MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[bozotheclown]

Hey, happy to kill Bob because this seems like a kill he'd do. Ok with ending on Bob, rdr or bozo tbh. I'll need more convincing on fox.

Worcej, I do not think anyone on the scum team (other than maybe you) who is in this game would be so spiteful as to play for town loss vs their own win. So I really think this kill only makes sense as PR hunting. Glad our PR's are so well hidden, although I think I have a good idea of the remaining two so I'm hoping 3p is not witch.

Woah, bozo?

Yep. If we wanna go for 3p kill I agree with bosux that he's the best candidate.

Although, you... You would be an incredible 3p candidate. But that'll be easier to figure out once the last scum is dead. So I would not daykill you before then

Why do you think I am 3P? You said you couldn't be the 3P because you have not been afraid of the NK. Do you think I have been playing to avoid the NK?

[Durga]

Woah, bozo?

Yep. If we wanna go for 3p kill I agree with bosux that he's the best candidate.

Although, you... You would be an incredible 3p candidate. But that'll be easier to figure out once the last scum is dead. So I would not daykill you before then

Why do you think I am 3P? You said you couldn't be the 3P because you have not been afraid of the NK. Do you think I have been playing to avoid the NK?

Who do you think it is then? Summit?

And yeah, you're in that sweet sweet range of not too scummy and not too townie, not too active and not too lurker. I love it. I admire it. I want to be it.

[summit_fever]

Yep. If we wanna go for 3p kill I agree with bosux that he's the best candidate.

Although, you... You would be an incredible 3p candidate. But that'll be easier to figure out once the last scum is dead. So I would not daykill you before then

Why do you think I am 3P? You said you couldn't be the 3P because you have not been afraid of the NK. Do you think I have been playing to avoid the NK?

Who do you think it is then? Summit?

And yeah, you're in that sweet sweet range of not too scummy and not too townie, not too active and not too lurker. I love it. I admire it. I want to be it.

I gave my opinion.. I think worcej is less likely to be 3P since the self-voting was done in a way that ran a large risk he'd be the kill. Though, worcej might have reasoned that was playing to the wincon given how scumread he was.

It could be anybody.

[summit_fever]

Why do you think I am 3P? You said you couldn't be the 3P because you have not been afraid of the NK. Do you think I have been playing to avoid the NK?

Who do you think it is then? Summit?

And yeah, you're in that sweet sweet range of not too scummy and not too townie, not too active and not too lurker. I love it. I admire it. I want to be it.

I gave my opinion.. I think worcej is less likely to be 3P since the self-voting was done in a way that ran a large risk he'd be the kill. Though, worcej might have reasoned that was playing to the wincon given how scumread he was.

It could be anybody.

-We need to hit the last mafioso.

-Then PR's claim.

-Then we start killing, and we have to do this with some randomness thrown in.

-If multiple PRs are still alive they should be valid kill targets to us.

-If we face fakeclaims then we are dealing with the witch. Perhaps the warlock might try fakeclaiming one of the claimed PRs trying to get them killed while prediciting it the night before.. This would only work if they have two successful kills.

[bozotheclown]

Yep. If we wanna go for 3p kill I agree with bosux that he's the best candidate.

Although, you... You would be an incredible 3p candidate. But that'll be easier to figure out once the last scum is dead. So I would not daykill you before then

Why do you think I am 3P? You said you couldn't be the 3P because you have not been afraid of the NK. Do you think I have been playing to avoid the NK?

Who do you think it is then? Summit?

And yeah, you're in that sweet sweet range of not too scummy and not too townie, not too active and not too lurker. I love it. I admire it. I want to be it.

I would rule out worcej because of his self vote at EOD, and I will buy your argument why it is not you. Any of emc, Bob, Hamilton, rdrivera, summit, or TrPrado seem possible, or Foxcastle if I am wrong about him being the last mafia. summit does not seem particularly likely since he has been fairly active. Hamilton stand out to me as a possibility because of staying of the wagons D1-D3. Bob has done that also, but he has not been online at EOD.

[Hamilton Brian]

That NK doesn't really make sense. Was Seth on to something, and getting too close to figuring something out?

Blows up all the tunneling I did on him. Apologies post mortem, Seth. You were innocent, and I was wrong.

[summit_fever]

Who do you think it is then? Summit?

And yeah, you're in that sweet sweet range of not too scummy and not too townie, not too active and not too lurker. I love it. I admire it. I want to be it.

I gave my opinion.. I think worcej is less likely to be 3P since the self-voting was done in a way that ran a large risk he'd be the kill. Though, worcej might have reasoned that was playing to the wincon given how scumread he was.

It could be anybody.

-We need to hit the last mafioso.

-Then PR's claim.

-Then we start killing, and we have to do this with some randomness thrown in.

-If multiple PRs are still alive they should be valid kill targets to us.

-If we face fakeclaims then we are dealing with the witch. Perhaps the warlock might try fakeclaiming one of the claimed PRs trying to get them killed while prediciting it the night before.. This would only work if they have two successful kills.

Whoops. We need to have three PRs alive to have the ability to sacrifice one. So if we can get the last mafioso today, we are able to increase the pool we are killing in which will make it less likely the warlock would be able to correctly predict the daykill

[TrPrado]

Which is weirder, seth being the kill or me being roleblocked a second night in a row?

[TrPrado]

That NK doesn't really make sense. Was Seth on to something, and getting too close to figuring something out?

Blows up all the tunneling I did on him. Apologies post mortem, Seth. You were innocent, and I was wrong.

Figuring what out?

[worcej]

Yep. If we wanna go for 3p kill I agree with bosux that he's the best candidate.

Although, you... You would be an incredible 3p candidate. But that'll be easier to figure out once the last scum is dead. So I would not daykill you before then

Why do you think I am 3P? You said you couldn't be the 3P because you have not been afraid of the NK. Do you think I have been playing to avoid the NK?

Who do you think it is then? Summit?

And yeah, you're in that sweet sweet range of not too scummy and not too townie, not too active and not too lurker. I love it. I admire it. I want to be it.

Post less and you'll be closer lol

[worcej]

Which is weirder, seth being the kill or me being roleblocked a second night in a row?

Both are equally weird.

[summit_fever]

Bozo,

Do you recall Fox agreeing to, or making, such a suboptimal kill? I guess it's possible one could believe seth was a PR.

Since everybody wants Bob dead, and having seth and Bob dead helps progress the game along.

##vote bob
##end

[Hamilton Brian]

Which is weirder, seth being the kill or me being roleblocked a second night in a row?

Stop! Really?

[Hamilton Brian]

That NK doesn't really make sense. Was Seth on to something, and getting too close to figuring something out?

Blows up all the tunneling I did on him. Apologies post mortem, Seth. You were innocent, and I was wrong.

Figuring what out?

Well, I don't know. Who the last mafia is? Who the 3P is? That's the "what" I was referring to.

[Hamilton Brian]

I do come back to Worcej's theory. I like it. I like the info Damo's VCA presented. I feel like mine can fit in there somewhere.

Can't expand more; have company over.

[TrPrado]

That NK doesn't really make sense. Was Seth on to something, and getting too close to figuring something out?

Blows up all the tunneling I did on him. Apologies post mortem, Seth. You were innocent, and I was wrong.

Figuring what out?

Well, I don't know. Who the last mafia is? Who the 3P is? That's the "what" I was referring to.

Then allow me to rephrase, is there something about seth's posts that leads you to believe this could be the reason he was killed?

[rdrivera2005]

That NK doesn't really make sense. Was Seth on to something, and getting too close to figuring something out?

Blows up all the tunneling I did on him. Apologies post mortem, Seth. You were innocent, and I was wrong.

This post gave me a feeling HM could be the last mafia.

[rdrivera2005]

That NK doesn't really make sense. Was Seth on to something, and getting too close to figuring something out?

Blows up all the tunneling I did on him. Apologies post mortem, Seth. You were innocent, and I was wrong.

This post gave me a feeling HM could be the last mafia.

HB, I meant.

[Hamilton Brian]

Then allow me to rephrase, is there something about seth's posts that leads you to believe this could be the reason he was killed?

I don’t know. Why do you think he was killed? Do you infer anything in his posts?

[Hamilton Brian]

This post gave me a feeling HM could be the last mafia.

Well, like I said at the very beginning, don't let me get in the way of good town investigators by being a distraction. I'll bust my ass to try to find a case that suggests who that last goon is.

Barring that, if there's a lie detector power left to use, then I am VT and not the goon and not the PR.

Kill me today (Day whatever it is), but it will be a pure mis-kill.

Now where do we go from here?