M1015 - Super Mafioso Bros

[Jamiet99uk]

Could you explain why Summit is more scummy to you then HR?

I'm pretty convinced they're both scum (the only other likely option I can see is you and Jamie on a team) and choosing one over the other is like splitting hairs.

In previous games where I've played with town!summit, he's made some observant points, and he hasn't done that here. He seems afraid to contribute, especially now at this stage in the game. I think his townread of Hamilton seemed forced and like he already knew Hamilton was town, and I also don't like how much he's been focused on Macca. I think summit is likely scum and he's been going after Macca as an easy target.

HR has spent most of the game hyper focused on Hamilton and, as I mentioned in my longer post earlier this phase, some of his arguments for scum!Hamilton seem like he was trying to push a narrative to get a miskill. But at times he does feel genuine so he's not quite as high on my scumlist as summit.

Why do you think HR is more likely scum than summit?

I have the same feelings as you about Summit. He was obviously town in many games and this game he is just lacking.

HR on the other side seems just likely his scum game on Matrix. Pushing town kills and tryng to look scum hunting but without teeth. Compare with last game were he was town and NKed D1. That insistence on scum NKing Damo is also completely out of character, HR is a smart player.

He didn't "insist" that Damo had been the scum kill. He said it was possible. People were ruling it out as impossible. Some people need to learn the difference between "unlikely" and "impossible". I actually said the same. It's weird you're fixating on HR for this point.

[Hellenic Riot]

I was fixated on HB being scum because I could not, and still cannot, remotely fathom why he didn't vote me D2. Him flipping town has taken so much out of me that I had to resort to VCA, which is full barrel-scraping territory, and I scumread essentially everybody except Bo now. And I just cannot be bothered fighting this as a result, so if you're going to kill me, roll away.


If anyone can come up with a single reason as to why Summit is town, I'm all ears, but I'm mostly checking out now. Vote as you will.

[Hellenic Riot]

Could you explain why Summit is more scummy to you then HR?

I'm pretty convinced they're both scum (the only other likely option I can see is you and Jamie on a team) and choosing one over the other is like splitting hairs.

In previous games where I've played with town!summit, he's made some observant points, and he hasn't done that here. He seems afraid to contribute, especially now at this stage in the game. I think his townread of Hamilton seemed forced and like he already knew Hamilton was town, and I also don't like how much he's been focused on Macca. I think summit is likely scum and he's been going after Macca as an easy target.

HR has spent most of the game hyper focused on Hamilton and, as I mentioned in my longer post earlier this phase, some of his arguments for scum!Hamilton seem like he was trying to push a narrative to get a miskill. But at times he does feel genuine so he's not quite as high on my scumlist as summit.

Why do you think HR is more likely scum than summit?

I have the same feelings as you about Summit. He was obviously town in many games and this game he is just lacking.

HR on the other side seems just likely his scum game on Matrix. Pushing town kills and tryng to look scum hunting but without teeth. Compare with last game were he was town and NKed D1. That insistence on scum NKing Damo is also completely out of character, HR is a smart player.

Actually, I'd love to hear how I've been without teeth this game. You spent the whole of M57 saying I was letting people off easily - When on earth have I done that here?

[summit_fever]

MOST SCUM - macca - bo - HR - Kgray - Rivera - Jamie - MOST TOWN

Not really too confident with the inside reads but I'm confident jamie is town and macca is scum.

[bo_sox48]

SCUM - Jamie / HR / summit / rdrivera / kgray / a really long dropoff / Macca - TOWN

[Jamiet99uk]

SCUM - Jamie / HR / summit / rdrivera / kgray / a really long dropoff / Macca - TOWN

I am your TOP scumread?

No.

[bo_sox48]

I think the most likely team is you, HR, and summit.

[bo_sox48]

The cold shot on Vecna D1 was done by either you or HR, that much I am confident in.

[summit_fever]

KGRAY says:
MOST SCUM - Summit > HR > Rdr > Jamie > Bo > Macca - MOST TOWN

JAMIET says:
MOST SCUM - Summit > HR > Rdr > Macca > Kgray > Bo - MOST TOWN

RDRIVERA says:
MOST SCUM - HR >Summit > Kgray > Macca > Bo > Jamiet - MOST TOWN

SUMMIT says:
MOST SCUM - macca - bo - HR - Kgray - Rivera - Jamie - MOST TOWN

BO_SOX says:
SCUM - Jamie / HR / summit / rdrivera / kgray / a really long dropoff / Macca - TOWN

[summit_fever]

The cold shot on Vecna D1 was done by either you or HR, that much I am confident in.

Why are you so confident in reading a day 1 nightkill?

[Jamiet99uk]

The cold shot on Vecna D1 was done by either you or HR, that much I am confident in.

Well it wasn't me

[bo_sox48]

Because it was a fearkill, or a kill out of respect for a player's skill and perceived ability to read the scumteam.

[bo_sox48]

The cold shot on Vecna D1 was done by either you or HR, that much I am confident in.

Well it wasn't me

Your back-and-forth theater with HR has me thinking that if he is scum, you're scum. So maybe it wasn't you, but if it was him you were there.

[Jamiet99uk]

The cold shot on Vecna D1 was done by either you or HR, that much I am confident in.

Well it wasn't me

Your back-and-forth theater with HR has me thinking that if he is scum, you're scum. So maybe it wasn't you, but if it was him you were there.

I'm town

[Jamiet99uk]

Bo_Sox are you going to fucking vote?

[kgray]

The cold shot on Vecna D1 was done by either you or HR, that much I am confident in.

Well it wasn't me

Your back-and-forth theater with HR has me thinking that if he is scum, you're scum. So maybe it wasn't you, but if it was him you were there.

But you listed Jamie above HR. Do you think HR is scum independently of Jamie?

I'm not convinced on Jamie and I'm not voting for him today, but I would vote for HR.

[bo_sox48]

Well it wasn't me

Your back-and-forth theater with HR has me thinking that if he is scum, you're scum. So maybe it wasn't you, but if it was him you were there.

But you listed Jamie above HR. Do you think HR is scum independently of Jamie?

I'm not convinced on Jamie and I'm not voting for him today, but I would vote for HR.

As I said, I think the likeliest team is Jamie/HR/summit.

[bo_sox48]

Bo_Sox are you going to fucking vote?

Is my vote for some reason going to decide where we coalesce? We're all voting as one today, and I've made my preferences clear enough.

[Jamiet99uk]

Bo_Sox are you going to fucking vote?

Is my vote for some reason going to decide where we coalesce? We're all voting as one today, and I've made my preferences clear enough.

It is a TIE and you have not voted.

Pay fucking attention.

[bo_sox48]

I'm well aware that it's tied. I'm not untying it.