MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[BobMcBob]

Okay what the heck happened while I was asleep? I mean I'm not completely sad at the result, because on the bright side I didn't die, but seriously, you guys couldn't manage to actually kill someone?

[Vecna]

its literally your fault for having that name bob

[bo_sox48]

Putting worce aside since he's settled enough (if we need to check he's scum then wagoning and offing bob would do it, if the theory of rational play holds true)

I'm really not sure how Prado is so amazingly...null. He just like, doesn't register for me lmao

Did he register for you earlier in the game? I had him as a high townread on D1 into D2 but since then I agree with you.

[damo666]

Okay what the heck happened while I was asleep? I mean I'm not completely sad at the result, because on the bright side I didn't die, but seriously, you guys couldn't manage to actually kill someone?

You hardly helped did you?

[BobMcBob]

its literally your fault for having that name bob

No it's your fault for all voting for bob instead of bobmcbob. I didn't do anything that couldn't have been stopped by people typing literally 5 extra letters.

Okay what the heck happened while I was asleep? I mean I'm not completely sad at the result, because on the bright side I didn't die, but seriously, you guys couldn't manage to actually kill someone?

You hardly helped did you?

And of course I didn't help, I find it hard to vote in my sleep. I let the EoD play out by itself without my presence, as usual, and trusted that whatever happened it would've either been good or I would've deserved it for poor play.

[worcej]

I'm pretty bummed you're still here to waste our time man

Likewise.

[worcej]

its literally your fault for having that name bob

No it's your fault for all voting for bob instead of bobmcbob. I didn't do anything that couldn't have been stopped by people typing literally 5 extra letters.

Okay what the heck happened while I was asleep? I mean I'm not completely sad at the result, because on the bright side I didn't die, but seriously, you guys couldn't manage to actually kill someone?

You hardly helped did you?

And of course I didn't help, I find it hard to vote in my sleep. I let the EoD play out by itself without my presence, as usual, and trusted that whatever happened it would've either been good or I would've deserved it for poor play.

TBF, it's the bot's fault for not registering 'bob' as a nickname for you and people, including myself, explicitly counting on that as a representation of votes.

However, there is some definite issue with your vote. It was bad when you know 2 scum were voting him at one point with myself.

[BobMcBob]

Yeah I realised that when I woke up this morning as well, but it's not like the wagon was gonna get any traction anyway. I just really needed somewhere to sit my vote that wasn't you or me, and that was the one I settled on after completely forgetting VCA is a thing.

[BobMcBob]

Durga's EoD votes were just plain unhelpful. I don't think they're scummy per se but switching back and forth so many times actually made it more likely to tie because it confused so many people and didn't allow them a steady state to base their vote on, which was probably another major factor in causing the tie.

[worcej]

FWIW - this is my views currently:

Confirmed Town: damo (RIP after this phase)

Town lean: bozo, Vecna, rdr, Bob, HB

Null: Prado, summit, seth, bo_

Scum lean: emc

Scum: Durga, Fox

[TrPrado]

Lmao that was awesome to read

Anything useful? How do you feel about seth's lashing out around EOD?

[Hamilton Brian]

@worcej, I’d like you to consider this piece that I came across yesterday when I was doing my in-depth Durga read (D1 to N2) because I swore up and down she was scummy.

At one point, and I don’t remember when exactly, she pled with whomever had a PR role to focus on Ghug that night. Would a scum player gamble on outing their partner when there were still 4 in the game? I don’t think so...that’s a big risk to try to assume a townread.

Now, Durga as 3P? That is something to consider.

[bo_sox48]

Lmao that was awesome to read

Anything useful? How do you feel about seth's lashing out around EOD?

As someone who is so insistent on finding something useful, I'm surprised you didn't read any of my other posts where I actually said something about EOD.

I feel seth is town, as I've made clear. I don't know what he was thinking quoting Durga at EOD, though. That is definitely weird.

[TrPrado]

Oh sorry, I guess we have different definitions of useful.

[TrPrado]

Are you planning on pushing worcej for another day?

[bo_sox48]

I'm not expecting to survive the night, but if I do, it's an option.

[Durga]

I'm not expecting to survive the night, but if I do, it's an option.

You're... not? Why?

[worcej]

@worcej, I’d like you to consider this piece that I came across yesterday when I was doing my in-depth Durga read (D1 to N2) because I swore up and down she was scummy.

At one point, and I don’t remember when exactly, she pled with whomever had a PR role to focus on Ghug that night. Would a scum player gamble on outing their partner when there were still 4 in the game? I don’t think so...that’s a big risk to try to assume a townread.

Now, Durga as 3P? That is something to consider.

With the uncertainty on what PRs we actually did get in the game rolls, I don't put much weight in this and if she did have here other teammates at this time, it isn't actually risky.

[bo_sox48]

I'm not expecting to survive the night, but if I do, it's an option.

You're... not? Why?

Fearkill N1, PR N2, no PRs out in the open to kill N3. I'm not the most townread player but I'm not a likely lynch any time soon, assuming town knows what's good for them. Maybe they'll wait until later, but I don't know. I'm going to try to give two good cases by EON regardless.

[TrPrado]

So the list of people who did not read EON2 is bo and Bob