MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[bozotheclown]

Okay, reading d2 I'm actually changing my mind on bo I think. I think some of his reactions have been non-mafia. And he has demonstrated a lot of thinking, and while I don't agree with that thinking always, it is hard to think when you're scum.

On the other hand, tr is deliberately ignoring me in the least townie way possible. And his interactions with ghug do not scream town tr to me.

What do people think of this team?
ghug-chaqa-trprado-yoyo/bob

Because this is what I'm leaning towards. I know I've switched it up like a million times but this is where I'm currently at. If I'm wrong about one of these (and if I am, I think it's yoyo/bob - because i'm starting to think its just a red herring bc of how much everyone is pushing this slot) then rdr or bo is likely it.

I don't know who 3p is but I'm fairly sure bozo, summit, worcej, emc, and fuck even seth probably are not mafia.

Thankfully we have two PRs + damo left. It feels like this is our game to lose.

If TrPrado is mafia, that was a very convincing bus of Chaqa. I reviewed 2 games where TrPrado was mafia, M36 and M50, and he only voted for his teammates when they were confirmed guilty with one exception, D7 of M36, where he did place a tie breaking vote on his teammate, although it was well before EOD.

[Durga]

Okay, reading d2 I'm actually changing my mind on bo I think. I think some of his reactions have been non-mafia. And he has demonstrated a lot of thinking, and while I don't agree with that thinking always, it is hard to think when you're scum.

On the other hand, tr is deliberately ignoring me in the least townie way possible. And his interactions with ghug do not scream town tr to me.

What do people think of this team?
ghug-chaqa-trprado-yoyo/bob

Because this is what I'm leaning towards. I know I've switched it up like a million times but this is where I'm currently at. If I'm wrong about one of these (and if I am, I think it's yoyo/bob - because i'm starting to think its just a red herring bc of how much everyone is pushing this slot) then rdr or bo is likely it.

I don't know who 3p is but I'm fairly sure bozo, summit, worcej, emc, and fuck even seth probably are not mafia.

Thankfully we have two PRs + damo left. It feels like this is our game to lose.

If TrPrado is mafia, that was a very convincing bus of Chaqa. I reviewed 2 games where TrPrado was mafia, M36 and M50, and he only voted for his teammates when they were confirmed guilty with one exception, D7 of M36, where he did place a tie breaking vote on his teammate, although it was well before EOD.

Do you have links to his town games?

[bozotheclown]

I do not understand the emc votes, I do not see anything about his D2 interaction with Chaqa that makes me suspect emc is mafia.

[bozotheclown]

Okay, reading d2 I'm actually changing my mind on bo I think. I think some of his reactions have been non-mafia. And he has demonstrated a lot of thinking, and while I don't agree with that thinking always, it is hard to think when you're scum.

On the other hand, tr is deliberately ignoring me in the least townie way possible. And his interactions with ghug do not scream town tr to me.

What do people think of this team?
ghug-chaqa-trprado-yoyo/bob

Because this is what I'm leaning towards. I know I've switched it up like a million times but this is where I'm currently at. If I'm wrong about one of these (and if I am, I think it's yoyo/bob - because i'm starting to think its just a red herring bc of how much everyone is pushing this slot) then rdr or bo is likely it.

I don't know who 3p is but I'm fairly sure bozo, summit, worcej, emc, and fuck even seth probably are not mafia.

Thankfully we have two PRs + damo left. It feels like this is our game to lose.

If TrPrado is mafia, that was a very convincing bus of Chaqa. I reviewed 2 games where TrPrado was mafia, M36 and M50, and he only voted for his teammates when they were confirmed guilty with one exception, D7 of M36, where he did place a tie breaking vote on his teammate, although it was well before EOD.

Do you have links to his town games?

The "Updated Mafia Scoresheet" link on the bot is a good way to find which games he was town.

[bozotheclown]

If TrPrado is mafia, that was a very convincing bus of Chaqa. I reviewed 2 games where TrPrado was mafia, M36 and M50, and he only voted for his teammates when they were confirmed guilty with one exception, D7 of M36, where he did place a tie breaking vote on his teammate, although it was well before EOD.

Do you have links to his town games?

The "Updated Mafia Scoresheet" link on the bot is a good way to find which games he was town.

M33, M46, and M48 appear to be his latest town games.

[Durga]

Do you have links to his town games?

The "Updated Mafia Scoresheet" link on the bot is a good way to find which games he was town.

M33, M46, and M48 appear to be his latest town games.

Okay.. soo....

In M48 he was miskilled d1 for shit posting and joking around a bunch

m46 was an ACE ATTORNEY THEMED GAME!! that apparently I was in.

Lmao, also TrPrado in m46:

I haven't played in like a year. Please stop discussing games that have happened since then.

Hey you're not very meek in that game Tr

[Durga]

Man went from

"Don't discuss games I wasn't in" to "I didn't know if I was allowed to claim roleblock anymore uwu ~~~"

[Durga]

Sorry, but I absolutely do not buy that town!Prado does not know whether it is appropriate to claim rb or not because he hasn't played for a year, and for some reason, could not make that determination by d4 of the game he is in, that he presumably has read the thread of, without someone else telling him it was ok.

[Hamilton Brian]

I feel like I am full tilt to go on a TrP wagon.

[Hamilton Brian]

Man went from

"Don't discuss games I wasn't in" to "I didn't know if I was allowed to claim roleblock anymore uwu ~~~"

That's the kind of shit I get accused for doing. Not scum indicative, but...are you really that thick? Because when you're that thick, you're anti=town.

[Durga]

Man went from

"Don't discuss games I wasn't in" to "I didn't know if I was allowed to claim roleblock anymore uwu ~~~"

That's the kind of shit I get accused for doing. Not scum indicative, but...are you really that thick? Because when you're that thick, you're anti=town.

I assume you are talking to trprado and not me

[TrPrado]

Man went from

"Don't discuss games I wasn't in" to "I didn't know if I was allowed to claim roleblock anymore uwu ~~~"

That's the kind of shit I get accused for doing. Not scum indicative, but...are you really that thick? Because when you're that thick, you're anti=town.

I assume you are talking to trprado and not me

He isn't

[Durga]

That's the kind of shit I get accused for doing. Not scum indicative, but...are you really that thick? Because when you're that thick, you're anti=town.

I assume you are talking to trprado and not me

He isn't

What am I being thick about then? Why are you TRPRADO, responding to this and not all my other accusations? How is this the most emotion you can muster in response to me ripping at you

[TrPrado]

I assume you are talking to trprado and not me

He isn't

What am I being thick about then? Why are you TRPRADO, responding to this and not all my other accusations? How is this the most emotion you can muster in response to me ripping at you

lol what am I supposed to say? You're just throwing the word meek around like it really means something here and saying the posts I make and questions I ask while catching up are just echoing you. You want me to fight? Why would I do that? I've explained myself honestly and you can take it or leave it.

[rdrivera2005]

Okay, reading d2 I'm actually changing my mind on bo I think. I think some of his reactions have been non-mafia. And he has demonstrated a lot of thinking, and while I don't agree with that thinking always, it is hard to think when you're scum.

On the other hand, tr is deliberately ignoring me in the least townie way possible. And his interactions with ghug do not scream town tr to me.

What do people think of this team?
ghug-chaqa-trprado-yoyo/bob

Because this is what I'm leaning towards. I know I've switched it up like a million times but this is where I'm currently at. If I'm wrong about one of these (and if I am, I think it's yoyo/bob - because i'm starting to think its just a red herring bc of how much everyone is pushing this slot) then rdr or bo is likely it.

I don't know who 3p is but I'm fairly sure bozo, summit, worcej, emc, and fuck even seth probably are not mafia.

Thankfully we have two PRs + damo left. It feels like this is our game to lose.

If TrPrado is mafia, that was a very convincing bus of Chaqa. I reviewed 2 games where TrPrado was mafia, M36 and M50, and he only voted for his teammates when they were confirmed guilty with one exception, D7 of M36, where he did place a tie breaking vote on his teammate, although it was well before EOD.

How people have time to dig old games? I can't even re-read this one.

I think we should keep things simple now. If we fail to hit scum in the next days we can start conspiracy theories, but now we should look to the most simple explanations

I don't think there is scum on the first Chaqa voters. It was a fast movement closer to EOD, I don't think scum will join it so fast, at least before Flash claim. Emc could be an exception, but his vote with 4 minutes to go didn't look scum bus.

Worst looking votes are mine and Worcej. But I think both are town. So I think scum is between who vote Chaqa after Flash claim and who stayed away (like Ghug). So, we should be targeting between Bozo, seth, Fox, Bob and Bo. You already know my preference.

[Hamilton Brian]

Man went from

"Don't discuss games I wasn't in" to "I didn't know if I was allowed to claim roleblock anymore uwu ~~~"

That's the kind of shit I get accused for doing. Not scum indicative, but...are you really that thick? Because when you're that thick, you're anti=town.

I assume you are talking to trprado and not me

There has been shit I've said, contradictory, and the "are you really that thick" that I've referred to myself. I think TrP is projecting.

[Durga]

He isn't

What am I being thick about then? Why are you TRPRADO, responding to this and not all my other accusations? How is this the most emotion you can muster in response to me ripping at you

lol what am I supposed to say? You're just throwing the word meek around like it really means something here and saying the posts I make and questions I ask while catching up are just echoing you. You want me to fight? Why would I do that? I've explained myself honestly and you can take it or leave it.

Your vibe is really different from M46 it feels. Your presence is kind of... bland here. You're playing overly cautious this game, and that doesn't seem right for either being town or your specific town meta.

I can't understand why you would think, as town, that you should first ask about the roleblock before you claim it. You explanation of you haven't played for a year seems weak, and it's also d4 - how have you not refreshed yourself on town play yet if you are town?

You haven't really pushed cases, you haven't done anything investigative, you HAVE been insanely repetitive (not just of me, but others, notably calling out rdr for all caps after fox already did, and tons of other posts like this), you even acknowledged you're like this by saying you're working on some original thought, and you never posted it, and now you're claiming you can't post it yet for god knows what reason.

And yes, I do want you to fight. If you're town you should obviously engage with me to prove me wrong.

[Durga]

That's the kind of shit I get accused for doing. Not scum indicative, but...are you really that thick? Because when you're that thick, you're anti=town.

I assume you are talking to trprado and not me

There has been shit I've said, contradictory, and the "are you really that thick" that I've referred to myself. I think TrP is projecting.

I'm still confused, you're calling yourself anti-town?

[Durga]

Okay, reading d2 I'm actually changing my mind on bo I think. I think some of his reactions have been non-mafia. And he has demonstrated a lot of thinking, and while I don't agree with that thinking always, it is hard to think when you're scum.

On the other hand, tr is deliberately ignoring me in the least townie way possible. And his interactions with ghug do not scream town tr to me.

What do people think of this team?
ghug-chaqa-trprado-yoyo/bob

Because this is what I'm leaning towards. I know I've switched it up like a million times but this is where I'm currently at. If I'm wrong about one of these (and if I am, I think it's yoyo/bob - because i'm starting to think its just a red herring bc of how much everyone is pushing this slot) then rdr or bo is likely it.

I don't know who 3p is but I'm fairly sure bozo, summit, worcej, emc, and fuck even seth probably are not mafia.

Thankfully we have two PRs + damo left. It feels like this is our game to lose.

If TrPrado is mafia, that was a very convincing bus of Chaqa. I reviewed 2 games where TrPrado was mafia, M36 and M50, and he only voted for his teammates when they were confirmed guilty with one exception, D7 of M36, where he did place a tie breaking vote on his teammate, although it was well before EOD.

How people have time to dig old games? I can't even re-read this one.

I think we should keep things simple now. If we fail to hit scum in the next days we can start conspiracy theories, but now we should look to the most simple explanations

I don't think there is scum on the first Chaqa voters. It was a fast movement closer to EOD, I don't think scum will join it so fast, at least before Flash claim. Emc could be an exception, but his vote with 4 minutes to go didn't look scum bus.

Worst looking votes are mine and Worcej. But I think both are town. So I think scum is between who vote Chaqa after Flash claim and who stayed away (like Ghug). So, we should be targeting between Bozo, seth, Fox, Bob and Bo. You already know my preference.

This is a scummy post. Why can't you re-read this one? Why should we keep it simple? You want some more mis-kills before I find your scum buddy or something? That makes no sense. Why would town!rdr want to keep it *simple* and why are you dismissing my push on prado as a conspiracy theory? Is there something you disagree with? If so, can you tell me what specifically, and also tell me why you think he's townie? Beyond him voting Chaqa before going to do the dishes?

I also thought you weren't really around so how do you know how fast the movement was? Why is EMC the bus exception, but you're not willing to entertain trprado? Who do you actually scum read, you pretty much listed everyone but the known PR, and me and summit and prado - except prado has done nothing to deserve that.

Since when do all scum just never bus? Bozo pointed out that Tr has broken the vote to put his scum partner in the lead with a bus before. Is it so out of question that someone voted Chaqa, and then came back surprised that Chaqa was actually killed?

[Durga]

God I could have done so many productive things in life in the time I've spent playing this damn game. Good night.