MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[bo_sox48]

I'm talking about this. He came up with this wild theory that Chaqa's teammates were bombarding him, and I suspect that theory stems from the fact that he knows none of Chaqa's teammates were bussing him early on. He wants to change that narrative.

##vote Hamilton Brian

I don't like flash's wagon and I don't like Chaqa's

I am pissed I didn't have network access or my cell phone until now.

In obvious new, that was a great role to lynch without having used his power. So I am incredibly happy with that result and once again realize my reading ability sucks.

This makes no sense

Yes it does - if Chaqa literally told his team to bus him because his RL situation is rough, I would think they would have no concerns doing it to build town cred

I don’t think this is a genuine sequence at all. First you distance yourself from the EOD wagons (which can be justified in some instances, but why here?), then you quickly go from being really bad at reading people to absolutely certain that Chaqa’s teammates bussed him - which you, as Chaqa’s hypothetical teammate, notably did not do.

[Vecna]

lol, snap

[summit_fever]

can you both explain why u think this looks bad?

You think it's just a joke? It's a 16-1 shot based on luck. Or someone got a lil cocky.

I probably shouldve checked that. matthew was ghugs flavour?

Yeah, though with the wrong role

[damo666]

can you both explain why u think this looks bad?

You think it's just a joke? It's a 16-1 shot based on luck. Or someone got a lil cocky.

I probably shouldve checked that. matthew was ghugs flavour?

[rdrivera2005]

##VOTE RDRIVERA

I don't have a good reason other than Rdrivera has been rubbing me the wrong way since Day 1.

I think I'm going to stop pushing Worcej. This is exactly what I end up berating town for when we lose: latching onto inconsistencies and little things that "look" scummy that are really just townies putting themselves out there. And him struggling against being killed strikes me as more inline with times it's happened when he's town (although I don't have a good counterexample of him facing a legit lynch as scum).

Rubbing me the wrong way is the best you can get?

[rdrivera2005]

That's true. I suppose I can accept it not being a scumslip since that wasn't actually his role. Fiiiiiiiine

Huh, isn't it even weirder that he used "Matthew" instead of calling him the lie detector?

It's weird regardless, but he's referring to him as a role that he didn't have. I can buy that as a joke that coincidentally looks suspicious now, and thus I am presuming seth town.

if he called him scum lie detector it will be more understandable. Calling him Matthew is a really weird coincidence.

[bo_sox48]

Rubbing me the wrong way is the best you can get?

There's a lot of grasping at straws going on right now, I wouldn't take it personally.

[Vecna]

Ghug are you voting me in an attempt to replicate your town game from last time or are you that obsessed with me

Doesn't he always vote for you D1?

Is this bozo defending ghug? It's hella weird given how much ghug was grilling bozo this page for being useless.

Do you have reads on anyone yet, Seth?

Still pretty neutral on most people at this point. Do you have a read on Venca?

Seth i'm sorry if you did this but can you explain your weird obsession with Vecna

I also believe I win when bunny's team is eliminated.

##vote bunny

Not a lie, maybe?

I started the seth investigation thinking it maybe was because he knew ghug was svum. he started that after bozo and i believe one other mentioned them thinking me and ghug were scum together.

[Foxcastle]

I'm talking about this. He came up with this wild theory that Chaqa's teammates were bombarding him, and I suspect that theory stems from the fact that he knows none of Chaqa's teammates were bussing him early on. He wants to change that narrative.

I agree that Chaqa's teammates were unlikely to be bussing him early on, but my thought on this is that Worcej is just convinced Durga is scum and trying to fit a theory to that.

[bo_sox48]

Huh, isn't it even weirder that he used "Matthew" instead of calling him the lie detector?

It's weird regardless, but he's referring to him as a role that he didn't have. I can buy that as a joke that coincidentally looks suspicious now, and thus I am presuming seth town.

if he called him scum lie detector it will be more understandable. Calling him Matthew is a really weird coincidence.

I disagree, calling him Matthew makes sense linguistically if you're trying to craft a joke instead of calling him "the lie detector." It's definitely better delivery, more subtlety to it.

[Foxcastle]

Rubbing me the wrong way is the best you can get?

There's a lot of grasping at straws going on right now, I wouldn't take it personally.

I mean, he should take it personally. Rdrivera has been on my scumreads since Day 1 and has done nothing to get off them.

[bo_sox48]

I'm talking about this. He came up with this wild theory that Chaqa's teammates were bombarding him, and I suspect that theory stems from the fact that he knows none of Chaqa's teammates were bussing him early on. He wants to change that narrative.

I agree that Chaqa's teammates were unlikely to be bussing him early on, but my thought on this is that Worcej is just convinced Durga is scum and trying to fit a theory to that.

That's not how this works, Fox.

[bo_sox48]

Rubbing me the wrong way is the best you can get?

There's a lot of grasping at straws going on right now, I wouldn't take it personally.

I mean, he should take it personally. Rdrivera has been on my scumreads since Day 1 and has done nothing to get off them.

He's been on your scumreads since day 1 and all you have on him is a feeling?

[damo666]

Huh, isn't it even weirder that he used "Matthew" instead of calling him the lie detector?

It's weird regardless, but he's referring to him as a role that he didn't have. I can buy that as a joke that coincidentally looks suspicious now, and thus I am presuming seth town.

if he called him scum lie detector it will be more understandable. Calling him Matthew is a really weird coincidence.

But Matthew was the name of the possible Mafia lie detector. It makes perfect sense for Seth to use 'Matthew' to taunt ghug.

[Durga]

I'm talking about this. He came up with this wild theory that Chaqa's teammates were bombarding him, and I suspect that theory stems from the fact that he knows none of Chaqa's teammates were bussing him early on. He wants to change that narrative.

I agree that Chaqa's teammates were unlikely to be bussing him early on, but my thought on this is that Worcej is just convinced Durga is scum and trying to fit a theory to that.

That's not how this works, Fox.

I actually think worcej has done this before as town to me though

[Foxcastle]

I'm talking about this. He came up with this wild theory that Chaqa's teammates were bombarding him, and I suspect that theory stems from the fact that he knows none of Chaqa's teammates were bussing him early on. He wants to change that narrative.

I agree that Chaqa's teammates were unlikely to be bussing him early on, but my thought on this is that Worcej is just convinced Durga is scum and trying to fit a theory to that.

That's not how this works, Fox.

How does it work, then?

[Vecna]

That's an odd way to scumslip but I do think it's more likely than not a scumslip.

not liking this conclusion

[rdrivera2005]

Rubbing me the wrong way is the best you can get?

There's a lot of grasping at straws going on right now, I wouldn't take it personally.

I don't take things personally unless people start to question my integrity.

[e.m.c^42]

Ayy, I'm back, something unexpected came up and ate my time. Might be a bit laggy with interspersed replies, but here I go

[bo_sox48]

I agree that Chaqa's teammates were unlikely to be bussing him early on, but my thought on this is that Worcej is just convinced Durga is scum and trying to fit a theory to that.

That's not how this works, Fox.

How does it work, then?

I'll add to what I said before and maybe you can pick up on it. You don't get to absolve someone of having to explain and defend what they've done, what theories they have pushed, and how they have behaved because you think he's a bad player; that's not how this works.