MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

Okay - hold on. So, witch auto wins if our 2 PR's die right? So... We should kill for 3p? Not sure how to go about doing this

best to kill the remaining mafia.

if both mafia are dead, theres no way for 3p to kill the Pr's

Maf should refrain from NKing me until 3p dead

Yeah very true. I don't think mafia will want to use a nk on damo anyway. Sorry damo

[Durga]

I'm going to

##vote bo

[Durga]

I was re-reading D1 looking for who were against a policy lynch of Sarah and didn't mind Bismarck being a wagon: Summit and Fox.
Summit already addressed it and I think he is town.

Re-reading Fox D1 I just can't help feeling this was scum Fox. Fighting with Vecna and Durga, giving a weak scum read on Ghug and flying under the radar.

Could someone explain why most people are townreading Fox? I can't find any towny moments from him.

I thought his anger made him townie but maybe I'm wrong. I remember him as a more charming scum

[BobMcBob]

HB - I can see why he was one of the biggest wagons yesterday. He kind of felt awkward or helpful without being helpful for the majority of day 2. He also fixated on Seth a lot, which I just cannot get as Seth looks like a really strong town to me. I think I'd be down for a HB-sacrifice today if that's still an option.

Quick question HB, why did you see Seth as scum? I feel very much like he was an honest, helpful, active townsperson from what I read of him. Which part of behaviour makes (or made) you think otherwise?

[Durga]

It was in one of his big walls of text so I really had to look


I don't get it as an answer to the question worcej asked either. It's pretty clear he asked whether bo thought ghug shitposting at all was AI, but bo seemed to interpret it as anything WITHIN the shitposting that could be AI. Does that make sense? Is that how it reads to anyone else?

I read it the way bo_sox did. I think what Durga was saying is suspicious is that he said both their alignments could probably be determined by it, yet he apparently had no interest in making that determination.

Well, that too, but Durga had said that part herself. There's also the question of how do you get both from "ghug's flirting" and "ghug shitposting" which is a pretty one-sided characterization of the conversation.

Yeah I was wondering why he was being so offensive to ghug about it but totally ignored me who was doing more if not equal amounts of shit posting too.

[Durga]

And when I yelled at bo he didn't push back, but when ghug did I think they fought a bit? Bo are you scared of me??

[seth24c]

And when I yelled at bo he didn't push back, but when ghug did I think they fought a bit? Bo are you scared of me??

Bo has felt a little off to me, I don’t have time at the moment but I think he deserves a reread.

[BobMcBob]

I haven't actually gone over the iso yet but Vecna feels a little off this game from what I've seen so far. He hasn't been as assertive or dominant as usual. What's changed @vecna? Are you busy or tired or fed up with mafia, or did you just roll scum? (3p being the most likely scum type from his behaviour, but mafia is possible too)

[BobMcBob]

Come out and play emc. Contribute please. I know you're there.

[Jamiet99uk]

VOTE COUNT 3.1

worcej (2) - bozotheclown, summit_fever
Bo_Sox (1) - Durga

Worcej is scheduled to be hanged.

No other votes have been cast, so 11 people still need to vote.

29 hours and 57 minutes remain in Day Three.

[BobMcBob]

Lmao I somehow missed what happened with damo last night, can anyone else tell how immensely thorough my reading has been? I retract my read of damo from earlier but I do stand by my observation that he did next to nothing for the first two days, just my conclusion is totally moot now. (I forgot which roles could kill for town and then forgot to check and follow it up okay?)

[BobMcBob]

I'm a go bed now so bye I guess. Someone please take over in the useless ramblings department while I'm gone.

[Vecna]

I haven't actually gone over the iso yet but Vecna feels a little off this game from what I've seen so far. He hasn't been as assertive or dominant as usual. What's changed @vecna? Are you busy or tired or fed up with mafia, or did you just roll scum? (3p being the most likely scum type from his behaviour, but mafia is possible too)

Another one of these bullshit posts

[Vecna]

almost like he just saw the post from flash, noted he was a PR, and tried to copy it, without reading into any of the shit that actually went on in this game

[Vecna]

Also, who actually does not check on the EoN outcomes and what caused them? The only logical explanation for that that I can think of is it just being scum that assumed the night outcome would just be a dead towny and never actually read it.

[Durga]

I don't know he seems a bit out of it in general so I'm not exactly seeing it Vecna. What are your thoughts on bo?

[bozotheclown]

When? I don't remember you voting Ghug and neither the bot.

I was talking about N2.

How do you bus at night?

I suppose it depends on your definition of bussing, but ghug was one of my scum reads N2 based on the results of D2.

[bozotheclown]

yeah wait what

Again, there are only 2 mafia left, so if worcej thinks the 2 remaining scum are in Vecna, summit, and Durga, he would have to think that none of the top 4 wagons were mafia.

I really didn't thought Worcej was serious on this read. There is 0 chance two scum will buss the Executioner that way.
The only thing that refrain me a bit on voting Worcej if the fact Chaqa moved out of HB tp emc when Worcej wagon started. I don't see scum jumpimg out of the leading wagon when his buddy start to get traction.

I do not see any indication that worcej was not being serious.

Hamilton was already losing votes when Chaqa moved his vote, and Chaqa moved his vote off all of the wagons, so he may have just been keeping his options open.

[rdrivera2005]

almost like he just saw the post from flash, noted he was a PR, and tried to copy it, without reading into any of the shit that actually went on in this game

Do you want to flip this YoyoBob slot? I don't believe it's a town one (3P is what I am now thinking).

[rdrivera2005]

Again, there are only 2 mafia left, so if worcej thinks the 2 remaining scum are in Vecna, summit, and Durga, he would have to think that none of the top 4 wagons were mafia.

I really didn't thought Worcej was serious on this read. There is 0 chance two scum will buss the Executioner that way.
The only thing that refrain me a bit on voting Worcej if the fact Chaqa moved out of HB tp emc when Worcej wagon started. I don't see scum jumpimg out of the leading wagon when his buddy start to get traction.

I do not see any indication that worcej was not being serious.

Hamilton was already losing votes when Chaqa moved his vote, and Chaqa moved his vote off all of the wagons, so he may have just been keeping his options open.

It could be, but with Chaqa just leaving after the emc vote I have the feeling he wasn't worried with the wagons.