MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[Foxcastle]

I am fine to continue voting for Durga. I think too-cool-for-school Durga (e.g., not reading the setup, not reading the thread, etc) is somewhat scum indicative.

We should not be policy killing SarahK at this point. Day 1 is too important for that, we need a referendum on an actual player who might be scum.

I would potentially vote for Worcej or Ghug over Durga at this point, though. I think Worcej is playing too nicely. Bozo is obviously town to me—he's focusing way too much on small inconsistencies, so he will probably end up tunneling on a townie.

Defends Sarah/chaqa slot here.

Again, you are blatantly misreading this.

##VOTE SETH

[Hamilton Brian]

I think that’s a nice cherry to pick, but I look at policy killing the same way I look at votes on early end days. I think Fox was right to defend that slot, especially D1.

##vote Seth

[seth24c]

I think Day 1 was TvT and that scum mostly weren't driving any outcome. The Bismarck wagon helped them, and there may be scum there, but I think town is perfectly capable of getting to yesterday's EOD unassisted.

I think the scum team is in: Worcej, Flash, TrPrado, Rdrivera, and Summit. After that, I'd look at Yoyo and Durga. Maybe HR.

Damo is not mafia. Vecna is not mafia. Bozo is not mafia. Seth is not mafia. Hamilton is not mafia. Bo is not mafia.

(Again, if there is a lie detector, "X is not Mafia" statements potentially give them a town clear in addition to catching mafia. This is the actual statement we should be making people type out, but I doubt town has the tolerance for another round of that.)

If I were the WD, I would target Vecna tonight.
If I were the Desperado, I would target Worcej.

After saying he felt ghug was acting scummy several times earlier ghug doesn’t make fox’s reads list on either scum or town side. I think this is because my lest second swing at the end of day one put the spotlight on the bunny voters and ghug was one of them. Thus why fox tries to act like it was a totally town driven flip. Fox is definitely scum. ##vote fox

[e.m.c^42]

Is worcej here? I kind of want to pull his taunt closer to EOD and see how he reacts, but if he isn't going to be here there's not much point.

Who cares, ##vote worcej until I finish the last few middle pages (and so Jamie stops stressing lmao)

[seth24c]

seth, did you get a chance to re-read bo?

I did, feeling better about him now. I feel certain after reading fox that he is scum.

[seth24c]

seth, did you get a chance to re-read bo?

I did, feeling better about him now. I feel certain after reading fox that he is scum.

Sorry if this wasn’t clear. I feel better about bo, I think he is town. I am certain that fox is scum.

[TrPrado]

We probably should kill Worcej today, since it looks to me like today is TvT with a setup for a "Worcej was saved!" redux tomorrow. But if we did that, we'd just be killing Bob tomorrow.

Don’t think this makes sense in context of how many people are on Bob and how many people have said that they’re having doubts about worcej being scum after his performance today. He and Seth are not kills I want to do today.

[TrPrado]

That’s me checking in, gotta go clean

[Durga]

Why are people so certain of things that they should not be certain of if they're town

[Foxcastle]

I think Day 1 was TvT and that scum mostly weren't driving any outcome. The Bismarck wagon helped them, and there may be scum there, but I think town is perfectly capable of getting to yesterday's EOD unassisted.

I think the scum team is in: Worcej, Flash, TrPrado, Rdrivera, and Summit. After that, I'd look at Yoyo and Durga. Maybe HR.

Damo is not mafia. Vecna is not mafia. Bozo is not mafia. Seth is not mafia. Hamilton is not mafia. Bo is not mafia.

(Again, if there is a lie detector, "X is not Mafia" statements potentially give them a town clear in addition to catching mafia. This is the actual statement we should be making people type out, but I doubt town has the tolerance for another round of that.)

If I were the WD, I would target Vecna tonight.
If I were the Desperado, I would target Worcej.

After saying he felt ghug was acting scummy several times earlier ghug doesn’t make fox’s reads list on either scum or town side. I think this is because my lest second swing at the end of day one put the spotlight on the bunny voters and ghug was one of them. Thus why fox tries to act like it was a totally town driven flip. Fox is definitely scum. ##vote fox

Wow. I never said that about ghug. I refer to Ghug 3 times on day 1.

1. "I think it’s possible, just not sure I think it’s likely." [That ghug and vecna are scum together]

2. "I would potentially vote for Worcej or Ghug over Durga at this point"

3. "Ghug is on my list because I have a hard time reading him (even having just been scum with him), and something says I want to scumread him." (And then more about ghug and vecna not being scum together.)

My Day 1 iso is here for whoever wants to actually read it.

[Foxcastle]

Seth, why are you misconstruing a whole host of things I said?

[rdrivera2005]

Do you even have scumreads? What have you done this game to advance town's victory? Because I can't find it.

I gave reads all the time. Yoyo/Bob are the top one. You are my top one to 3P. Last scum is hard, it could be a deep one or someone that is coasting like Bozo, Seth or emc.

Speaking of coasting, your top read is the same one you've had from Day 1 when it based on a handful of posts before Yoyo disappeared?

Bob didn't do a thing to improve my read on this slot.

[Foxcastle]

I gave reads all the time. Yoyo/Bob are the top one. You are my top one to 3P. Last scum is hard, it could be a deep one or someone that is coasting like Bozo, Seth or emc.

Speaking of coasting, your top read is the same one you've had from Day 1 when it based on a handful of posts before Yoyo disappeared?

Bob didn't do a thing to improve my read on this slot.

Okay, you scumread Bob. Who else? Who are your town reads?

[summit_fever]

##vote seth

[seth24c]

After reading I feel much better about bo and RDR. Much worse about fox. Durga is my next person to read.

[bo_sox48]

Why are we flipping seth >_>

[e.m.c^42]

Actually, foxC is here, let's poke atcha. ##vote foxc

[rdrivera2005]

Speaking of coasting, your top read is the same one you've had from Day 1 when it based on a handful of posts before Yoyo disappeared?

Bob didn't do a thing to improve my read on this slot.

Okay, you scumread Bob. Who else? Who are your town reads?

Already answered on my scum reads.

Town: Vecna, Durga, summit, Prado, HB and Bo. Damo obviously.

[bo_sox48]

I guess he's only ahead 1 vote, but still... I'm lost on that one

[Jamiet99uk]

​Vote Count 3.8

Seth24c (4) Durga, Foxcastle, Hamilton Brian, Summit_fever
BobMcBob (3) Rdrivera, Damo666, TrPrado
Worcej (2) bozotheclown, bo_sox
Foxcastle (2) Worcej, EMC
Bo_sox48 (2) TrPrado, Seth24c
Hamilton Brian (1) BobMcBob

No-Kill (1) Vecna

They're building a gallows for SETH as it stands.

18 MINUTES remain in Day Three.