MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

Yeah if fox is scum he's 3p I think.

[worcej]

Really though? Chaqa asked for a bus and it went down in that way? This would explain his shitposting with an hour or two to go I guess...and durga was the first scum on the bus? She definitely pushed it in a way that nobody else did. Is this one of the reasons you think she's scum?

She may not have been the first scum on the bus. There is still the potential of Vecna and yourself if we are determining ‘first’

So you think that it is possible that with 30 minutes to go, and the top 4 wagons town, 2 of Vecna, summit, and Durga decided it would be a good time to bus a mafia PR? If so, why did ghug sit out the bus?

It may be what happened - you don't know any different unless you're scum yourself.

ghug sat out to probably distance himself. All we can do is hypothesis what happened.

[worcej]

I 100% think Durga is scum, but don't think anyone will agree with me at this point.

omg lmao you think 100% that i get chaqa lynched and tunnel on ghug when no one else was? as scum?

Why not. It is entirely possible.

[worcej]

She may not have been the first scum on the bus. There is still the potential of Vecna and yourself if we are determining ‘first’

So you think that it is possible that with 30 minutes to go, and the top 4 wagons town, 2 of Vecna, summit, and Durga decided it would be a good time to bus a mafia PR? If so, why did ghug sit out the bus?

I agree with you on theory, but how do you know the top 4 wagons are town?

A very good point here.

[worcej]

Okay - hold on. So, witch auto wins if our 2 PR's die right? So... We should kill for 3p? Not sure how to go about doing this

Yes, the witch auto wins and town and mafia both lose if all PRs are dead.

TBF - I think bozo is the 3P and not scum.

[worcej]

I agree with you on theory, but how do you know the top 4 wagons are town?

yeah wait what

Again, there are only 2 mafia left, so if worcej thinks the 2 remaining scum are in Vecna, summit, and Durga, he would have to think that none of the top 4 wagons were mafia.

Where did I say that the last two are in that pile of three?

Find it for me and directly quote it.

[Durga]

I 100% think Durga is scum, but don't think anyone will agree with me at this point.

omg lmao you think 100% that i get chaqa lynched and tunnel on ghug when no one else was? as scum?

Why not. It is entirely possible.

Possible = 100 percent? Get out of here worcej

[worcej]

I 100% think Durga is scum, but don't think anyone will agree with me at this point.

Do you have a case?

It's feel more than anything. Hard to have a concrete case given this game has had no real investigative results, but her comments about not knowing what is going on felt over the top each time. Now the ghug vs her could very easily have been scum theater and I consider her (and him) good enough to have put that performance on.

To be crystal clear - ghug was never a wagon, so I do not believe she had any cause of concern to do the theater. The scum team was definitely not expecting a desperado to hit one of them, especially not their last PR.

##vote Durga

[worcej]

omg lmao you think 100% that i get chaqa lynched and tunnel on ghug when no one else was? as scum?

Why not. It is entirely possible.

Possible = 100 percent? Get out of here worcej

I believe I've echoed my certainty in it with a vote on you.

[worcej]

I 100% think Durga is scum, but don't think anyone will agree with me at this point.

Do you have a case?

Two things
1. I'm a little pissed off that people are entertaining that I would bus two scum team members when everyone knows I don't bus. Stop wasting time. This is why y'all keep losing as town.

2. Put TrPrado on the 3rd party potential list. He's the perfect amount of null to be there.

Also, I hate 3ps. I just want to catch scum. This extra bullshit is so boring.

Your bus on ghug never had any momentum or votes to back it, so it wasn't a true bus.

[Durga]

I even asked anyone who had night actions to use them on ghug. Why would I be so shortsighted? This is actually insane. You target me every game even when it makes 0 sense. Frankly, it's annoying.

Now unlikely Chaqa I actually have a date so I'm logging off, someone else please grill worcej for me while he's actually here.

[worcej]

Okay - hold on. So, witch auto wins if our 2 PR's die right? So... We should kill for 3p? Not sure how to go about doing this

We have 3 PRs still alive. The mafia would lose also, so they should be motivated to keep damo alive since his power is used.

That would be a dumb mafia team - keeping a town clear alive just to avoid a 3p win makes the scum more likely to be hit.

[worcej]

I even asked anyone who had night actions to use them on ghug. Why would I be so shortsighted? This is actually insane. You target me every game even when it makes 0 sense. Frankly, it's annoying.

Now unlikely Chaqa I actually have a date so I'm logging off, someone else please grill worcej for me while he's actually here.

Have fun.

Your defensiveness seems unwarranted when you factor in the reality that no one listens to me.

And I don't always target you. That slot is reserved for damo lol...

[worcej]

Do you have a case?

Two things
1. I'm a little pissed off that people are entertaining that I would bus two scum team members when everyone knows I don't bus. Stop wasting time. This is why y'all keep losing as town.

2. Put TrPrado on the 3rd party potential list. He's the perfect amount of null to be there.

Also, I hate 3ps. I just want to catch scum. This extra bullshit is so boring.

I do not believe worcej would really think that.

You keep emphasizing that 'I don't bus' like I used to emphasize 'I don't fake claim'.

Nothing about that is substantial - what if you decided to overly bus this game to try to create distance?

[worcej]

That last post was aimed more at Durga than bozo...

[worcej]

I'd go worcej over flash and Chaqa at this point.

This seems to look good for worcej.

Could be scum distancing.

Just like what Durga has done as well.

[worcej]

Okay - hold on. So, witch auto wins if our 2 PR's die right? So... We should kill for 3p? Not sure how to go about doing this

best to kill the remaining mafia.

if both mafia are dead, theres no way for 3p to kill the Pr's

Maf should refrain from NKing me until 3p dead

I mean, I hope this happens. But it won't.

[worcej]

Damp - uh, did he even do anything so far? Most of his posts have been useless, less than 5 word long things with no relevance. I mean he says he'll try to solve later and I'm pretty sure that is his meta from what I hear, but at the moment he's just not doin' anything. I'm going to avoid making early conclusions, if he's still this useless in a couple of days time we can root him out then.
TrPrado - also exists. I don't know what to say, he had some good analysis I guess. He came at things from a pretty good angle and I like that so I'm gonna townlean him.

Why yes, 'damp' has done quite a thing if you paid attention to the game.

[worcej]

almost like he just saw the post from flash, noted he was a PR, and tried to copy it, without reading into any of the shit that actually went on in this game

Bob's lack of paying attention to the game makes me honestly town his slot.

[TrPrado]

I 100% think Durga is scum, but don't think anyone will agree with me at this point.

Do you have a case?

It's feel more than anything. Hard to have a concrete case given this game has had no real investigative results, but her comments about not knowing what is going on felt over the top each time. Now the ghug vs her could very easily have been scum theater and I consider her (and him) good enough to have put that performance on.

To be crystal clear - ghug was never a wagon, so I do not believe she had any cause of concern to do the theater. The scum team was definitely not expecting a desperado to hit one of them, especially not their last PR.

##vote Durga

Hard to have a case? What’s so hard about having a case? If you’re 100% absolutely certain how are you not going to be able to point to anything that is actually indicative of alignment?

Also, Durga, now that he’s answered I will say I wasn’t entertaining his theory I just wanted to see what his answer would look like.