MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[bo_sox48]

I honestly kinda wanna day kill Seth

Any reason other than because I said not to?

no, my world revolves around you ~

As it should <3

[bo_sox48]

But seriously, please lynch me now - too many of you do not believe I am town and it's better to get rid of me now so that you can stop wasting time looking back at me.

This kinda reads as some sort of scum reverse psychology shit, but it's inane enough that it seems more likely for notscum!worcej to do this.

That would make it reverse reverse psychology, which is just psychology

[Durga]

Any reason other than because I said not to?

no, my world revolves around you ~

As it should <3

agh gross don't heart me again

[Vecna]

Ayy, I'm back, something unexpected came up and ate my time. Might be a bit laggy with interspersed replies, but here I go

finally. was already starting to get scared u were gonna eat a modkill

You have a strange thing for emc but aight

I do. Youd understand this post if u were here the two games he got mofkilled as a pr lol (one of those actually allowed us to win as scum). Also, I like emc, and hes the real reason I went after chaqa

[e.m.c^42]

But seriously, please lynch me now - too many of you do not believe I am town and it's better to get rid of me now so that you can stop wasting time looking back at me.

This kinda reads as some sort of scum reverse psychology shit, but it's inane enough that it seems more likely for notscum!worcej to do this.

but, that being said, I really haven't been able to find the case on Durga that worce has been talking about all this time?

[TrPrado]

I don’t really remember and don’t know if I’ll have time to read but was anyone suspicious of flash before D2?

[Foxcastle]

I don't have a solid case on Rdrivera, but that's why I'm voting him. Scum win when they can be unobtrusive, which is how I'd describe Rdrivera's play. Maybe not in tone, but in action. On Day 1 and 2 he was pushing Yoyo based on very little and not exploring other options.

I think there's at least one scum on the Damo and Yoyo wagons from Day 1, and TrPrado and Rdrivera are the two that I'm not townreading. On Day 2, he opened early with a "Ghug is probably scum" and then tried to take credit shortly after the flip with "I told ghug was scum."

Does anyone know if town Rdrivera is likely to go along with various mechanical schemes (e.g., "I win when mafia and third party are eliminated," the hypo claims) without question? Because he did here, and I'd expect that even as scum space themselves out through that process, some would be quick to join. Rdrivera was one of the early posts of the "I win when" statement (after Bunny, Summit, and Damo), and an early hypo claimer on N1 (after Bozo, Flash, Worcej).

It's not much to go on, but I think town is often wrong in trying to hang players for their inconsistencies and flailings, while scum who are more careful about avoiding those kind of slips get by.

[Hamilton Brian]

I honestly kinda wanna day kill Seth

ive just put him back in my solid town bin. His explenations all make sense. He's way too cool and theres not even a hint of "oh shit they caught me" for the matthew thing.

try reread his entire day1 on the bot. the progression there seems very genuine to me - esp with his explenations.

I’m definitely leaving the option open after today. The explanations were pretty good; does scum put that much effort into contriving? Maybe. Given there’s two left, it’s in their interest.

[Vecna]

the only weird thing is that the joking, inquisitiveness imto ghug, the sensible answers...it all fits so poorly with the sudden hesitation around the bismarck wagon and the panicked reaponse after that.

[summit_fever]

I don't have a solid case on Rdrivera, but that's why I'm voting him. Scum win when they can be unobtrusive, which is how I'd describe Rdrivera's play. Maybe not in tone, but in action. On Day 1 and 2 he was pushing Yoyo based on very little and not exploring other options.

I think there's at least one scum on the Damo and Yoyo wagons from Day 1, and TrPrado and Rdrivera are the two that I'm not townreading. On Day 2, he opened early with a "Ghug is probably scum" and then tried to take credit shortly after the flip with "I told ghug was scum."

Does anyone know if town Rdrivera is likely to go along with various mechanical schemes (e.g., "I win when mafia and third party are eliminated," the hypo claims) without question? Because he did here, and I'd expect that even as scum space themselves out through that process, some would be quick to join. Rdrivera was one of the early posts of the "I win when" statement (after Bunny, Summit, and Damo), and an early hypo claimer on N1 (after Bozo, Flash, Worcej).

It's not much to go on, but I think town is often wrong in trying to hang players for their inconsistencies and flailings, while scum who are more careful about avoiding those kind of slips get by.

In M56 Rivera expressed dislike of massclaims but thought they might favour town and went along with it without too much fuss....so pragmatic about it?

[e.m.c^42]

EMC is here, and I want to know if he thinks worcej is mafia.

I would like to think he would play...better if he was scum, lol. I recall not seeing him as scummy at all when he played as scum.

[e.m.c^42]

You know what, reading backwards might be faster lmao

[Jamiet99uk]

​Vote Count 3.6

BobMcBob (5) Hamilton, Rdrivera, Damo666, Durga, Summit_fever
Worcej (2) bozotheclown, bo_sox
Bo_sox48 (2) TrPrado, Seth24c
Hamilton Brian (1) BobMcBob
Foxcastle (1) Worcej
Rdrivera2005 (1) Foxcastle

No-Kill (1) Vecna

Currently BobMcBob is set to hang.

56 MINUTES remain in Day Three.

EMC must cast a vote.

[TrPrado]

I think we should save Seth until tomorrow, I have something I want to look into but don’t have time now

##VOTE BOBMCBOB

He and Yoyo have both seemed like they’re more concerned about optics and seeming useful than actually solving the game.

[e.m.c^42]

I don't see the Matthew joke from seth as alignment indicative, but it is a bit odd he didn't really continue to make flavour jokes or references.

[Durga]

I would desperado seth and WD Durga

Worcej was this a "I want to die by WDing Durga" or did you want to save me after d1 and have changed your mind

[e.m.c^42]

Same here, not buying that what chaqa said about HB was a scum slip.

LOL great call Seth.

You're willing to toot your own horn here, but not on calling your shot with ghug?

Huh, summit missed the sarcasm. He's usually pretty sharp about small details, isn't he?

[Foxcastle]

We probably should kill Worcej today, since it looks to me like today is TvT with a setup for a "Worcej was saved!" redux tomorrow. But if we did that, we'd just be killing Bob tomorrow.

[Foxcastle]

We probably should kill Worcej today, since it looks to me like today is TvT with a setup for a "Worcej was saved!" redux tomorrow. But if we did that, we'd just be killing Bob tomorrow.

Rdrivera, Summit, and TrPrado now my top scum reads.

[summit_fever]

We probably should kill Worcej today, since it looks to me like today is TvT with a setup for a "Worcej was saved!" redux tomorrow. But if we did that, we'd just be killing Bob tomorrow.

I think town vs town is likely. I'm just not sure what to do. Does anybody have strong feelings one way or the other on bozo?