MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[rdrivera2005]

Why are you picking a fight with someone way townier than you

I'm pretty sure he's the third party. He feigned ignorance of the witch role earlier in a way I don't think anyone at this stage would. I think it was fake. I'll find the post for you.

I think it's either him or Bob.

Bozo as a distant third.

[bo_sox48]

Why are you picking a fight with someone way townier than you

I'm pretty sure he's the third party. He feigned ignorance of the witch role earlier in a way I don't think anyone at this stage would. I think it was fake. I'll find the post for you.

I think it's either him or Bob.

If it's Bob, we shouldn't be worried about it lol

[rdrivera2005]

Why are you picking a fight with someone way townier than you

I don't agree with this statement.

You don't agree because he's tunnelling on you. And honestly, I haven't seen anything to call you townie either rdr. Usually I feel I can read you really well.

Nothing to do with me. I was comparing Fox and Bo.

And I haven't seen anything to call Fox townie.

And compare this bo with last game scum bo if you really think he is Mafia. I think he is town.

[Foxcastle]

##call GM
witch win conditions in the OP:
1. All of the Town and Mafia PRs are dead, and you remain alive.
OR
2. You have successfully gained control, at one point or another, of all of the Town and Mafia PRs (even if they subsequently died).
OR
3. You are the last person alive.

Since 4 PR's are dead and we only had 2 nightphases, is it correct to assume that the second win condition can never be achieved anymore? (aka the witch needs to control all -6- PR's, not just the living remaining ones?)

I suppose that's correct, yes, Vecna.

In response to this, I said " I thought there was a determination that the 3P's catch-PRs-to-win mechanic had been nixed by PR deaths?"

I see now that I misread point 1, though, thinking it was "all of the town and mafia are dead." Obviously that doesn't make sense.

[TrPrado]

Bo, why do I get the feeling you’re afraid of late surprise wagons?

[summit_fever]

I don't like the deadpan defence seth has put up. I think it's unlikely he forgot about that post, since it was in the first few posts he made as a new player. Those seem the most likely to stick in someone's mind for a while, especially when you're focuss

I don't like the vote on bo after saying he was going to re-read bo yet offered nothing for support.

I don't like either end of day seth has played. If seth is still around when this game gets deep don't ignore that post. Foxcastle got away with a doozy last game because people were willing to let the mistake go.

Nevertheless, worcej's defence just reads town to me. I'm happy with bob since this slot hasn't done anything since day 2 to make me feel more positive about it.

##vote BobMcBob

[Vecna]

Ayy, I'm back, something unexpected came up and ate my time. Might be a bit laggy with interspersed replies, but here I go

finally. was already starting to get scared u were gonna eat a modkill

[Foxcastle]

I don't like the deadpan defence seth has put up. I think it's unlikely he forgot about that post, since it was in the first few posts he made as a new player. Those seem the most likely to stick in someone's mind for a while, especially when you're focuss

I don't like the vote on bo after saying he was going to re-read bo yet offered nothing for support.

I don't like either end of day seth has played. If seth is still around when this game gets deep don't ignore that post. Foxcastle got away with a doozy last game because people were willing to let the mistake go.

Nevertheless, worcej's defence just reads town to me. I'm happy with bob since this slot hasn't done anything since day 2 to make me feel more positive about it.

##vote BobMcBob

Who's your second read after Bob? I've come around on Worcej, but the reaction to that with 1.5 hours to go should not be to to solidify the Bob wagon, but to make your second scumread the next competing wagon.

[Durga]

Ayy, I'm back, something unexpected came up and ate my time. Might be a bit laggy with interspersed replies, but here I go

finally. was already starting to get scared u were gonna eat a modkill

You have a strange thing for emc but aight

[Durga]

I honestly kinda wanna day kill Seth

[Vecna]

Your insight is stunning, Bo. How did you manage to conclude all that from just my last two posts where I say that I'm scumreading Rdrivera on a feeling and that he's been in my scumreads since Day 1???

Why are you playing this game if you don't want to play this game?

Why are you picking a fight with someone way townier than you

interesting. Fox was actually shaping up to be my preferred wagon for the day.

...and then he voted rdrivera and my interest was piqued.

[Durga]

Why are you playing this game if you don't want to play this game?

Why are you picking a fight with someone way townier than you

interesting. Fox was actually shaping up to be my preferred wagon for the day.

...and then he voted rdrivera and my interest was piqued.

Really? What? Why?

[Vecna]

I honestly kinda wanna day kill Seth

ive just put him back in my solid town bin. His explenations all make sense. He's way too cool and theres not even a hint of "oh shit they caught me" for the matthew thing.

try reread his entire day1 on the bot. the progression there seems very genuine to me - esp with his explenations.

[summit_fever]

I don't like the deadpan defence seth has put up. I think it's unlikely he forgot about that post, since it was in the first few posts he made as a new player. Those seem the most likely to stick in someone's mind for a while, especially when you're focuss

I don't like the vote on bo after saying he was going to re-read bo yet offered nothing for support.

I don't like either end of day seth has played. If seth is still around when this game gets deep don't ignore that post. Foxcastle got away with a doozy last game because people were willing to let the mistake go.

Nevertheless, worcej's defence just reads town to me. I'm happy with bob since this slot hasn't done anything since day 2 to make me feel more positive about it.

##vote BobMcBob

Who's your second read after Bob? I've come around on Worcej, but the reaction to that with 1.5 hours to go should not be to to solidify the Bob wagon, but to make your second scumread the next competing wagon.

I'm down to bob/bozo/seth/emc as possible mafia.

Bozo is tough because I'm concluding that you have to negative inference him to read him as mafia, and it feels like he's leaving a lot left unsaid.

[e.m.c^42]

Hey EMC, continue towntelling my buddy. I think youre probably firmly town, but your reads were scarily on point for the few posts you have done.

You pretty much only talked about Ghug and Chaqa (and Durga) and those first two now both flipped scum. Chaqa also had an unusual boner for you.

Now who's buttering ;)

but granted, it seems like not posting random shit has helped.

[bo_sox48]

Bo, why do I get the feeling you’re afraid of late surprise wagons?

Don't know, you must not know me very well if you think I'm not all about late surprise wagons.

[e.m.c^42]

@bozo

This has just about nothing to do with our current game, but since you aren't in the discord I can't just ping you. You have that mafia AI that you use (or have used previously) to help predict reads, yes? What are the chances that with GPT-3 you'll be able to have one that can generate posts as well as reads?

That is, assuming that your posts aren't already bot generated. Lol

That is a good idea, but my mafia AI was more theoretical. I think it was Squigs who had implemented something.

Alas, the dream of JMO playing mafia is gone.

[bo_sox48]

I honestly kinda wanna day kill Seth

Any reason other than because I said not to?

[e.m.c^42]

But seriously, please lynch me now - too many of you do not believe I am town and it's better to get rid of me now so that you can stop wasting time looking back at me.

This kinda reads as some sort of scum reverse psychology shit, but it's inane enough that it seems more likely for notscum!worcej to do this.

[Durga]

I honestly kinda wanna day kill Seth

Any reason other than because I said not to?

no, my world revolves around you ~