MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[Vecna]

What do you think of Rdrivera Durga?

He had some reads D2 that make quite a bit of sense. He did do his thing where he pointed at ghugscum D2 (without voting though).

Is he town here, or did he just do his classic "bus without committing" move?

[Durga]

What do you think of Rdrivera Durga?

He had some reads D2 that make quite a bit of sense. He did do his thing where he pointed at ghugscum D2 (without voting though).

Is he town here, or did he just do his classic "bus without committing" move?

Honestly my gut says town but my mind says don't be fooled so easily.

[Durga]

Bo has still not addressed his fear of me

[Hamilton Brian]

Guess im doing a great job pissing everyone off this game. Everyone seems so angry

I'm not angry.

Noticed the shared suspicion of Fox you have with Worcej. That contrasts with Damo's view.

Why might you think there's better kills today than worcej and bob?

[Durga]

The more I think about it the less it seems like worcej is scum. What kind of insane bold ass play would that be.

[Hamilton Brian]

@vecna, at one point earlier you mentioned "strands" connecting Seth and EMC. You brushed it off as probably nonsense, but do you have any particulars, even if you think they're off-course?

[Durga]

Seth had such a strong d1 and it totally tapered off, so definitely worth looking into

[Hamilton Brian]

The more I think about it the less it seems like worcej is scum. What kind of insane bold ass play would that be.

Do you think the claim of VT was a careless mistake born of frustration or calculated?

[rdrivera2005]

I get that it annoys you Rdrivera, but at the same time, you were here during EoD this time. You were arguing against the Chaqa wagon, then said he was suspicious after all, but vanished for 11 minutes. Then you suddenly pop in with 1 minute to go and vote him.

So whats the story. You waited at work for 48 minutes longer to play mafia, but then with 11 mins to EoD you leave, to pull into a gas station just in time to vote Chaqa?

Because...you know, it sounds kinda odd? Especially in combination with the way you talked and moved in regards to the chaqa wagon?

You can't read?

I work until 30 minutes to EOD. My last post with 14 minutes to EOD was when I get to my car (after leaving work, I have to close the floor, bring the key to a box to be cleaned for next day, go to parking building to get my car usually on 5th or 6th floor). I drove until close to EOD and parked the car because I saw the vote movement on bot (yes, I was using cell while driving, sue me) and want to see what was happening. Anything else you want to know about my life?

I am not engaging with you (or anyone) about this again and in fact I will not engage with you anymore as I want the game to keep civil and in the front page.

I have no interest in calling you a liar, or debating this. This sounds completely realistic, and I know youre one of those people that is usually very sincere about his real life. However, you also gotta understand we have to try to sort the people that were not looking great around this wagon.

So why didnt you vote Chaqa straight away when u stated he was hella suspicious for suddenly popping back in? You stated he was probably better than a coinflip at that point?

My vote on Flash look scummy, this is something I can agree and can't do anything about it.

About Vhaqa he was a coin flip to me, I found his come back scummy, but it wasn't enough to get a vote, specially when I was leaving.

Look from the motivation POV. Why I will shadow a teammate and not buss him after I already told I was leaving? Scum at that point either stayed away like Ghug or bussed Chaqa. I think staying away is the most likely until the claim.

[Durga]

The more I think about it the less it seems like worcej is scum. What kind of insane bold ass play would that be.

Do you think the claim of VT was a careless mistake born of frustration or calculated?

I think if he's town it's his shitty ego getting in the way again. It seems to get in the way for most things. I have no idea why he plays this game since he's made 0 effort to investigate or figure out what's happening. I feel like he's town because an explanation for why he 100 percent scum reads me is that his ego is warped that he can't fathom that my scum reads were actually correct so the only truth can be that I'm scum.

[Hamilton Brian]

Trying to understand some motivation here.
Player A puts vote on player B who is PR.
PR claims.
At very last moment, Player A shifts vote off B, lands on somewhat runaway wagon (Player C who flips scum) and not a competing, but not runaway, wagon.

If player A is town, why land on player C?

If player A is scum, why land on C?

Just wondering if it's nothing, or something.

[BobMcBob]

Okay, so I finished reading it and I'm back with a grand total of zero new opinions. Looks like the one important thing I missed was the rather embarassing mistake with damo. So I'm just going to ##vote hamiltonbrian, my case on him is just the same as it was last time I made it, go look up the post if you want.

[damo666]

The description for that role says the predictions must be made at night, so I do not think it was possible to have a prediction in for D1.

Yeah, you're right.

I dont understand this conclusion and dialogue.

My hypothesis was that HB couldn't be warlock because he failed to place a vote D1 but bozo correctly pointed out that warlock predictions are made at night so D1 voting irrelevant.

[damo666]

The more I think about it the less it seems like worcej is scum. What kind of insane bold ass play would that be.

I'm kind of worried about this. Strange play as scum but then strange play as town. I'm in a quandary.

I'm busy at the moment, if anyone has some spare time could they do a quick Seth ISO. He had a strong start but has slumped alarmingly.

[Durga]

Okay, so I finished reading it and I'm back with a grand total of zero new opinions. Looks like the one important thing I missed was the rather embarassing mistake with damo. So I'm just going to ##vote hamiltonbrian, my case on him is just the same as it was last time I made it, go look up the post if you want.

This is insanely lazy. Why would you end on the wagon that scum were on last day? HB would be a terrible kill

[damo666]

##Vote Seth

Basing that vote on:
a) the apology post where Seth claims they got nervous from all the talk about the Bis wagon;
b) claim to being overwhelmed at the vote and being the deciding vote (why should that matter?);
c) reiterating the feeling of being "overwhelmed" in several posts; the decision to put a vote on Bis to, and I'm paraphrasing, "bring them into the game." The multiple apologizing seems trying to stretch the appearance of town too far.
d) protesting; Paraphrasing again, "I am not scum."

##vote Seth

[damo666]

Okay, so I finished reading it and I'm back with a grand total of zero new opinions. Looks like the one important thing I missed was the rather embarassing mistake with damo. So I'm just going to ##vote hamiltonbrian, my case on him is just the same as it was last time I made it, go look up the post if you want.

This is insanely lazy. Why would you end on the wagon that scum were on last day? HB would be a terrible kill

+1

[Vecna]

@vecna, at one point earlier you mentioned "strands" connecting Seth and EMC. You brushed it off as probably nonsense, but do you have any particulars, even if you think they're off-course?

well, there was the oh so obvious "save" of the emc slot by seth, the fascination back and forth between chaqa and emc could semi-connect the four.

I had a few other reasons thought up when going to bed, but i forgot em again. it probably wasnt very usefull.

EMC should come back and show off his stuff some.more though.

[rdrivera2005]

Okay, so I finished reading it and I'm back with a grand total of zero new opinions. Looks like the one important thing I missed was the rather embarassing mistake with damo. So I'm just going to ##vote hamiltonbrian, my case on him is just the same as it was last time I made it, go look up the post if you want.

This is insanely lazy. Why would you end on the wagon that scum were on last day? HB would be a terrible kill

+1

+2

[Vecna]

The more I think about it the less it seems like worcej is scum. What kind of insane bold ass play would that be.

Do you think the claim of VT was a careless mistake born of frustration or calculated?

its either scum or town that wants to demonstrate their townyness by taking away the possibility of fakeclaiming and outing a pr in the process. Quite a clever play really, since even as a town pr you could use it to hide and divert suspicion if you do survive.