MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

That's an odd way to scumslip but I do think it's more likely than not a scumslip.

not liking this conclusion

It's odd to call a joke (whether the joke was made with knowledge or ignorance) a scumslip. No one has ever called it a scumslip.

[bo_sox48]

That's an odd way to scumslip but I do think it's more likely than not a scumslip.

not liking this conclusion

Then read two posts forward lol

[Foxcastle]

There's a lot of grasping at straws going on right now, I wouldn't take it personally.

I mean, he should take it personally. Rdrivera has been on my scumreads since Day 1 and has done nothing to get off them.

He's been on your scumreads since day 1 and all you have on him is a feeling?

Your insight is stunning, Bo. How did you manage to conclude all that from just my last two posts where I say that I'm scumreading Rdrivera on a feeling and that he's been in my scumreads since Day 1???

[bo_sox48]

Durga, your tunneling knows no bounds.

[Durga]

Durga, your tunneling knows no bounds.

It's because I have history with you.

[bo_sox48]

I mean, he should take it personally. Rdrivera has been on my scumreads since Day 1 and has done nothing to get off them.

He's been on your scumreads since day 1 and all you have on him is a feeling?

Your insight is stunning, Bo. How did you manage to conclude all that from just my last two posts where I say that I'm scumreading Rdrivera on a feeling and that he's been in my scumreads since Day 1???

Why are you playing this game if you don't want to play this game?

[rdrivera2005]

It's weird regardless, but he's referring to him as a role that he didn't have. I can buy that as a joke that coincidentally looks suspicious now, and thus I am presuming seth town.

if he called him scum lie detector it will be more understandable. Calling him Matthew is a really weird coincidence.

I disagree, calling him Matthew makes sense linguistically if you're trying to craft a joke instead of calling him "the lie detector." It's definitely better delivery, more subtlety to it.

Well, linguistically I don't have a clue on this and will accept your word on it.

[bo_sox48]

Durga, your tunneling knows no bounds.

It's because I have history with you.

I don't know what you're referring to but I haven't done anything wrong by you, and if you disagree then take it to one of the 50 places from a PM to a text message where you can privately discuss it with me.

[Durga]

He's been on your scumreads since day 1 and all you have on him is a feeling?

Your insight is stunning, Bo. How did you manage to conclude all that from just my last two posts where I say that I'm scumreading Rdrivera on a feeling and that he's been in my scumreads since Day 1???

Why are you playing this game if you don't want to play this game?

Why are you picking a fight with someone way townier than you

[Durga]

Durga, your tunneling knows no bounds.

It's because I have history with you.

I don't know what you're referring to but I haven't done anything wrong by you, and if you disagree then take it to one of the 50 places from a PM to a text message where you can privately discuss it with me.

Lmao this was a joke bo...

[Foxcastle]

That's not how this works, Fox.

How does it work, then?

I'll add to what I said before and maybe you can pick up on it. You don't get to absolve someone of having to explain and defend what they've done, what theories they have pushed, and how they have behaved because you think he's a bad player; that's not how this works.

If you think "bad town play" isn't how this place works, then I'm not sure I can help you.

[bo_sox48]

I probably need to go camping again because I legitimately cannot tell.

[TrPrado]

That's an odd way to scumslip but I do think it's more likely than not a scumslip.

not liking this conclusion

It's odd to call a joke (whether the joke was made with knowledge or ignorance) a scumslip. No one has ever called it a scumslip.

And now he’s defending it as a joke, because you know why shouldn’t we call things we haven’t read scum slips.

[Foxcastle]

He's been on your scumreads since day 1 and all you have on him is a feeling?

Your insight is stunning, Bo. How did you manage to conclude all that from just my last two posts where I say that I'm scumreading Rdrivera on a feeling and that he's been in my scumreads since Day 1???

Why are you playing this game if you don't want to play this game?

In what way am I not playing this game?

[bo_sox48]

Your insight is stunning, Bo. How did you manage to conclude all that from just my last two posts where I say that I'm scumreading Rdrivera on a feeling and that he's been in my scumreads since Day 1???

Why are you playing this game if you don't want to play this game?

Why are you picking a fight with someone way townier than you

I'm pretty sure he's the third party. He feigned ignorance of the witch role earlier in a way I don't think anyone at this stage would. I think it was fake. I'll find the post for you.

[rdrivera2005]

Your insight is stunning, Bo. How did you manage to conclude all that from just my last two posts where I say that I'm scumreading Rdrivera on a feeling and that he's been in my scumreads since Day 1???

Why are you playing this game if you don't want to play this game?

Why are you picking a fight with someone way townier than you

I don't agree with this statement.

[bo_sox48]

I thought there was a determination that the 3P's catch-PRs-to-win mechanic had been nixed by PR deaths?

Anyway, I'm close enough to caught up to ##VOTE WORCEJ

[Durga]

Why are you playing this game if you don't want to play this game?

Why are you picking a fight with someone way townier than you

I don't agree with this statement.

You don't agree because he's tunnelling on you. And honestly, I haven't seen anything to call you townie either rdr. Usually I feel I can read you really well.

[rdrivera2005]

Why are you playing this game if you don't want to play this game?

Why are you picking a fight with someone way townier than you

I'm pretty sure he's the third party. He feigned ignorance of the witch role earlier in a way I don't think anyone at this stage would. I think it was fake. I'll find the post for you.

I think it's either him or Bob.

[Foxcastle]

Why are you playing this game if you don't want to play this game?

Why are you picking a fight with someone way townier than you

I'm pretty sure he's the third party. He feigned ignorance of the witch role earlier in a way I don't think anyone at this stage would. I think it was fake. I'll find the post for you.

No, I was referring to this post below, which I had just been reading on my catch up.

##call GM
witch win conditions in the OP:
1. All of the Town and Mafia PRs are dead, and you remain alive.
OR
2. You have successfully gained control, at one point or another, of all of the Town and Mafia PRs (even if they subsequently died).
OR
3. You are the last person alive.

Since 4 PR's are dead and we only had 2 nightphases, is it correct to assume that the second win condition can never be achieved anymore? (aka the witch needs to control all -6- PR's, not just the living remaining ones?)

I suppose that's correct, yes, Vecna.