M59 - Duck Season? - Game Thread

[MoscowFleet]

OK that's believable

##unvote

This doesn't answer the question, damo. If you didn't think he was the traitor, what were you referring to when you said "Is it worth taking the risk?".

I don't follow. It is what I was referring to.

..ooookay, I'll make it easier to follow.

Is it worth taking the risk?

##vote Tom

Can you explain exactly what you meant by this post and vote? If you think you've already explained it, humour me and explain again, thanks.

[yavuzovic]

I missed an important part of the game when I prepared my last post. I will add anything missing now.

[Hellenic Riot]

It’s been a long time since I played with MF. But I remember him both being subbed out occasionally and lurking frequently.

Out of interest, how many times are you going to mention how long it's been since you played with MoscowFleet?

[yavuzovic]

And for what it’s worth, there was no scheme intended. It’s was literally a memory from me as a kid that the flavor reminded me of.

OK that's believable

##unvote

This doesn't answer the question, damo. If you didn't think he was the traitor, what were you referring to when you said "Is it worth taking the risk?".

damo666 looks confused. I believe I know something about him

[damo666]

@Moscow

When I voted Tom I was saying is it worth taking the risk not daykilling him in case he is the Tasmanian Devil.

I am now convinced enough that he was not signalling and I don't want him miskilled because he is valuable as town.

@Yav why do you think I am confused?

[damo666]

and @Yav what do think you know about me?

[yavuzovic]

Alright
> Goldfinger0303 has a question about the deadline. BunnyG and Fluminator claimed that he might be trying to prepare a nest to lurk. (Maybe he is! When I was mafia, I would try to avoid so that I would have a smaller risk of making a mistake. He may be genuinely busy though.)
> Food and HR are lurking but I saw a recent post from HR so I'm listing him out of lurkers for now.

[yavuzovic]

and @Yav what do think you know about me?

I have a guess on your role

[yavuzovic]

@Yav why do you think I am confused?

Well nothing solid BUT your votes definitely LOOK LIKE you are confused.

[Tom Bombadil]

It’s been a long time since I played with MF. But I remember him both being subbed out occasionally and lurking frequently.

Out of interest, how many times are you going to mention how long it's been since you played with MoscowFleet?

I’m not really following this? I was asked directly by bozo the last time I played with Moscow and answered the question. So one time I guess...

[Tom Bombadil]

Alright
> Goldfinger0303 has a question about the deadline. BunnyG and Fluminator claimed that he might be trying to prepare a nest to lurk. (Maybe he is! When I was mafia, I would try to avoid so that I would have a smaller risk of making a mistake. He may be genuinely busy though.)
> Food and HR are lurking but I saw a recent post from HR so I'm listing him out of lurkers for now.

Yav - Do you find Goldie saying he is busy and then lurking more suspicious than people just lurking without any warning/excuse?

[Tom Bombadil]

@Moscow

When I voted Tom I was saying is it worth taking the risk not daykilling him in case he is the Tasmanian Devil.

I am now convinced enough that he was not signalling and I don't want him miskilled because he is valuable as town.

@Yav why do you think I am confused?

What specifically convinced you that I wasn’t signaling?

[damo666]

@Moscow

When I voted Tom I was saying is it worth taking the risk not daykilling him in case he is the Tasmanian Devil.

I am now convinced enough that he was not signalling and I don't want him miskilled because he is valuable as town.

@Yav why do you think I am confused?

What specifically convinced you that I wasn’t signaling?

The emboldened paragraph in the thread I unvoted you.

[damo666]

@Yav why do you think I am confused?

Well nothing solid BUT your votes definitely LOOK LIKE you are confused.

Well I'm confused to the extent that as a townie I lack information.

[damo666]

and @Yav what do think you know about me?

I have a guess on your role

What is the probability you are right?

[kgray]

Interesting defense of Tom. Out of the blue.

I thought so too.

@hthefourth, assuming you now know why Bunny thought Tom's post seemed odd, do you still think he has scum motivations for bringing it up?

I mean, I think the reasons are pretty thin. However, that may be more an indication of me being a noob to this game online (i.e. without the benefit of body language/tone) than anything else. Most times I've played, the bit "such and such looks suspicious" without further elaboration is just lazy shit-throwing, which doesn't help the town win even if the person doing it is actually town.

Now that I have seen that Bunny has rationale for their accusations, I can't complain.

And what do you think about Bunny's rationale itself? Do you think Bunny is more likely to act the way he did as town or as scum?

[kgray]

> Hthe has an objection about it and votes BunnyGo for this claim. ( Actually towny for Bunny)

Why do you think Bunny's actions were towny?

> Bozo follows him but doesn't seem serious and it's too early to suggest a lynch. Right after that he places a bunch of votes which is weird.

Bozo voted for Tom before damo did, and the only votes he placed after his first vote for Tom was one for MoscowFleet and then another moving back to Tom (which was still before damo's vote for Tom).

[TrPrado]

Is this the tom post y'all are talking about?

I assume it’s the one where he specifically referenced the character for the flavor of the traitor role without being prompted :)

taz tshirt?

That's the one! I saw it and knew how people would react but it's not exactly a worthwhile discussion because it seems like it would just lead to a rabbit hole of WIFOM.

[BunnyGo]

What do we have now
> Tom blatantly referring to Tazmanian Devil
> Hthe has an objection about it and votes BunnyGo for this claim. ( Actually towny for Bunny)
> Bozo follows him but doesn't seem serious and it's too early to suggest a day kill. Right after that he places a bunch of votes which is weird.

Am I missing an important point? I'm usually careless.

(By the way, looking Vecna's messages; he is like the great town Vecna. Doesn't have a long serious post but touches important points. I don't remember the exact game (it's been some time I haven't played) where he was a difficult town player for us the scums.)

Message modified for word usage.

[TrPrado]

Because bozo, you voted many times with weak reasoning, I know that you would have better reasons if you were serious. You are probably not serious though. I don't strongly scumread you but you are the lead anyway.

List of people I have gotten Bad Vibes (TM) from is now Macca and yavuz