MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[bozotheclown]

Bozo,

Do you recall Fox agreeing to, or making, such a suboptimal kill? I guess it's possible one could believe seth was a PR.

Since everybody wants Bob dead, and having seth and Bob dead helps progress the game along.

##vote bob
##end

I do not think it would be suboptimal for Foxcastle. The bloodhound is as good as the cop with only one mafia left, so the last mafia has to be concerned with that PR, and seth was a PR possibility that was suspicious of Foxcastle and might have chosen to scan him if he had been the cop or bloodhound.

[bozotheclown]

This post gave me a feeling HM could be the last mafia.

Well, like I said at the very beginning, don't let me get in the way of good town investigators by being a distraction. I'll bust my ass to try to find a case that suggests who that last goon is.

Barring that, if there's a lie detector power left to use, then I am VT and not the goon and not the PR.

Kill me today (Day whatever it is), but it will be a pure mis-kill.

Now where do we go from here?

You should know there is no lie detector left. Why would you claim you are not a PR when we are trying to keep our PRs hidden?

[Hamilton Brian]

[You should know there is no lie detector left. Why would you claim you are not a PR when we are trying to keep our PRs hidden?

Didn’t realize LD was done.

Thought I read a post where PRs were supposed to claim.

My misunderstanding.

[Hamilton Brian]

Don’t like the “End” vote right now. Ending days when we have investigation time is scummy.

[Durga]

I am actual SO drunk guys. So drunk. But let's end on someone!!!!!!

[summit_fever]

Don’t like the “End” vote right now. Ending days when we have investigation time is scummy.

Why do you think it's scummy?

[summit_fever]

I am actual SO drunk guys. So drunk. But let's end on someone!!!!!!

I'm surprised more didn't want to end on bob. Guess it's Friday/Saturday.

[bozotheclown]

I believe our biggest threat remaining this game is a potential warlock. The remaining mafia needs a number of mis-kills to win, and a witch would need our 3 remaining PRs to die, and would have no way to kill them once we get the last mafia. However, the longer the game goes on, the better chance a warlock would have of correctly picking each day-kill. Therefore, I think we need to keep our PRs hidden as long as possible to make it more difficult to guess the day-kill. If a PR is at risk of getting day-killed they should of course claim in time to divert the kill, but otherwise claiming just reduces the pool that the warlock would have to choose from.

[bozotheclown]

I am actual SO drunk guys. So drunk. But let's end on someone!!!!!!

I'm surprised more didn't want to end on bob. Guess it's Friday/Saturday.

Hammering Bob before he has a chance to post would be a bad idea, we do not want to risk killing any PRs without them having a chance to claim.

[summit_fever]

I am actual SO drunk guys. So drunk. But let's end on someone!!!!!!

I'm surprised more didn't want to end on bob. Guess it's Friday/Saturday.

Hammering Bob before he has a chance to post would be a bad idea, we do not want to risk killing any PRs without them having a chance to claim.

Seems reasonable.

##unend

[summit_fever]

##vote foxcastle

[TrPrado]

That NK doesn't really make sense. Was Seth on to something, and getting too close to figuring something out?

Blows up all the tunneling I did on him. Apologies post mortem, Seth. You were innocent, and I was wrong.

This post gave me a feeling HM could be the last mafia.

I'm really feeling this particular coin flip

[Hamilton Brian]

I am actual SO drunk guys. So drunk. But let's end on someone!!!!!!

Yeah, but don't hammer end the day. Although I am hammered right now. F'in mafia and the drink are not good companopns.

[Hamilton Brian]

Why do you think it's scummy?

It cuts down the investigation time if we're so disposed. The obvious example of scum pushing the end vote was one of the more recent games. I think Damos put it out there, and Durga was one of the final "yeas."

To a simpleton like myself, it makes me think the person initiating it is scum.

[TrPrado]

##VOTE RDR I am thinking this is the right play. His minimal interaction with bo and his wagon and his last post trying to shade HB for that post on top of previous concerns make me think he's the remaining scum.

[Hamilton Brian]

I'm really feeling this particular coin flip

Which makes me think, if you've been paying any attention, you're trying to hide something or you're just flailing. Now that your 3P thesis is obsolete, what else do you have?

It was an amanzing pieve of literature, and compelling, but it wasn't solid-state.

What the hell are you hiding from TrP? What are your secrests?


And again, flip me...so what. Another VT. And it benefits town how?

Unless TrP is not town...

[Hamilton Brian]

##VOTE RDR I am thinking this is the right play. His minimal interaction with bo and his wagon and his last post trying to shade HB for that post on top of previous concerns make me think he's the remaining scum.

It’s an interesting play. Some have called Rdr out for being Mafia, but I never got more than a null read. I’ve bought in to their IRL problems.

[Hamilton Brian]

And I think I misspoke. I didn’t mean to address IRL problems. Sorry RdR. I am a inconsiderate numbskull.

[dargorygel]

VOTE COUNT 5.1
BobMcMob (2) worcej,
Rdrivera2005 (2) durga, prado
Foxcastle (2) bozo, summit

The present vote is a three way tie. So no one is in immediate danger.
There is 1/6 votes to end.
Not voted
Emc, damo, foxy, HB, BobMcBob

Posting requirements not met
Emc, foxy, BobMcBob, damo

There are five claimants of inebriation.
But there are still 1 Day, and 17 hours, and 50 minutes remaining in this day.

[BobMcBob]

Okay what the heck happened with that kill last night? Is mafia mocking us or something? Or just YOLO'ing it? I'd guess the latter but who knows. I'm gonna read back up on Fox and rivera at some point to see who I think we should flip today.