-kill votes and are valid at end of day.

So unvotes are counted as "No-DK?" Intermesting. Thank you.

[bozotheclown]

@bozo I apologize for my comment above... that was rude. I always get too loose in this game.

I actually think you're the best player here, but I don't understand why you think we should discuss PRs.

Considering you and damo were the top wagons when damo brought it up, I think damo forced the issue.

[bozotheclown]

Food's reads just can't be real. They are so out of touch. That scum team is worse than his reads list.

It did not seem unreasonable to me. What reads do you find most objectionable?

[foodcoats]

@bozo I apologize for my comment above... that was rude. I always get too loose in this game.

I actually think you're the best player here, but I don't understand why you think we should discuss PRs.

Considering you and damo were the top wagons when damo brought it up, I think damo forced the issue.

I just realized that damo is town. If he was scum and thought I crumbed something worthwhile he'd just propose me as an NK to his team.

[hthefourth]

I think Durga may be scum, but I think Macca's iso is very scummy (I debated whether it could be a new player thing [whether or not they are new - I don't know them] but it's even scummier as a new mafia player, I think). It's super wishy washy and empty. I especially don't like "not having scumreads." DKing an absent player may be bad form but maybe that's a defense strategy. Maybe Durga is bussing Macca. Durga never explained why she moved off of my wagon. Mayhaps an axis of evil.

##VOTE Macca

@Durga, you said that Macca "hasn't changed." Are there other reasons that you are scumreading Macca right now? Also, since you moved your vote from foodcoats to Macca, you've still been throwing a lot of flak foodcoats' way. Why move your vote?

foodcoats' "axis of evil" comment seems really brash to me. But I'd still like to have these questions answered.

[BunnyGo]

@bozo I apologize for my comment above... that was rude. I always get too loose in this game.

I actually think you're the best player here, but I don't understand why you think we should discuss PRs.

Considering you and damo were the top wagons when damo brought it up, I think damo forced the issue.

I just realized that damo is town. If he was scum and thought I crumbed something worthwhile he'd just propose me as an NK to his team.

Not necessarily:

Imagine there was little movement to end of day and you managed to survive and he didn’t. Then he gets dead and doesn’t get to tell his team what he saw. That said it was pretty early. But pointing it out too close to EOD would make him dead.

[BunnyGo]

Ok, no worcej movement and I’m less thrilled with the leading wagons. Get back up there ##vote food

[bozotheclown]

@bozo I apologize for my comment above... that was rude. I always get too loose in this game.

I actually think you're the best player here, but I don't understand why you think we should discuss PRs.

Considering you and damo were the top wagons when damo brought it up, I think damo forced the issue.

I just realized that damo is town. If he was scum and thought I crumbed something worthwhile he'd just propose me as an NK to his team.

That certainly is what he wants you to think.

[bo_sox48]

VOTE COUNT 1.9

MoscowFleet (4) - rdrivera2005, Vecna, Fluminator, damo666
foodcoats (3) - kgray, Hellenic Riot, BunnyGo
Macca573 (3) - Durga, foodcoats, MoscowFleet
bozotheclown (3) - yavuzovic, worcej, seth24c
damo666 (2) - Tom Bombadil, Macca573
seth24c (1) - summit_fever
summit_fever (1) - flash2015
BunnyGo (1) - hthefourth
yavuzovic (1) - TrPrado
flash2015 (1) - bozotheclown
TrPrado (1) - goldfinger0303

MOSCOWFLEET is currently set to have an Acme anvil dropped on his head.

There are just under 4 hours left in day 1.

[Durga]

I think Durga may be scum, but I think Macca's iso is very scummy (I debated whether it could be a new player thing [whether or not they are new - I don't know them] but it's even scummier as a new mafia player, I think). It's super wishy washy and empty. I especially don't like "not having scumreads." DKing an absent player may be bad form but maybe that's a defense strategy. Maybe Durga is bussing Macca. Durga never explained why she moved off of my wagon. Mayhaps an axis of evil.

##VOTE Macca

@Durga, you said that Macca "hasn't changed." Are there other reasons that you are scumreading Macca right now? Also, since you moved your vote from foodcoats to Macca, you've still been throwing a lot of flak foodcoats' way. Why move your vote?

foodcoats' "axis of evil" comment seems really brash to me. But I'd still like to have these questions answered.

Well not really, other than his meta here is the same as it was when he was scum. And he deserves more pressure. I don't like that he came up with another excuse for not being around at EoD when I def remember him saying he could have been around last game but chose not to because he was scum.

Yeah, I moved my vote because food was actually engaging. But his post quality has remained garbage, and I'm actually ready to

##vote food

[BunnyGo]

@Durga, you said that Macca "hasn't changed." Are there other reasons that you are scumreading Macca right now? Also, since you moved your vote from foodcoats to Macca, you've still been throwing a lot of flak foodcoats' way. Why move your vote?

foodcoats' "axis of evil" comment seems really brash to me. But I'd still like to have these questions answered.

Well not really, other than his meta here is the same as it was when he was scum. And he deserves more pressure. I don't like that he came up with another excuse for not being around at EoD when I def remember him saying he could have been around last game but chose not to because he was scum.

Yeah, I moved my vote because food was actually engaging. But his post quality has remained garbage, and I'm actually ready to

##vote food

I wasn’t paying attention to Macca as scum. He said he could make it in general but chose not to when he was scum with no pressure?